The features of IS research at the UTAS are discussed below.
Although there was general recognition that the research output of school staff was relatively low, several participants identified that the contribution was skewed. The majority of publications were in national and international refereed conferences, with a limited number of quality journal publications. One participant no longer working at the UTAS saw an opportunity for researchers to target high-quality conferences and journals in order to obtain quality feedback. For this to happen it was identified that broadly accepted academic leadership and a unifying research culture would be required, enabling the development of research groups and the emergence of research strengths for the school.
One participant believed that in the late 1990s the school’s research focused on rigorous interpretive research methodologies. At that time, it produced a series of quality PhD theses, evidenced by comments from staff from other schools in Australia and the later success of some of those PhD graduates.
The school did not have a strong history of attracting Australian Research Council (ARC) Discovery funding. The majority of the research funding obtained by IS in recent years has come from external, national competitive grants from the Smart Internet and Sustainable Tourism collaborative research centres and ARC Linkage grants. A limited number of the school’s staff was involved in attracting these research funds. More recently, one staff member in particular had attracted considerable industry funding to the school, particularly in the area of e-health.
Small internal research grants have been made available by the Faculty of Business, while the university-wide Institutional Research Grants Scheme is designed to prepare staff for the future submission of ARC grants.
As teaching loads were high, participants perceived that pressure existed to push the balance away from research towards teaching. Some staff had a teaching and administrative load only, while several staff members had a 75–85 per cent research load. The majority of staff members were, however, expected to undertake teaching, research and administration.
Some participants perceived greater recognition was given for good teaching than for research at the university through processes such as teaching merit certificates, teaching development grants and evaluation of teaching and learning. At a faculty level, however, there has been a recent attempt to redress this through the introduction of research awards. Faculty funding is available to assist staff to travel to conferences, which needs to be combined with school professional development funding. A faculty scheme of seed funding to encourage a range of different forms of research was introduced several years ago. A comment was made that incentives for the conduct of quality research could be defined and implemented better. For example, the same participant perceived that highly productive research staff did not receive recognition or incentives through the distribution of research quantum income. The same participant considered that the Department of Education, Science and Training (DEST) point system was ineffective in challenging staff to undertake better research. The new approach of the federal government to research outcomes in Australian universities could, however, redress this situation.
Research and teaching targets for individual staff are set within the compulsory performance management scheme implemented at the UTAS. Promotion is linked to good research outcomes and, more recently, an alternative route to promotion has been introduced through the demonstration of quality teaching.
It was believed that active researchers in the school would attend on average one to two conferences a year. In the past, the Australasian Conference of Information Systems (ACIS) has been popular with staff and research students because it provides researchers with opportunities to network. One participant, however, commented that attendance at ACIS by school staff had declined in recent years. ICIS, ECIS, HICSS, GITMA, IRMA and other topic-specific national or regional conferences have been attended occasionally by at least one staff member, while health care and security conferences have been popular.
Finally, few comments were made on changes planned for research in the School of Information Systems in coming years. Associated with the relatively recent appointment of a Woolworths Chair in Information Systems at the school, several participants referred to a new focus on IT governance and business process management. This move was seen as having potential to benefit the school, and several comments related to a desire for the emergence of a collegial research culture. While a senior participant foreshadowed a limited research group culture for the future, based on the belief that it was not possible to ‘bureaucratise IS research’, another saw progress of the IS discipline at the UTAS as being linked to the future research performance of the school.