Aims of the study

This study aims to characterise the state of the IS academic discipline in the UTAS, and also contribute to a better understanding of the same discipline in universities throughout Australia. Consequently, the data gathered for the study will be analysed at three levels. Table 8.1 sets out the three levels.

Table 8.1 Three levels of analysis discussed in the study

Covered in this paper

Level

Scope

 

1

Descriptive analysis using quantitative and qualitative sources

 

2

Examines whether an inverse relationship exists between the impact of local contingencies on the discipline and the degree of professionalism

 

3

Cross-case analysis drawing on theoretical framework

The first level of analysis will be reported in this current chapter and provides a descriptive examination of IS at the UTAS from qualitative and quantitative sources. The second level of analysis will also be reported in this chapter, and aims to examine in the Tasmanian IS academic context the postulation contained within the theoretical framework that an inverse relationship exists between the impact of local contingencies on a discipline and its degree of professionalism.

At the third level of analysis, some of the data gathered for the current study will be utilised for a cross-case analysis, and reported elsewhere. The cross-case analysis will draw on the remainder of the theoretical framework, which contends that a discipline will establish over time with the development of mechanisms of control and a core body of knowledge. This component of the theoretical framework cannot be investigated in a single case, as cross-regional analysis is required on such issues as key IS research and teaching topics, and whether a unique symbol set exists for the discipline. Moreover, some Australian longitudinal data will be needed at this third level.

Consistent with the content of the other state reports, the following issues have been examined within Tasmanian IS academia:

Changes to the structural placement of the School of Information Systems at the UTAS were first proposed in 2006—for implementation in 2008—and involved a closer relationship between the IS and computing disciplines. Consequently, another aim of this chapter was to consider different perspectives of the relationship between the two disciplines, as provided by a senior academic from each discipline at the UTAS. A further aim of the chapter was to present vignettes of two academics who were influential on the IS discipline at the university in past years.