Analysis and findings: level two

Figure 3.2 of the theoretical framework guiding the study—and presented in an earlier chapter—postulated an inverse relationship between the impact of local contingencies on the IS discipline and its degree of professionalism.

The impact of local contingencies at the School of Information Systems at the UTAS was evaluated by categorising the level-one data relating to research and teaching issues, including the variation in both by centre, into high, medium or low impact. Non-local factors were omitted. Where the categorisation by the second researcher differed, discussion took place until agreement was reached. Qualitative and quantitative data were considered, where relevant. This analysis is presented in Table 8.4.

Overall, it can be seen from Table 8.4 that local contingencies had a low to medium impact on curriculum and teaching issues, while they had a high to medium impact on research issues. Research was influenced particularly by local factors, with no issues recorded in the low range and few in the medium range. An analysis of the extent of professionalism of the IS discipline at the UTAS follows.

The degree of professionalism for research and teaching issues at the School of Information Systems in Hobart was also evaluated using the level-one data, employing the same method used for the evaluation of the impact of local contingencies. Professionalism requires high task certainty, routinisation of activities and a clear division of labour. The analysis is set out in Table 8.5.

Table 8.4 Classification of the impact of local contingencies on research and curriculum/teaching

Area

High

Medium

Low

IS curriculum and teaching issues

Three-campus delivery of IS in Tasmania influenced by politicians;

Oracle taught because of its use in the Tasmanian government, the major employer of IS graduates

Funding pressures make adjusting staff profile to student demand difficult;

Role of course advisory committees, particularly for MIS degree;

Increased use of video-conferencing, WebCT for teaching at non-Hobart campuses;

Some variation in delivery to Shanghai and Fuzhou.

Teaching focus does not vary by campus;

Moderation undertaken across multiple campuses;

Team marking across campuses;

Single points of course development for each unit;

Very similar unit content across all centres;

Teaching fairly centralised in Hobart.

IS research issues

Research not controlled centrally;

Few common topics;

Early emphasis on electronic commerce (EC), influenced by Tasmanian EC Centre;

Some research involvement in Telstra Broadband Lab, enabled through funding from Senator Harradine;

IT sometimes dealt with locally by accountants; greater use of consultants and outsourcing;

Small size of state means easy access to supportive government agencies;

Limited large private sector and manufacturing organisations has emphasised SME and government research;

Limited research culture;

Appointment of Woolworths Chair in IS associated with political pressure on state government;

Limited PhD supervisors;

No research conducted in school centres outside Tasmania.

Common interest in electronic commerce in previous years; diverging justification for this provided;

Emphasis on interpretive methods, but positivist approaches used and taught;

Faculty influence on research topics and structure.

 

Table 8.5 suggests that IS curriculum and teaching activities had a high to medium level of professionalism at the UTAS, while research activities had a low to medium degree of professionalism.

Table 8.5 Classification of features of IS research and curriculum and teaching at the UTAS by degree of professionalism

Area

High

Medium

Low

IS curriculum and teaching issues

Relatively centralised location of staff in Hobart aids task certainty through opportunities for communication;

Moderation of teaching across campuses;

Similar teaching content across campuses;

High-quality flexible online support is an example of clear division of labour in this area;

Widespread use of workshops and case studies in teaching;

Range of mechanisms exists to promote good teaching;

Sequential delivery style used to develop student responsibility from Years 1–3;

Focus on management and strategy in teaching;

Four major teaching themes identified.

Staff performance management scheme sets teaching targets;

Little emphasis on service teaching means greater routinisation across degrees;

Oracle certification is an example of high task certainty.

 

IS research issues

 

Some emphasis on qualitative research methods;

Perceived fewer incentives for research than for teaching;

Some incentives provided by faculty/university to do research.

Some emphasis on SME and government research;

New focus on IT governance, business process management;

Majority of staff expected to undertake research.

Research program not controlled centrally;

Few common topics;

Research culture hard to sustain, detracting from routinisation of research;

Perceived lack of recognition for productive research staff;

Limited history of attracting ARC funds;

Less attendance at conferences than in past;

Perceived need to focus on fewer research areas;

Limited quality journal publications reduces task certainty for publishing in these journals;

High teaching loads leave little time to routinise research.

An examination of IS at the UTAS in 2007 and beyond will be presented next, before the conclusions of this study are considered.