Previous

Vā Moana

11

Teu le vā as Indigenous relationality in contemporary museological praxis

Melani Anae and Leone Samu Tui

One could easily argue that Pacific research methodologies (PRM) and Pacific relational ethics (PRE) are not new: a genealogical approach would send us back to our ancient Pacific philosophers and practitioners of ancient Indigenous knowledges—indeed back to Tagaloa-a-lagi and the 10 heavens. However, in recent years there has been a renaissance of PRM and PRE taken up by Pacific researchers based in Aotearoa New Zealand and the wider Pacific to counter the Western hegemonic tradition of how research is carried out and why—especially research involving Pacific people, families and communities. This renaissance seeks to decolonise and re-Indigenise research carried out on Pacific peoples and communities by doing research based on Pacific Indigenous theories, PRM and PRE. It demands that research carried out on, and about, Pacific peoples and communities is ethical and methodologically sound with transformational outputs. In reality, the crisis in Pacific research is the continuing adherence to traditional Western theories and research methods that undermine and overshadow the vā—the sacred, spiritual and social spaces of human relationships between the researcher and researched that Pacific peoples place at the centre of all human/environment/cosmos/ancestors and animate/inanimate interactions. In this chapter, we trace changing understandings and iterations of teu le vā—from its cultural context and meanings, to a research paradigm and methodology in education, to its current deployment in Indigenous Pacific museum praxis.

In Aotearoa New Zealand, teu le vā (TLV) has been used as an integral Ministry of Education (MoE) Pacific research paradigm since the publication of Teu Le Va—Relationships across Research and Policy in Pasifika Education (TLVRPE) in 2010 (Airini et al., 2010). In 2013, quite independently and without reference to this document, the Pacific staff at Tāmaki Paenga Hira Auckland War Memorial Museum formulated a strategic plan with a similar title: Teu Le Vā: The Pacific Dimension at Auckland Museum (TLVPD). Here, we explore both iterations of this paradigm in their applied contexts. We contend that a core element of TLV in the educational context of TLVRPE—the need ‘to value, nurture, and if necessary, tidy up’ relational contexts—is absent from the TLVPD strategy, and that there is an urgent need to teu le vā within the museum setting.

While some progress has been made in favour of greater visible Indigenous and community representation in museums, very little scholarship has examined the generative influence of Indigenous concepts and paradigms on Indigenous museum practices. Leone Samu Tui (2020) explored Anae’s TLV paradigm in her BA (hons) thesis, The Teu Le Va Paradigm in Contemporary Museological Praxis: An Exploratory Study, arguing that the TLV paradigm, both through its methodology and consolidated contemporary theoretical iterations, has much to offer museological discourse and praxis.

To this end, we present a future-focused relational framework adapted from the TLVRPE that outlines how the TLV approach can be understood, valued and enacted in the museum context; articulates relational contexts; and identifies vā between entities within a museum setting inspired by articulations found in the TLVRPE. The framework also addresses shortcomings in the implementation of the TLVPD at the Auckland Museum. Overall, it demonstrates the TLV paradigm’s ultimate directive: to produce transformative and empowering outcomes for all Auckland Museum stakeholders, especially Pacific communities.

Teu le vā as relational ethic and pragmatic application

Teu le vā is an Indigenous concept—a Samoan cultural reference that means ‘to value, nurture and tidy up sacred and secular relational spaces for optimal outcomes’.1 Extended as a relational ethics paradigm in 2007 by Anae (2007a), it has since become an influential teaching and research contribution. The MoE’s Pasifika Education Research Guidelines (Anae et al., 2010), incorporated into the TLVRPE Framework below, acknowledges TLV as its conceptual, philosophical and methodological core, and documents TLV’s conceptual and philosophical basis in research praxis.

TLV is significant because it not only infers cultural protocols and etiquette, both physical and sacred, but also implies proscribed and prescribed behaviours and their concomitant moral and ethical underpinnings. It insists that direct action must follow a breach of the tapu (sacred) in the vā to correct the relationship and/or the relational arrangement. Thus, not only during formal rituals, but also at small family or village meetings, when one is told to teu le vā, the matter is taken very seriously, and immediate action is taken to address the incorrect relational arrangement (Airini et al., 2010, p. 12). In all human relationships, action/behaviour and consequences consist of the duality of reciprocal practical action being sanctioned by spiritual, moral and sacred support.

In our research relationships, Pacific researchers can teu le vā in general by exposing, understanding and reconciling our vā with each other in reciprocal relationships in the research process, and by engaging in dialogue with all research participants at all levels. A person is separate from others (independent) and connected to others (dependent) simultaneously. A relational personhood, or interdependent personhood, fosters rather than assumes autonomy. Thus, the role of the Pacific researcher is to facilitate continued dialogue between all research collaborators to ensure debate and continued dialogue over time. Where there is tension or disagreement, to teu le vā means to soothe, mute and/or attenuate these to correct or realign priorities and ensure the dialogue is kept intact and moving forward.

TLVRPE Framework2

The TLVRPE Framework brings research collaborators into PRE to help provide optimal education outcomes for, and with, Pacific learners. Conventional approaches and thinking have not always been up to the task of dealing with Pacific education issues. After discussion with Pacific education researchers, policymakers and other change leaders in education, the TLVRPE Framework was developed to facilitate new and different kinds of relationships, in which knowledge could be exposed and translated into policy that would bring about Pacific students’ educational success. The document takes a strategic, evidence-based, outcomes-focused approach, outlining three interactive principles for optimal relationships that will lead to directive action. First, optimal relationships through TLV between researchers and policymakers are necessary for a collective and collaborative approach to research and policymaking; second, collective knowledge generation is pivotal in developing optimal relationships in which new knowledge and understandings can be generated; and, third, research and policy efforts must be focused on achieving optimal Pasifika education and development outcomes.

The TLVRPE authors envisaged that emphasising the importance of relationality and the significance of context would enhance research collaborators’ understanding that the spirit of ‘relationship’ is crucial and persuade them to work together for optimal outcomes. In this way, types of research, research problems, findings and links to policy formation can be more explicitly conceptualised, strategically formulated, approached, valued and acted on in terms of the aspects of the vā in relationships (in)formed by the research process.

Anae’s suite of publications on TLV developed from an Indigenous cultural reference standpoint and a non-Western understanding of relational ethics (Anae 2005, 2007a, 2007b, 2010a, 2010b, 2016, 2017, 2019). More saliently, the essential Indigenous inclusion of spirituality to Western relationality discourse has provided the fertile soil for new understandings and research directions in the field of relational ethics. The TLV approach gives language to Pacific research practitioners’ actions in their daily work with relational research communities and stakeholders. This includes their work with Pacific people(s) and communities who need their services and support; work with their Pacific colleagues/research teams; and work with policymakers, research institutions and funders. Anae and other Pacific authors of interdisciplinary Pacific research and cultural competencies guidelines identify the valuing of relationships as the central location for ethical action, as human flourishing is enhanced by healthy and ethical relationships (Bergum & Dossetor, 2005).

All researchers should be committed to spiritual vā—with the people they serve, individually and collectively, and with each other. Today, the need to engage in the knowledge economy can obscure the commitment to vā by an emphasis on advanced technology, consumerism, legal liability, bureaucracy, objective rationalism and individual autonomy. TLV, by contrast, evokes the need to attend to the art of ethics by delineating comprehensive and philosophically grounded ethics for Pacific research in the diverse fields of education, health, justice, social needs and more.

PRE focuses on whole people as interdependent moral agents and on the quality of their mutual commitments. The relational discourse defines the space between people as an ethical or relational space, a space that must be nurtured and respected if an ethical practice is to be enacted. TLV means that each person has a power that is fundamental to human development. In dialogue, all sides can be heard, and one’s autonomy is fostered through gaining voice and perspective and through the experience of engagement with others. Bergum and Dossetor (2005, p. 96) explain that:

Ethical behaviour is not the display of one’s moral rectitude in times of crisis … it is the day to day expression of one’s commitment to other persons and the ways in which human beings relate to one another in their daily interactions.

For us, this means that TLV provides the connection between the researcher and all the other research relational communities and measina. It is a connection built on compassion and the cultivation of physical, mental, ethical and spiritual energy. Of paramount importance is the relationship of fa‘aaloalo (trust and respect) between the researcher and the researched (Verbos & Humphries, 2014).

The TLVRPE Framework provides insights into how TLV can be applied to other social contexts. On the contested terrain of relational ethics, where battles rage about concepts, values, practices and how ethics should be taught and applied, TLV provides a tangible way forward. Its guidelines not only encourage exemplary moral action but also the acquisition of a deeper knowledge of ethics. The hope is that improved moral behaviour will be promoted by knowing what the right and good thing to do is, and by seeing how decisions are made and implemented in practice. The worth of community and of relationships in research praxis needs to be valued. TLV, through the TLVRPE Framework, enables us to understand what relationships are about, how they are created, what they mean and how they are sustained. Healthy and ethical relationships enhance human flourishing, and morality is rooted in collective life (Bergum & Dossetor, 2005).

In the research field in Aotearoa, Pacific concepts have generally provided a genealogical and generative space for new understandings of PRE. Indigenous concepts are being defined and interrogated through inter-Pacific and intra-Pacific lenses by Pacific scholars such as Sanga and Reynolds (2017) who have called for new work to be placed within existing patterns and models. The explicit acknowledgement of vā (genealogical relationships) is of particular concern as iterations of Indigenous concepts/models/frameworks are developed in the field (Sanga & Reynolds, 2017, p. 200). Given that Pacific Indigenous relational concepts are increasingly being used in Aotearoa, how can further iterations of concepts/models/frameworks be developed in other fields, such as museology? What do conceptual frameworks of Indigenous relational understandings reveal about current museum practices and principles?

Auckland Museum as a case study for TLV in museum praxis

As a critically reflexive Moana museum practitioner (CRMMP),3 Samu Tui constantly reflects on her personal experiences of Pacific Indigenous museum practice. Her use of the term ‘Moana’ is a nod to recent Moana scholars who promote that term to reclaim and reframe knowledge and all that it entails from a Pacific positionality. Moana connotes, inter alia, a Polynesian mindset and is the term that best encapsulates Samu Tui’s specific life experiences (Kaʻili, 2017). In her professional practice and in this chapter, Samu Tui aims to be a CRMMP, acknowledging the centrality of relationships in Indigenous museum professional praxis that enable her to better serve Pacific communities in Auckland and beyond.

Despite foundational shifts over recent decades, few authors examine the mutual influence of the practical engagement of Pacific concepts and paradigms on Indigenous Pacific museum practices. An important exception is Schorch et al. (2016), which Dr Albert Hakiwai contributed to. Objects from the Pacific have been acquired, imbued with meanings and absorbed into Western museum collections since the exploratory voyages of Captain James Cook and others in the late eighteenth century. Subsequent display and exhibition practices within museums have played their part in establishing narratives through a Eurocentric imagination about communities Indigenous to Oceania and elsewhere, primarily excluding input from Pacific peoples themselves (Wolfe, 2018). Over the last 40 years, this lack of Indigenous engagement has been addressed through critical scholarship challenging museums, the academy and wider society to make space and privilege Indigenous voices (Mead, 1983; Smith, 2012). The resulting new museology, which calls for greater reflexivity and diverse perspectives, including Indigenous scholars and communities, has significantly impacted museum practices across governance, display and exhibition, public programs, collection management and curatorial praxis (Kreps, 2003; McCarthy, 2011). As McCarthy (2011) has pointed out, museums operate at the intersection of practice and theory; therefore, it is crucial to document the activity and progress occurring at this intersection.

A key site where these changes can be recorded is Tāmaki Paenga Hira Auckland War Memorial Museum. Established in 1852, the museum moved to its current site on Pukekawa Hill in the Auckland Domain in 1929. Since then, Auckland Museum has had the mandate to serve its local Auckland communities, particularly as the Auckland region’s war memorial. The museum’s total collection includes over 4 million individual objects, across human history, natural sciences and documentary heritage. Today, 300,000 objects are accessible online through the museum’s online digital database. Auckland Museum’s Pacific collection is considered world-class and includes just over 30,000 taonga (treasured objects) (Auckland War Memorial Museum, 2013). Most of the institution’s operational funding is sourced from city ratepayers. The amalgamation of various city councils in Auckland in 2010 impacted the museum’s strategic planning, resulting in its Future Museum strategy (Auckland War Memorial Museum, 2012).

Despite Auckland Museum’s pre-eminent Pacific collection and the institution’s close proximity to Pacific community hubs, the under-representation of locally based Pacific communities—in museum staff and visitor numbers, as well as in collections and exhibitions that reflect contemporary Pacific experiences of life in Tāmaki Makaurau—has long been an issue in need of redress.

Teu le vā Pacific dimension

Teu Le Vā: The Pacific Dimension at Auckland Museum was developed by Pacific museum staff in 2013 to address the museum’s lack of engagement with wider Pacific communities in Auckland.4 This strategy included capital investment in collections, renewal of permanent galleries and establishing a Pacific development program. The TLVPD sought to ‘focus attention on approaches, activities, and ways of working within the Auckland Museum and between the Auckland Museum and [Pacific] source communities and other stakeholder groups’ (Auckland War Memorial Museum, 2013, p. 5).

Significant in the drafting of this document was that, aside from the facilitation provided by a Pākehā project manager, the TLVPD was crafted and put together by Auckland Museum staff members of Pacific heritage. It was rare to have Pacific staff all together in one room collaborating, let alone collectively articulating a Pacific worldview and establishing a baseline for fostering a relationship with Auckland’s Pacific communities. This exercise enabled Pacific staff members to bring their ‘polycultural capital’ (Mila-Schaaf, 2011) into work with them, drawing on their cultural value systems and knowledge. The final draft represents actual views and input from staff members, including the selection of proverbs used as anchors and images from the Pacific collections to populate the document.

Several initiatives and changes in museum practice were born out of the TLVPD. Running almost concurrently with the drafting of the document was the mandate to assemble and recruit the museum’s first permanently established Pacific Advisory Group (PAG), each member serving a three-year term.5 In 2017, a TLV manager was recruited to lead the ongoing delivery and implementation of the TLVPD across the organisation. Several more Pacific positions were created and filled, including associate curator, documentary heritage, Pacific collections. Pacific staff at Auckland Museum continue to meet regularly as a TLV Pacific staff network.

Input and advocacy from the PAG, the staff network and the TLV manager has resulted in myriad opportunities for the museum to engage with Pacific concepts in museological practice, and for Pacific communities to engage with the museum. These have manifested in curatorial approaches to gallery renewal, input into building renovations and new staff onboarding procedures, as well as other initiatives such as the delivery of Pacific Language Weeks and cultural protocols to welcome communities into the museum.

The Pacific Collection Access Project

Of all the Pacific initiatives undertaken at the Auckland Museum after the TLVPD was formalised, the most visibly impactful was the Pacific Collection Access Project (PCAP). This three-year project, which ran from 2016 to 2019, involved recruiting eight team members (including Samu Tui) on full-time, fixed-term contracts. The project, which covered 13 island groups, was resourced as one of several Future Museum Collections Readiness projects. Its purpose was to undertake conservation and rehousing, enrich catalogue record documentation and produce high-resolution photography of taonga to promote better digital and physical access. PCAP was the ‘first cab off the rank’. What set it apart from other projects undertaken at the same time—for instance in the natural sciences and social and military history departments, as well as the Te Awe taonga Māori collection project—was the emphasis placed on community engagement to create opportunities for Pacific communities in Auckland to connect with their treasures.

Between 2016 and 2019, over 7,000 Pacific peoples visited or engaged with the Auckland Museum. Knowledge holder sessions were also held as part of the project. These sessions brought forth Indigenous community-held knowledge that was shared with museum staff to enrich catalogue records and the overall understanding of the collections being cared for.

PCAP brought the importance of vā relationships into sharp relief (Samu Tui, 2021), but there were limitations to its application in practice that reflected shortcomings of the TLVPD. These included an uneven understanding of the TLV paradigm at the heart of the TLVPD across the museum, as well as the absence of external consultation with communities during the drafting and internal consulting process of TLVPD. The justification at the time consisted in equal parts of necessity, time constraints and lack of resources (Pereira, cited in Christophe, 2016). To the authors of this chapter, the crucial shortcoming was the lack of understanding among various museum stakeholders of vā and the contextual areas of responsibility and accountability outlined in the earlier part of this chapter.

While the TLVPD referred to the vā between source communities and taonga, the strategy did not prepare museum professionals to manage and care for multi-level relationships daily. Although purported to be a ‘living document’, the museum’s high-level strategic document had not been reviewed or updated since its publication in 2013. This is urgently needed in light of the many developments brought about since its inception.6

Adapting the TLVRPE Framework

Tools and principles borrowed from TLV bring the Pacific research paradigm into the museum sector for further development in museum practice. Future strategies can consequently be aligned with TLV, thus updating the TLVPD and addressing shortfalls in the provision of adequate museum practice at an operational level. Inspired by a deep dive into the origins and use of the TLV paradigm underpinning the TLVRPE—particularly Anae’s suite of conceptual TLV work—Samu Tui (2020) has adapted and created the TLV Relational Museum Framework (TLVRMF). Figure 11.1 illustrates the wider vā context in which TLVRMF was developed.

This diagram visually depicts how relationships underpin teu le vā in practice, illustrating the TLV paradigm as it would ideally function when embedded within a museum context. It shows how vā relationships are arranged in relation to one another, and how they interact in a holistic manner. At the centre is Samu Tui, a CRMMP engaging in four separate realms: museum policy, museum practice, source communities, and knowledge and research. Each realm has its own vā, which overlap and influence the other realms. Such a visual representation of these optimal connections is currently missing from the TLVPD, which only notes aspirations.

Figure 11.1: A model of the TLV paradigm in the museum context

Figure 11.1: A model of the TLV paradigm in the museum context.

Source: Adapted from Airini et al. (2010).

Museums are often viewed as civic forums, especially in their orientation towards visitor experience; however, at their core, they are the holders of collections, whether material culture or intangible heritage. Taonga are in the care and stewardship of museum staff who ultimately retain the power to curate, display and determine how museum practice is shaped when caring for collections. Senior Curator Pacific Histories and Culture at Te Papa Sean Mallon (personal communication, 14 October 2020) argues that museum workers have more power and decision-making ability than non-museum workers—no matter how much they might want to share power with source communities.

In light of this, CRMMPs must nurture and maintain relationships at three optimal levels:

  1. above—at management and governance level
  2. across—with fellow staff members who have different levels of familiarity with TLV
  3. below or outwards—with source communities.

CRMMPs must also maintain a theory-based practice that can deliver transformational, empowering outcomes for taonga and their source communities. These elements are all part of museum practice that is, in turn, influenced by environmental factors (e.g. Covid-19 and implications of digital aspects of cultural heritage, such as open access). Nurturing a network of relationships in this way take time and effort.

Referring to Figure 11.1, the TLVPD is a museum policy document—that is, a formally approved document that operates in the vā with other decision-making processes. The second branch, diametrically opposite, is the area of community, which is simultaneously outside and inside (e.g. the PAG) the museum context. Research and theory, which influences knowledge generation in its many forms at the museum, takes up another branch. Located at the other end is practice, which includes access, engagement and experience. Embedded in all these elements is the awareness of vā—relational space—which determines the types of interactions. Encircling these elements are the environment, the local context of the museum and time (represented by the red dashed lines). As mentioned earlier, TLV includes a spiritual component—a holistic view of all relationships coming together in an ecosystem. Thus, witnessing knowledge holders connect with taonga, which they know have been made by family members or ancestors, involves a spiritual element. As Anae (2017) argues, it ought to be seen in all our relationships, for to view relationships as sacred effects the nature of relationships, elevating both their treatment and the work of museums.

TLV Relational Museum Framework

Offered as a resource to ‘update’ or support the current TLVPD, Table 11.1 presents the final iteration of the TLVRMF—a framework for understanding and enacting TLV in the Auckland Museum context. It contributes to ongoing engagement with the TLV paradigm as a pathway to direct transformative action in the museum space.

Table 11.1: TLV Relational Museum Framework

Relational contexts

Concept/principle

Teu le vā

Museum institution (executive team + Trust Board)

Critically reflexive Moana museum practitioner (CRMMP)

1. The vā between mana whenua/tangata whenua and Pacific communities in the museum.

In Aotearoa, engaging with stakeholders in the museum context means meaningful engagement and observance of Māori as mana whenua, tangata whenua.

Upholding bicultural principles and observing the Māori Values (He Korahi Māori) framework at a strategic level with close relationships maintained with Te Taumata a Iwi.

Coordinating protocols during events and ensuring that protocols are enacted. Acknowledgements to mana whenua and ceremonies. Cognisance of ancient relations and kinships of knowledge and ties to Moana Nui a Kiwa.

2. The vā between taonga in Pacific museum collections and CRMMPs.

The assemblage of collections based on past ethnographic-based priorities and what this means now; awareness of proximity, sacredness of items and consideration of the unique individual storage/information needs for each item.

Providing resources and backing for storage to take into account cultural considerations in the collection management of taonga.

Actively seeking out new information about taonga that reveals its original cultural contexts and provenance details.

3. The vā between CRMMPs (especially tuakana and teina) and colleagues.

Recognising that the museum is still a sector with few Pacific people in it; that more Pacific people should be encouraged to thrive in museum careers and contribute to the care and practice of museum measina/taonga/iyau etc.

Enabling resources for professional development of emerging CRMMPs.

Seeking to network with others; not working in isolation but building on what others have done; and being open to opportunities to share learnings with volunteers/Pacific peoples interested in the museum as a career.

4. The vā between the museum institution and CRMMPs.

Through TLV processes, a commitment to transformative change for Pacific source communities, families, etc., to do away with a colonial mentality, increase access to collections and actively promote Indigenous knowledge systems that are not only museologically exciting but also further philosophical and moral expectation.

Ensuring that the project will lead to forms of operational praxis changes that take on elements of the project, if not the project outright, to preserve and nurture the vā between the institution and CRMMPs, and CRMMPs and source communities via participants.

Within negotiated funding, timing and parameters, selecting the best parameters for the project in terms of what is achievable and culturally safe. Also, as good practice, disseminating work and notes to participants (e.g. the recordings of knowledge holder sessions).

5. Untangling Pacific population cohorts; the vā between island and NZ-born members in these source communities.

Acknowledging and untangling the different dimensions of identity and ethnicity. Recognising the salience of context.

Specific statements that ask to define the particular community being engaged with; consulting with the teu le vā manager.

Proposals put forward should detail which community is being targeted to approach for engagement and partnership within the museum project; work to understand and engage with that community should be undertaken before anything else.

6. The vā between source communities and their taonga.

Understanding that this relationship can carry with it many emotions, trauma or a reconnecting; that these taonga carry embodied knowledge privy first and foremost to the source community, perhaps even only select members of that community (i.e. knowledge holders).

Ensuring access. Remuneration for expertise and knowledge shared in the context of museum work. Crediting any knowledge that comes out of the work of knowledge holders. Acting on recommendations where possible.

Ensure content management record notes are kept that detail community input on collection management preferences.

7. The vā between the museum institution and Pacific/source communities.

Recognising the asymmetry of power dynamics.

Acknowledging that relationships may be broken or non-existent with source communities due to prior trauma and other factors. Taking direction from the Pacific Advisory Group and CRMMPs.

CRMMPs acting in double advocacy role: advocating on behalf of the source community from within the museum while also translating or nurturing relationships with the source community on behalf of the museum institution.

8. The (digital) vā between Indigenous and Western knowledge systems.

For example, open access versus what Barbara Makuati-Afitu describes as ‘Honouring the Whisper’ (National Digital Forum, 2017); Indigenous theory discussed in the context of museum practice and studies.

Recognising the significance of Indigenous knowledge.

Being cognisant of knowledge that is not meant for the museum; advise community knowledge holders of use and copyright.

9. Best practice reference points—vā between:

  • CRMMPs and museum institutions
  • CRMMPs and colleagues
  • CRMMPs and communities
  • CRMMPs and taonga.

Implementing sound principles and internal organisational policies that incorporate the six transformative research practices outlined in the Pasifika Education Research Guidelines (Anae et al., 2010) and adapted for the museum context in Figure 11.1.

The institution should request that staff demonstrate how these processes will be addressed in their project design. The institution should approve the necessary budget for proper hosting and also ensure that spaces are available for this purpose.

Reciprocal relationships to be nurtured with tangata whenua, research institutions, funders, team colleagues and source communities. How these relationships are to be nurtured should be clearly delineated in the planning stages of projects as well as internal policy documentation (e.g. acknowledging time).

Source: Adapted from Airini et al. (2010).

The TLVRMF identifies nine vā (relational contexts) that require critical nurturing within a museum setting, namely, between:

  1. mana whenua/tangata whenua and the museum
  2. taonga in Pacific museum collections and CRMMPs
  3. CRMMPs (tuakana and colleagues) and other colleagues
  4. the museum and CRMMPs
  5. island and New Zealand–born source communities
  6. Pacific communities and taonga
  7. the museum and Pacific source communities
  8. Indigenous and Western knowledge systems
  9. CRMMPs and the institution, CRMMPs and colleagues, CRMMPs and communities, and CRMMPs and taonga.

In the context of Aotearoa New Zealand, the vā between tangata whenua and the Crown—bicultural partners under the Treaty of Waitangi—takes precedence. It is in relation to the recognition of tangata whenua as Indigenous First Nations peoples that Pacific museological practice is conducted. The remaining eight vā can be viewed from the position of the CRMMPs as relational contexts above (the vā between CRMMPs and the museum institution), across (the vā between CRMMPs and colleagues, best practice reference points for optimal vā), and inwards and outwards between taonga and source communities (the vā between taonga and source communities, between taonga and CRMMPs, and between CRMMPs and source communities).

TLVRMF works towards high-quality praxis across museum activities that acknowledge the cultural contexts of Pacific communities in Auckland. It encourages a Pacific development focus on praxis, where participants and communities have tangible representation, feedback opportunities and consultation opportunities for co-development. This framework emphasises building capacity and growing the pool of critically reflective Moana museum professionals—not necessarily restricted to Pacific descent but practitioners who are mindful and attuned to these contexts.

This framework articulates relational contexts and identifies vā between entities within a museum setting, inspired by critical reflection in relation to the drafting of the TLVPD and the first project it directly shaped, the PCAP. The TLVRMF demonstrates the ultimate directive of the TLV methodology, which is to produce transformative and empowering research outcomes.

The authors posit that TLV can only become embedded into museums properly when harmonious relationships are nurtured at multiple levels—up, across and inwards in the care of taonga, extending outwards to source communities. In adapting the TLVRPE for the museum, the principles remain the same, although the actors are different. In place of the Pacific researcher is the CRMMP. Instead of relational contexts within Pacific education research, the premise is relational museum operation for better praxis. Three guiding principles, adapted for the museum context, emphasise:

  1. nurturing the relationship between CRMMPs, museum managers and executive leadership
  2. translating local and practical knowledge into supported internal and culturally safe museum policies
  3. creating internal culture and practices that are transformational, generating tangible outcomes.

Conclusion

What Indigenous relational concepts are frequently used by Pacific peoples in Aotearoa New Zealand? How do these concepts relate to museology and the subfield of Pacific relational energy? What do conceptual frameworks of Indigenous relational understandings reveal about current museum practices and principles? In answer to such questions we find similarities and differences between definitions of relationality within institutions and those created by Indigenous peoples. These similarities and differences can be partly explained by the epistemic inclusion or exclusion of the dynamics of relationality as these are enacted by Indigenous peoples in the context of their various vā, outlined in the TLVRMF presented here. How museum practitioners use these vā—in particular, how they use them to guide policy—shapes the capacity of their institutions to understand the value and need to teu le vā—to nurture spiritual energy in practices of respect, reciprocity, responsibility and accountability (Anae, 2019). Consequently, a conceptual framework of museological vā surfaces transformations in ways of knowing as these move from spiritual energy to material expression, and reveals the relative capacity of existing institutions to address these transformations through, alternatively, disrupting and decolonising current museology praxis, shaping changes in existing museology strategies, and adjusting institutional policy and programming.

The TLVRMF outlines how TLV can be understood, valued and enacted in the museum context. This future-focused relational framework articulates relational contexts and identifies vā between entities and multi-level processes required to TLV within a museum setting. It addresses shortcomings arising in the implementation of the TLVPD, while also building on the momentum it has created. Overall, it demonstrates the ultimate directive of the TLV paradigm, which is to decolonise and re-Indigenise museum spaces to produce transformative and empowering outcomes for museum stakeholders, especially Pacific communities.

Soifua.

References

Airini, Anae M., Mila-Schaaf, K., Coxon, E., Mara, D. & Sanga, K. (2010). Teu le va: Relationships across research and policy in Pasifika education. Ministry of Education, Research Division. educationcounts.govt.nz/publications/pacific/teu-le-va-relationships-across-research-and-policy-in-pasifika-education.

Anae, M. (2005). Teu le va—‘new’ directions in thinking about ‘doing’ Pacific health research in New Zealand. Paper presented at the Centre for Pacific Studies, University of Auckland Pacific Scholars Postgraduate Seminar Series, Auckland.

Anae, M. (2007a, 1–2 November). Teu le va: Research that could make a difference to Pacific schooling in New Zealand [Keynote address]. Ministry of Education Symposium, Wellington.

Anae, M. (2007b). Teu le va: New directions in thinking about ‘doing’ Pacific health research. Public Health Research Forum. hrc.govt.nz/root/Publications/Pacific_Health_Research_Publications.html (site discontinued).

Anae, M. (2010a). Research for better Pacific schooling in New Zealand: Teu le va—A Samoan perspective. MAI Review, 1, 1–24.

Anae, M. (2010b). Teu le va: toward a ‘native’ anthropology. Journal of Pacific Studies. Special Issue: Genealogies: Articulating Indigenous Anthropology in/of Oceania, 33(2/3), 222–240.

Anae, M. (2016). Teu le va: A Samoan relational ethic. Knowledge Cultures, 4(3), 117–130.

Anae, M. (2017). Teu le va: A new research paradigm. In U. L. Va’ai & A. Casimira (Eds.), Relational hermeneutics: Decolonising the mindset and the Pacific Itulagi (pp. 85–100). University of the South Pacific and Pacific Theological College.

Anae, M. (2019). Pacific research methodologies and relational ethics. In Oxford research encyclopedia of education. Oxford University Press. doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.013.529.

Anae, M., Coxon, E., Mara, D., Wendt-Samu, T. & Finau, C. (2010). Pasifika education research guidelines [Final report]. Ministry of Education, New Zealand. wipo.int/export/sites/www/tk/en/databases/creative_heritage/docs/pasifika_education_guidelines.pdf.

Auckland War Memorial Museum. (2012). Future museum, Auckland War Memorial Museum: Master plan. Auckland War Memorial Museum.

Auckland War Memorial Museum. (2013). Teu le Vā: The Pacific dimension at Auckland Museum. Auckland War Memorial Museum.

Bergum, V. & Dossetor, J. B. (2005). Relational ethics: The full meaning of respect. University Publishing Group.

Christophe, A. (2016). Exhibiting connections, connecting exhibitions: Constructing trans-pacific relationships through museum displays in Oceania (2006–2016) [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of East Anglia.

Kaʻili, T. O. (2017). Marking indigeneity: The Tongan art of sociospatial relations. University of Arizona Press. doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1t89kr9.

Katz, R. (1993). The straight path: A story of healing and transformation in Fiji. Addison-Wesley.

Kreps, C. (2003). Liberating culture: Cross-cultural perspectives on museums, curation and heritage preservation. Taylor and Francis.

McCarthy, C. (2011). Museums and Māori: Heritage professionals, Indigenous collections, current practice. Left Coast Press.

Mead, S. M. (1983). Indigenous models of museums in Oceania. Museum International, 35(2), 98–101. doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0033.1983.tb00437.x.

Mila-Schaaf, K. (2011). Polycultural capital and the Pasifika second generation negotiating identities. Integration of Immigrants Programme.

Nabobo-Baba, U. (2005). Vugalei: Voices and silences of what and how we know: Indigenous Fijian epistemology and implications for education [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of Auckland.

National Digital Forum. (2017, 28 November). Barbara Makuati-Afitu—Pacific perspectives: Re-connecting Pacific communities with their collections [Video]. youtube.com/watch?v=gnUv15HDdhk&t=10s.

Samu Tui, L. (2020). The teu le va paradigm in contemporary museological praxis: An exploratory study [Unpublished BA (hons) thesis]. University of Auckland.

Samu Tui, L. (2021). Teu le Vā—Evolving relationships and practice in the wake of the Pacific Collection Access Project (PCAP). In R. Buchanan, A. Burns, J. Lundh & H. Rose (Eds.), Uneven bodies reader (pp. 24–28). Govett-Brewster Art Gallery.

Sanga, K. & Reynolds, M. (2017). To know more of what is and what it is not: Pacific research on the move. Pacific Dynamics: Journal of Interdisciplinary Research, 1(2), 198–204.

Schorch, P., McCarthy, C. & Hakiwai, A. (2016). Globalizing Māori museology: Reconceptualizing engagement, knowledge, and virtuality through Mana Taonga. Museum Anthropology, 39(1), 48–69. doi.org/10.1111/muan.12103.

Smith, L. T. (2012). Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples [2nd ed.]. Zed Books.

Thompson, S. & Thompson, N. (2002). The critically reflective practitioner. Palgrave Macmillan.

Verbos, A. K. & Humphries, M. (2014). A Native American relational ethic: An indigenous perspective on teaching human responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 123(1), 1–9. doi.org/10.1007/s10551-013-1790-3.

Wolfe, R. (2018). Oceania in the museum: Changing representations of Pacific collections [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of Auckland.


  1. 1 Tongan scholars talk about similar notions in their own Indigenous worldviews. Konai Helu-Thaman writes about the valued concept of vaa/vahaʻa/wah and its importance for enhancing interpersonal as well as intercultural understanding. Similarly, as seen in the work of Fijian scholars Unaisi Nabobo-Baba (2005) and Richard Katz (1993), the dimensions of tapu, sa and cursing aspects in Fijian culture are prominent in indigenous knowledges and beliefs in the area of traditional healing and wellbeing. Thus, there are resonances of TLV in and with other Pacific cultures (Anae, 2007b, 2019).

  2. 2 The framework summarises how the TLV approach can be understood, valued and acted on. It suggests how researchers can carry out more ‘robust’ research, and how policy-planners/funders/ministries can identify robust research measures with which to ensure that research outcomes inform policy (Airini et al., 2010, p. 17).

  3. 3 Following from Teather (cited in McCarthy, 2011) and Thompson and Thompson (2002).

  4. 4 Without reference to the TLVRPE, which was inspired by the Samoan Indigenous paradigm TLV, this strategic direction was part of a wider suite of documents, including He Korahi Maori, created in support of the museum’s long-term Future Museum strategy during the period 2012–15.

  5. 5 In 2023, this group, led by its third chairperson, was in its tenth year.

  6. 6 In the ten years since the TLVPD was put in place, there had been no formal evaluations or reviews of its efficacy and/or its practical impact; however, a researcher was contracted to undertake this work in the summer of 2022–23, and a refresh of the strategy was launched in 2024 (see Auckland Museum, (2024). ‘Matafatafa Aho Pacific Delivery Plan 2024–2029’).


Previous

Updated:  11 August 2026/ Responsible Officer:  / Page Contact: