This final section reviews the findings, and presents the study’s limitations and suggestions for future research.
In the descriptive analysis of the School of Information Systems at the UTAS, the extent to which IS was impacted on by local factors, whether it was perceived to be a separate field at the university, the distinctive characteristics of its curriculum and research and the key people who had an impact on IS at the UTAS were considered. An analysis was then undertaken of the perceived degree of impact of local contingencies and the degree of professionalism—for IS teaching and research at the UTAS.
The level-two analysis suggests that while local contingencies had a low to medium impact on curriculum and teaching, they had a high to medium impact on research issues. There were, however, indications that the reverse was the case for the degree of professionalism, in that curriculum and teaching issues had a high level of professionalism while research activities were assessed as low to medium. These findings for research issues are consistent with the view of IS as a fragmented adhocracy, as explained in the framework chapter earlier in this volume. The different findings for curriculum and teaching issues have not, it is believed, been identified before for IS, and make a contribution to research on the development of this discipline.
The level-two findings are consistent with the postulation from the theoretical framework that an inverse relationship exists between the impact of local contingencies on a discipline and its degree of professionalism. As the findings were derived from a single case study, however, the inverse relationship found is best confirmed by case studies conducted in other areas of Australia and elsewhere. Moreover, if the findings are confirmed in different regions using different methods of analysis, this characteristic will act to strengthen the findings.
Additional planned future work is to examine the remainder of the theoretical framework developed for the study through a cross-case analysis of how the components of the IS discipline developed over time. It is possible that the framework might need modification as a result of its application to further cases. Once these level-three findings are known, comparison can be made with research conducted in Europe and North America to see if the common findings extend to Australia at least six years later.
The degree of change experienced in the IS discipline is demonstrated by this case study from Tasmania. This chapter has reported that teaching and research into IS at the single university in the state resumed in a science-based faculty, in conjunction with computing, after 11 years in a separate school in a business faculty. Opportunities exist for future research that examines the impact of co-location of IS with computing at the UTAS on student enrolments, teaching and research.