Review of findings

It has been quite difficult to collect reliable data about the state of IS in South Australia and impossible to make any intrastate comparisons among the three local universities in the state. Only the UniSA has a significant IS discipline operating across the breadth of academic activity: IS teaching, scholarship and research.

The IS discipline at the UniSA has quite a long history in relative terms, as it was created at the time of the university’s own formation from its antecedent institutions in 1991. Although the IS discipline within the UniSA has been subject to organisational changes, it has remained an influencing discipline and, notwithstanding the cyclical oscillations of student demand for IT programs in general, it appears to have remained strong and to have held a high professional profile within the state throughout its history.

Although there is not sufficient evidence to support the contention that the IS discipline in South Australia is fully mature in the sense of Ridley’s (2006) framework, it clearly meets a number of her level-two criteria. There is strong evidence that a clear ‘core body of knowledge’ exists, albeit in the only university that claims an IS discipline; and academics in the discipline share a ‘unique symbol system’—another criterion of Ridley’s framework identifying the discipline as mature. Furthermore, the ‘key research and teaching of IS topics’ suggest a well-established discipline, with a recognised international profile.

Clearly, then, the IS discipline in South Australia meets some (but not all) of the criteria in Ridley’s framework, providing some evidence of the maturity of the IS discipline in South Australia, but raising a number of fascinating questions. The interviews with active IS discipline members have suggested that the state’s unique qualities—the focus on resource, agriculture and defence sectors; the lack of large companies to provide substantial graduate employment possibilities and to drive research in certain directions; and the lack of a single state minister responsible for ICT—have played a large part in South Australia’s unusually low level of academic interest in IS. The only other state similar to South Australia in terms of population and climate—Western Australia—has a significantly greater academic focus on the IS discipline, with four universities all offering directly competing IS degrees.

Although there is considerable debate about what constitutes, or what should constitute, the core content of IS, it is generally accepted that IS draws on a range of disciplines for its methods and research practices (Avison and Elliot 2006). While some see this as a weakness in the identity of IS, others view it as a strength in uniquely qualifying IS to ‘offer essential insights and perspectives’ into the ‘complex and fragmented emergence of IT artifacts’ and ‘their computational capabilities and cultural meanings’ (Orlikowski and Iacono 2001). It could well be that South Australia’s limited range of core foci for ICT provides the major explanation for this state’s unusual IS profile.