This short statement expresses a personal view of the structural placement of IS (and computer science) in the UTAS. The views might be of relevance to other universities. This contributor has had no input to university decisions since 1999.
The context is that IS and computer science have been taught by two ‘schools’ (or departments) in the UTAS. Both schools have been under financial stress from loss of undergraduate student numbers, especially of Australian students, and low research output. The stress was perhaps higher for IS than for computer science, since the latter was somewhat larger, had attracted a large international intake and was perhaps slightly more research active. The two schools are named (eponymously) Information Systems in the Faculty of Business and Computing in the Faculty of Science, Engineering and Technology. Both had their genesis in a single school. Senior executives do not believe that there are any distinguishing differences between the disciplines.
In March 2007, the vice-chancellor and the senior executive consisting of all the deputy and pro-vice-chancellors and the deans invited the two schools to come up with a plan for ‘marriage’ before the 2008 budget was drawn up. This gave urgency to the question of where the discipline of IS fits in the UTAS.
The background to this ‘request’ was that both schools were in trouble with funding related to outputs; neither school had been able to satisfactorily differentiate its offerings from the other to Tasmanian school-leavers despite enormous effort, marketing had been unsuccessful in leading to growth and the university was unconvinced that the ‘corner had been turned’. The two schools were not seen as worth saving as separate entities for their research output or for their community contribution. These are all arguable assessments, but were nevertheless persuasive arguments to university management.
Personally, I view IS as having established itself completely as a sub-discipline within the field of ICT. There are, however, many other sub-disciplines within this field, such as computer architecture, networking technologies, software engineering, theoretical computer science, mobile computing, Internet technologies, robotics, and so on. They form an overlapping and continuous spectrum of ICT application.
None have any existence without the pervasive impact of computer artefacts. As a former chair of a unified school but without influence, I regretted the break-up into two entities and I welcomed a possibility of reuniting them. This might not be so obvious to schools of IS that were founded independently, but I believe that the computer artefact is at the core of all these sub-disciplines, and unnecessary fragmentation serves no one.
In larger universities, the continued existence of IS and computer science schools might be retained, especially as IS often established itself in a separate faculty. If an amalgamated school would be too large for good management, independent existence is a good option.
Even then, however, IS is on difficult ground, as it is often moving out of its obsolescent business background into education, medicine, architecture and even science, as the discipline that deals with computer applications. This brings it into direct conflict with computer science, which has never given up this ground. The pressure will be on to bring the ICT disciplines closer together.
In smaller universities, such as the UTAS, the outcome is likely to be a single school, which has some advantages of greater coherence, though it might come with angst and turmoil in the short term.
In fact, when I look at the research output of the School of Computing at the UTAS, perhaps 50 per cent of the papers could be classified as ‘information research’ and are capable of being done in a large, competent IS school. The remainder consists of artificial intelligence, image processing, robotics and a few other theoretical computer science matters such as graph theory, bioinformatics and parallelism. In IS at the UTAS, its involvement in medical informatics and in ICT forensics could fit equally well in computer science.
Perhaps we all need to take a step back and decide what matters to us and to society, and whether the decades-old split between computer applications and infrastructure deserves to be mended. After all, the ACS has never ceased to encompass both.