Methodology

The Tasmanian case study was based on a detailed case-study protocol developed by the Queensland study team members.

Before the two schools merged, an open-ended questionnaire was e-mailed as an attachment to the participants after piloting. Where a response had not arrived within the time frame indicated for the return of the questionnaire, contact was again made with the academic, either in person or by e-mail, to encourage them to respond.

Eight academics who were currently closely involved with IS at the UTAS, or who had been in the past, were approached to participate in the survey. Of these, five were currently involved in either IS teaching or research, or both, at the university in Information Systems. Of the remaining three academics, two were working as IS academics outside Tasmania, while the third was employed in an allied discipline elsewhere at the UTAS at the time the data were collected. Of the participants, four had been employed as a head of school or in a more senior position. The three participants no longer working with IS academics at the UTAS were known internationally in IS or an allied discipline. Although the author of this chapter was also a former member of the School of Information Systems at the UTAS, her views were not included in the data collection and care was taken to try to exclude them from the analysis. This was done by having another person trained in IS research methods categorise the data after they had been stripped of identifying characteristics, and, where the classification differed, agreement was reached after discussion.

The survey method was used as some of the participants were located in other states or nations. An interview was, however, conducted with one of the participants. Some of the responses took participants up to two hours to complete. Consequently, the survey and interview captured broad perceptions of the state of IS at the UTAS, as well as points of differentiation and distinctive characteristics of IS at that university. Existing statistical and archival material were also collated to supplement the data obtained from the participants, and to facilitate some degree of triangulation. After the chapter was written, the original participants were invited to comment on it. Five participants took up this invitation.

A thematic analysis process was followed, allowing the integration of the qualitative data collected from participants and the quantitative data collated from other sources (Dixon-Woods et al. 2005). Although thematic analysis can be data driven, in this study the themes were driven by those in the theoretical framework referred to earlier. The discussion reported in the findings section below was ‘weighted towards themes that appear to have a high level of explanatory value’, rather than reflecting how frequently the themes were reported (Dixon-Woods et al. 2005:47).

The text relating to each question was examined for themes arising from the framework. The themes, and issues arising from the themes, have been presented below, grouped into the five major categories set out earlier. Statistical and archival data have been incorporated into the discussion relating to the themes, where relevant. The discussion of the themes in the section below presents the findings of the descriptive examination of IS at the UTAS from qualitative and quantitative sources, and forms the first level of analysis for this study.

After discussion of the themes, two tables were prepared to analyse the data at the second level. The second-level analysis examines whether an inverse relationship exists between the impact of local contingencies on a discipline and its degree of professionalism, in the Tasmanian IS academic context. In order to do this, the impact of local contingencies on IS teaching and research at the UTAS, and its degree of professionalism, were each independently categorised by two researchers as high, medium or low. Consistent with the previous framework chapter, professionalism was regarded as having high task certainty, routinisation of activities and a clear division of labour. Where a discipline was not highly professionalised, however, the control of work process would be decentralised, with limited routinisation of tasks (Whitley 1984).

In addition to the data collected in the manner described above, a senior academic from the School of Information Systems at UTAS provided updated information in mid-2007 on the school’s research and teaching directions. Also, two senior academics were approached to comment on the merger of the schools of IS and Computing, and its implications, from their perspective. Two vignettes on senior academics, linked to IS at the UTAS in the past, were also solicited and included in this chapter.