Ridley’s (2006) theoretical framework has been developed through a thematic study of IS and non-IS literature. Common components were identified and included in the framework, which was influenced by Whitley’s (1984) theory of the establishment of scientific fields. Essentially, Whitley proposed three conditions necessary for the formation of a new field:
mechanisms of control such as publication records and an ability to gain research funding
research skills and standards
a unique symbol set.
Ridley (2006) suggests that Whitley’s second and third conditions together comprise ‘a core body of knowledge’, and adds theory and an agreed set of topics as additional essential components. On this basis, she then constructs a two-tiered framework comprising mechanisms of control, a core body of knowledge, the impact of local contingencies and the degree of professionalism as the first level. The second level builds on the core body of knowledge drawn from Whitley and consists of research and teaching methods and standards, a unique symbol set, key research and teaching IS topics and laws, rules and evidenced guidelines. Table 7.1 provides an abridged version of Ridley’s own summary of this framework.
|
Level 1 component |
Level 2 component |
|---|---|
|
Mechanisms of control |
|
|
Core body of knowledge |
|
|
Research and teaching methods and standards |
|
|
Unique symbol set |
|
|
Key research and teaching IS topics |
|
|
Laws, rules and evidenced guidelines |
|
|
Impact of local contingencies |
|
|
Degree of professionalism |
Ridley (2006) believes this framework is sufficiently robust to accommodate future developments in IS and has tested it (successfully) against the inclusion of pragmatism into the IS literature. This characterisation framework forms the basis for the present chapter.
This study of IS in South Australia takes the form of a positivist case study (Yin 2003), based predominantly on interviews conducted with IS teaching staff at the University of South Australia and the University of Adelaide,[1] and enhanced by data drawn from internal and external sources. Case studies of this type frequently make use of a detailed case-study protocol; Australasian study team members developed such a protocol at the time of the original Australasian Journal of Information Systems (AJIS) special issue paper preparation to ensure consistency of data collection across the universities studied. Major objectives of this protocol were to facilitate:
comparability across the states
consistency across the individual state case studies
efficiency in the data-gathering process.
Data were collected by a combination of personal interviews and e-mail questionnaires, filled in by staff and returned to the authors for analysis and review. Existing documentary and archival material was also gathered to supplement the interview data and to provide some triangulation of observations.
Data gathered from interviews and questionnaires were then analysed using the Ridley framework, so that qualitative data collected from participants and quantitative data collated from other sources could be integrated more effectively (Dixon-Woods et al. 2005; Ridley 2006).
The discussion that follows was ‘weighted towards themes that appear to have a high level of explanatory value’, rather than reflecting how frequently the themes were reported (Dixon-Woods et al. 2005:47).
[1] A description of Flinders University is included in this chapter for the sake of completeness but, since IS does not exist as a school, department or even a discipline within a school at Flinders University, detailed data were not gathered from Flinders for this study.