While all nine universities in Victoria represented in the study offer IS programs, the location of the programs within the university structure differs by institution. Table 9.2 shows that IS programs in universities in Victoria can be categorised between business and science/technical/engineering faculties. Six departments are located within faculties of science/technical/engineering, whereas Deakin, RMIT and Victoria University offer IT programs through the business and the science/technical/engineering faculties.
The home faculties in which IS in Victorian universities was situated indicated a diverse mix. The two main faculties, shown in Table 9.2, are business and science; however, IS is also situated in an interesting mix of arts, law, engineering, communication and health science faculties. The demarcation between a science and/or a business focus in IS departments is quite clear. This diversity of home faculties seems to indicate that, on the whole, IS has not matured in Victoria as a stand-alone discipline.
|
University |
Department, school or group |
Home faculty |
Demarcation |
|---|---|---|---|
|
ACU (national) |
Business and Informatics |
Arts and Sciences |
Science |
|
Deakin |
Information Systems Information Technology |
Business and Law Science and Technology |
Business Science |
|
La Trobe |
Computer Science and Computer Engineering |
Science, Technology and Engineering |
Science |
|
Monash |
Berwick School, Caulfield School, Clayton School, Gippsland School |
Information Technology |
IT |
|
RMIT |
Business Information Technology Computer Science and Information Technology |
Business Science, Engineering and Technology |
Business Science |
|
Swinburne |
Astrophysics and Supercomputing Computer Science and Software Engineering Information Systems Telecommunications |
Information and Communication Technologies |
IT |
|
Melbourne |
Information Systems Software Engineering |
Science Engineering |
Science |
|
University of Ballarat |
Information Technology and Mathematical Sciences |
Information Technology and Mathematical Sciences |
IT |
|
Victoria University |
Information Systems Computer Science and Mathematics |
Business and Law Health, Engineering and Science |
Business Science |
Despite the placement of six of the nine IS departments within a non-IS home faculty, data revealed a move in an overwhelming majority of universities in Victoria to recognise IS as a separate entity. Table 9.3 shows that only three of the nine Victorian universities represented have not attained a separate identity for IS. In universities where there was a separate IS identity, this was expressed as:
a clear demarcation between IS subjects and others in the faculty (RMIT, Victoria University)
a strong reputation in industry (Swinburne)
IS had long had a strong separate identity (Monash).
A specific example might serve to explain this better. For many years in the 1970s and 1980s, Caulfield and then Chisholm Institute of Technology pioneered IS education in Victoria. An early activity was the Commonwealth government’s Programmer-in-Training (PIT) scheme. Some people also raised the issue of ‘competing’ with business, IT and computer science departments in connection with the existence of a separate identity.
Overall, the existence of a separate identity for IS was viewed positively, although at Melbourne it was indicated that while IS had a separate identity as a department, ‘not many people know about our department’. Of the three universities (ACU National, University of Ballarat and La Trobe) that do not afford IS a separate identity, La Trobe has experienced some problems with this status, including the lack of representation of IS journals and conferences in a recent journal and conference ranking exercise undertaken to improve the department’s (Computer Science and Computer Engineering) research profile. At the University of Ballarat, IS does not have separate administrative status and IS lecturers teach into other areas of the School of Information Technology and Mathematical Science. This is also true for ACU National, as one of the three IS lecturers teaches the business units and IS does not have separate administrative status.
Despite the generally positive perception of having a separate identity, senior academics in Victoria were relatively evenly divided between ‘same’ and ‘less’ in their views on status as shown in Table 9.3. Only one senior academic at Monash felt that IS academics were viewed more highly than their colleagues in other departments. At the four universities in Victoria where it was perceived that IS academics saw themselves as having a lesser status than their colleagues a number of reasons were given.
In some cases it appeared to be due to the relatively new and evolving nature of IS departments in Australia (Melbourne, RMIT, Victoria University).
A respondent representing Swinburne felt that the perception of the IS faculty was that they were ‘less prominent in research than their colleagues’.
At those universities where the perception was that there was no difference between the status of IS academics and their colleagues no elaboration for this perception was forthcoming.
Interestingly, Table 9.3 also shows that status and separate identity are not necessarily correlated. For example, academics at the University of Ballarat considered their status ‘no more or less’ and those at La Trobe were said to have mixed perceptions of status. In contrast, at those universities that had a separate identity, many viewed themselves as having less status for the reasons described above.