The already fragmented condition of IS in most universities means that with further reductions in undergraduate recruitment their positions will not improve and could deteriorate further. In the view of the authors, the strong candidates for survival and prosperity are SISTM at the UNSW and Business IS at the University of Sydney. The chasing pack is led by the Department of Information Systems at the UTS and the IS discipline at Wollongong, which face difficulties at the moment but do have the critical mass to move forward, if the way is clear. Postgraduate specialist programs remain strong at the UTS.
Research is characterised by almost no cross-institutional cooperation and little within institutions. The ‘changing of the guard’ at the UNSW and the University of Sydney could bring about revivals. The problem will be, however, to avoid the lost opportunities of the 1970s. New South Wales (and Sydney in particular) had at least two institutions with plenty of highly employable undergraduate students, the respect of the IT industry and other institutions, and proximity to a large part of the Australian IT industry for support and research opportunities, yet IS in the institutions failed to develop an identity or a presence. It can be argued that this was due partly to a premature desire to define a discipline. Elias (quoted in Ridley 2006) suggests that modelling low-status on high-status disciplines is bound to fail. The moves suggested by Ridley (2006) for establishing a discipline will, if pursued by individuals or specialised research groups, work against the establishment of a broadly supported discipline. Individual prestigious reputations are established at the expense of wide collaboration, and standard research methods and unique symbol systems are used to exclude rather than enrol. Information systems—and perhaps all new disciplines—defines itself by what it is not, particularly ‘not computer science’. It is easy for those outside a developing prestigious group to think ‘but that’s not really IS’. The drive for academic recognition, particularly in the current university research climate, can also damage relations with industry—relations that are vital to the identity of IS. The question is how can we build a ‘discipline that isn’t a discipline’?