Research focus within the four universities also varies widely and this could be one of the reasons why all interviewees identified a low level of collaboration between WA universities. Indeed, at the time of writing, there were no joint projects and staff in each university seemed unfamiliar with research being conducted in other WA institutions. Funding was variable, with the onus on staff to generate funding through successful grant applications, internally or externally, or through collaborative partnerships with industry. Curtin has an industry-sponsored professor, which comes with considerable prestige in addition to research funds.
Research output also varied considerably. At the UWA, the research activity of staff was largely interdisciplinary and had a relatively low proportion contributing to strictly IS-related research, compared with a high output overall at ECU, with about 90 per cent of staff research active. Curtin followed the more typical path, with 20 per cent of staff providing 80 per cent of output. It was stated that Curtin had shifted emphasis towards teaching over research in recent years, but this could be changing as Curtin has made a strategic move to be a research-intensive university. Identified themes for continuing research are shown in Table 10.4.
|
University |
Themes |
Groups |
Funding |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Curtin |
Technology adoption Information technology Management Health informatics Relational ontology World-wide databases Grid supercomputing Electronic commerce Soft-systems methodology |
Individuals + PhD groupings around professors |
Grant-based + Research Performance Index funding system |
|
ECU |
Electronic markets Collaborative commerce in small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) IS evaluation IS in the construction industry IS education and IS in education |
Five formal research groups led by the professors/associate professors + individual |
Grant-based + Research Activity Index funding system |
|
UWA |
Knowledge management Virtual communities E-government Transport modelling Compliance-monitoring systems |
Individuals and interdisciplinary and inter-faculty collaborations |
Grant-based and individual research support from school funds |
|
Murdoch |
Human factors in IS Knowledge management E-learning Decision support Business strategy alignment |
Individuals |
Grant-based + individual allocation from school |
Curtin and ECU operate a research performance-monitoring scheme, which is linked directly to research funding (Curtin University—Research Performance Index; ECU—Research Activity Index). In this way, staff members are rewarded with a dollar value applied to the number of points they have generated towards the research assessment quantum. This scheme provides considerable incentive for staff to become productive but can favour quantity over quality. At ECU, however, the recent trend has been to decrease the funding per point being allocated to staff and to the use the money to provide competitive internal research grants.
All four universities support qualitative and quantitative research and employ multiple methods. Case studies and interpretive research were commonly applied. The overall research picture in Western Australia fits closely with the view of a ‘fragmented adhocracy’ (Whitley 1984; Culnan et al. 1993; Checkland and Holwell 1998), with low researcher mutual dependency and very different contributions from each of the four universities, reflecting local political pressures from within their different institutions but also from within the state—where all four compete for highly limited funding.