Addendum: another perspective on the IS discipline in NSW universities

David Wilson, Faculty of Information Technology, University of Technology, Sydney

The ICT market in Australia is one of the largest in the world, rated in the top three in the Asia-Pacific and eleventh in the world (CeBit 2006). Australia’s expenditure on ICT is between 4.6 per cent (Australian Information Industry Association and federal government reports) and 6.4 per cent of GDP (CeBit 2006), placing Australia ahead of countries such as the United Kingdom, Canada, China and Japan. New South Wales represents a significant proportion of this market, as it is home to 76 per cent of Australia’s ICT regional headquarters and provides employment to more than 120 000 people—about 41 per cent of the Australian ICT total (NSW DSRD 2007). New South Wales accounts for 42 per cent of ICT businesses and 47 per cent of telecommunications services (NSW DSRD 2007). New South Wales leads all other Australian states and territories in ICT research capabilities, being the headquarters of five national centres of excellence in ICT-related research fields, two major national research facilities and three cooperative research centres, as well as accounting for 43 per cent of the business expenditure on ICT services research and development in Australia (NSW DSRD 2007).

The ICT industry is changing and exhibits a shift from a techno-centric focus with technology priorities to a business-centric focus with business priorities where client-facing capabilities allied with business and project management skills are critical (Abraham et al. 2006; Zwieg et al. 2006). This represents a shift from a technical computer science and software engineering focus to a business IS focus. Information systems professionals are now required to possess business domain knowledge and project management skills and to have the ability to work well with clients and colleagues to solve business problems; the emphasis is on the client-facing skills of analysis and design enhanced with good communication skills, functional area process knowledge and industry knowledge (Abraham et al. 2006). Information systems professionals will be versatile as they assume numerous new roles, assignments and experiences (Morello and Libman 2005). This view is supported by chief information officers (CIOs), who identify ineffective communication with IS as the top inhibitor of alignment between business and IS (Luftman et al. 2005). Zweig et al. (2006) identified that, in the past, technically skilled early career IS professionals transformed themselves into mid-career professionals with strong business and project management skills through experience gained over many years. In the twenty-first century, this change needs to be effected more rapidly and this will require changes in university curricula, career paths and the continued development and training of IS professionals. Zweig et al. (2006) conclude that, although the balance of technical, business and project management skills is unlikely to be found in a fresh undergraduate, CIOs want to hire graduates with foundation technical skills complemented by business knowledge and project skills and the ability to work closely with non-technical departments and users.

In summary, New South Wales occupies a prominent position in a significant industry sector that is experiencing a skills shortage, yet the prognosis in the NSW chapter of this book is generally one of doom and gloom. NSW IS university departments are well positioned to produce graduates with the business-centric focus where client-facing capabilities allied with business and project management skills are in demand, yet the numbers of applications and enrolments are, in general, falling. There appears to be no one simple answer for this, but possible reasons that have been advanced include:

Whatever the reason—and in reality all these factors might contribute to the issue—it is clear that IS (and ICT) has lost credibility. The Y2K ‘fizzer’, the dotcom bust, the trend towards offshoring and a poor understanding of the IS industry among the general public have all contributed to decreased interest in IS-related careers among young people. The immediate issue is to promote IS as an interesting and rewarding career option for young people and to return the discipline to being one of choice. NSW IS university departments can be in the vanguard of this recovery.