Two frameworks were used to guide this study and evaluate its findings. The first was Whitley’s theory of scientific change (1984b), which proposed that three conditions were needed for the establishment of a distinct scientific field. These three conditions are:
scientific reputations to become socially prestigious and to ‘control critical rewards’
establishing standards of research competence and skills
a unique symbol system to allow exclusion of outsiders and unambiguous communication between initiates within the field.
Second, an updated framework proposed by Ridley (2006) was applied to the data collected. This more recent framework extends the Whitley set of conditions to include two additional conditions necessary to establish a distinct scientific field. Ridley’s two additional conditions are:
laws, rules and evidenced guidelines
research and teaching key topics.
Ridley (2006) categorises the various criteria into two main components: mechanisms of control and a core body of knowledge (research and teaching methods and standards, the existence of a unique symbol set, key research and teaching topics and laws, rules and evidenced guidelines). She also proposes that it is important to add two other components—that is, the impact of local contingencies and the degree of professionalism—to evaluate the variation in IS programs in Australian universities and to track progress and compare programs in a given state.
More detail of the framework and its derivation are provided in Chapter 3 of this volume.