Previous

Vā Moana

21

Vā theory and theorising beyond into the vahanoa: Post–human rhythmic conditions in Tu‘atonga

David Taufui Mikato Fa‘avae

In this chapter, the callings and projections of vā beyond is an expression of a desire to extend the assumed predominantly socially framed relatings of vā. Pacific peoples and communities appreciate life forces across entities in the world. This chapter is a consideration of vā’s post–human speculative potential. Post–humanist thought and theorising within the Euro-Western academe, conversely, has not always appreciated Indigenous concepts or framings grounded in the spiritual and unseen. My intention in this talatalanoa is to probe further into vā’s beyond–ness–like nature and rhythms in the vahanoa, a necessary sense–making that draws meaning from our Indigenous vernacular and embodied sensibilities. Vā’s potentialities lie in its simultaneity, through the considerations of its vibrant, dynamic, fluid and diverse relational interconnections across time–contexts, spaces and places. Such representations of vā can be expressed through the projections of its relational rhythms across and through physical, real–time or tangible spaces, beyond into the intangible, including the online and the more–than–human world time–contexts and spaces across the moana.

Tala fakatapu: Calling upon vā, unsettling vā–connections within settler–colonial Aotearoa New Zealand

The tala fakatapu (acknowledgement of people, place and sacred/spiritual space) is my desire to purposefully ground cultural acknowledgements. It is a deep and intimate appreciation and grounding of culturally ethical and spiritual practice. For Tongan people, the tala fakatapu is a hala‘anga (pathway) to connect with to‘utangata (generations of people) and fonua (land, place). I utilise tala fakatapu because I value vā and for its inclination to honour and ethically hold Indigenous relationality at the forefront of our shared ancestries, histories and positionings as Indigenous Moana/Pacific/Pasifika people dispersed across Te Moana-nui-ā-Kiwa. Tala fakatapu is creatively critical sense–making that is upfront about our positionalities. My tala fakatapu is motivated by the intention not to perpetuate harmful decisions that further oppress and dislocate or distance tangata whenua1 from their intimate connections with land and place–based relatings and knowings in the settler–colonial2 nation that is Aotearoa New Zealand.

Tapu moe Ta‘ehāmai

Acknowledgement and respect to the God/the unseen

Tapu mo Kuini Ngā Wai hono i te pō

Acknowledgement and respect to Kuini Ngā Wai hono i te pō

Tapu moe kelekele malumalu i Aotearoa

Acknowledgement and respect to the sacred land of Aotearoa

Tapu moe Tangata Whenua

Acknowledgement and respect to the people of the land

Tapu moe Ngāti Whātua-O-Ōrākei

Acknowledgement and respect to local iwi—Ngāti Whātua-O-Ōrākei

Tapu moe hou‘eiki moe ha‘a matāpule

Acknowledgement and respect to rangatira/chiefs

Tapu mo kimoutolu hono kotoa

Acknowledgement and respect to you all

On my father’s side (paternal), I am the grandson of Sione Taufui Mikato Fa‘avae (Ma‘ufanga Tongatapu and Satalo in Samoa) and Vika Lataheanga Fositā (Taunga Vava‘u, Pukotala Ha‘apai). On my mother’s side (maternal), I am the grandson of Sione P. Tomasi (Fuamotu) and Melenaite Vetekina Jennings (Niuafo‘ou and Angahā ‘Eua).

My fonua (placenta) is located in Alofi Niue, my place of birth. During the mid-1970s, my paternal grandparents made the decision to move to Niue, taking their children and their childrens’ partners in search of a better life. Though Tonga was always considered the homeland, their struggle to break away from economic hardship resulted in the difficult decision to migrate to the small island atoll. In pursuit of educational opportunities, my kinfolk moved again in the late 1980s, this time to Aotearoa New Zealand. It was there where I was mostly schooled and learned what it meant to be Tongan/Pasifika/Pacific in relation to other Pasifika/Pacific, Māori, including Palangi. It was there where my wife ‘Elenoa and I met and where our son Daniel’s fonua is grounded in Te Atatu Peninsula, in the west of Tāmaki Makaurau (Auckland).

Although my musings concerning vā may not connect entirely with most Tongan (or Pacific, Pasifika) people, they are inspired by vā’s rhythmic nature and flow—its beats and rhythms (i.e. tā) beyond normalised perceived knowings and doings (Fa‘avae, 2021a). I unfold vā’s rhythms further in earlier publications (see Fa‘avae, 2021a, 2021b). The Lea faka–Tonga concepts I draw from in this chapter are by no means loloto (deep, in-depth) or fālahi (wide, expansive). Nonetheless, they are an inspiration because they offer a hala‘anga that enables me to come a little closer to my ancestors and their ways of philosophising in the world. The call to enact fakatapu is the unsettling of taken-for-granted familiarity as tangata ‘o e moana—(people of the moana/Oceania).

When enacting fakatapu, one calls forth vā and its life force and energy: a call towards the vahanoa, beyond the normalised understandings of vā as predominantly social relations. Ka‘ili (2017, p. 121) refers to the vahanoa as the ‘open sea space between Islands’. For me, vahanoa as an open, expansive and unknown space has characteristics that offer more potential for the re-imagining of vā in the diaspora. The prefix faka– denotes ‘likeness, causation (causing or allowing to), supplying, having’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 24). Tapu has various meanings: sacred, holy, unlawful or forbidden (Churchward, 2015). When bounded together as fakatapu, the word becomes a verb linked to the respectful practice of tauhi vā (honouring and nurturing relationships and connections) with spiritual/sacred beings/entities. Doing fakatapu in this chapter, from the settler–colonial system’s confines and structures in Aotearoa New Zealand, requires an unsettling of our assumed comfort and familiarity as migrants/settlers on whenua not ancestrally ours. Engaging in fakatapu is a commitment that connects me, the writer/author; you, the reader; and us—as well as our shared responsibility to ensure that Indigenous or minority peoples’ knowledges and ways of being and becoming in the world are appreciated, not undermined or ignored. I have chosen to italicise Tongan terms and ideas in this chapter mainly for visual emphasis, and to aid the flow of reading, as well as to encourage readers to pause and consider the vibrant, dynamic and fluid epistemological and ontological conditions that shape Tongan sense–making of vā’s beyond–ness–like nature.

Vā is often called upon to connect relationally. Though many have framed vā in relational doings, primarily as a socially centred ideal and practice, my view is that vā is more. Theorising vā beyond being predominantly a social practice or concern (including social problems), thus requiring social change, is an opportunity to extend vā’s intersectionality framings (Collins, 2019; Fa‘avae, 2021b). Stretching vā beyond its social intersectionalities is an opportunity to (re)imagine vā and its critical inquiry and praxis possibilities and responsibilities for transformative social change in tuʻatonga. For instance, how vā as an ethical space of negotiating interconnections can shape the way in which talanoa, as a mode of critical dialogue and praxis, is best employed to activate critical interrogation and inquiry with other entities within the more–than–human world. For example, how talanoa can be employed meaningfully in research to capture vā’s meaning–making between people and texts, classrooms, architectures/buildings, paintings, artefacts, cultural heirlooms (i.e. fala/mat, ngatu/tapa cloth, etc.), vaka/canoe, rivers, mountains, motu/Islands, fonua/land and more.

If post–humanism focuses on ways of displacing historical notions that humans are central to existence, then what is the role of Indigenous Moana theories and concepts in this task? The central questions that direct this talatalanoa (ongoing conversation) are:

  1. what shapes vā’s possibilities beyond socially framed conditions?
  2. how is vā projected across places and spaces in tu‘atonga (the diaspora)?

The term ‘Indigenous’ carries historical colonial legacies that position ‘native(s)’ as deficient. Māori educational philosopher and scholar Georgina Stewart (2018, p. 740) links her articulation of indigeneity (with a small ‘i’) to a ‘place–based human ethnic culture that has not migrated from its homeland and is not a settler or colonial population’. As an adjective, Indigenous refers to a ‘person, language, culture, or some aspect of culture’ (Stewart, 2018, p. 740). Sāmoa’s former head of state Tui Atua Tupua Tamasese Ta‘isi Efi posits that ‘indigenous spirituality lives and breathes in our Pacific person and personhood’ (Tui Atua, 2017, p. xi). Core to Indigenous/Indigeneity in the Moana (or Pacific) are ‘our names and our naming; our knowing, being and seeing; and our identities and sense of belonging’ (Tui Atua, 2017, p. xi). Naming and articulating vā and its forms within Te Moananui-ā-Kiwa will embrace the transcending nature of vā; this is indicative of its temporal and spatial tendencies that often wayfind beyond physical, spiritual and cyber boundaries into the unknown (Fa‘avae, 2021b).

Through the ‘ontological turn’, the Euro-Western canon of philosophy provides opportunities for worlded ecologies to be taken more seriously beyond anthropocentrism (a view that humans are at the centre of knowing) (Matapo & McFall-McCaffery, 2022). The ontological turn is defined as the ‘convergence of post–humanism with post–anthropocentrism’ (Bignall & Braidotti, 2019, p. 1) and calls for more ‘radical epistemologies that aim at a more inclusive practice of becoming-human’ (Bignall & Braidotti, 2019, p. 1). My intention to unpack vā’s beyond–ness–like tendencies is inspired by Matapo and McFall-McCaffery’s (2022, p. 129) invitation to draw from vā and its knowledge ecology to ‘destabilise the humanist-centric position that knowledge belongs only to human beings’. This means enabling unfoldings of vā beyond as a social construct, eliciting from its connections to fonua (land), moana (ocean), langi (sky) and noa (something unknown or yet to be known, or unknown space). In doing so, we take into careful consideration vā and its conceptualisations beyond human-centred rationalising. These considerations open generative talatalanoa about non-anthropocentric epistemologies from Oceania.

Post–humanism and the post–human condition

When adopting Malone and Kuby’s (2022, p. 98) definition of the term ‘post’ as ‘a response to humanism or the logic of humanism’, this opens new thinking about what it means to be human in this lively, ever-changing world. The post–human condition is referred to as a critical epoch, a shift in academic theorising concerning humanity’s role. Post–humanism reflects an intellectual era that encourages alternative ways of being with and relating to nature. Rosi Braidotti (2013, pp. 1–2) states:

the posthuman condition introduces a qualitative shift in our thinking about what exactly is the basic unit of common reference for our species, our polity and our relationship to the other inhabitants of this planet.

In response to the Anthropocene, post–humanism should not be limited to a mere critique of humanism but embrace the challenge of displacing anthropocentrism,3 its ontological imaginings reflecting the ‘intricate web of interrelations that mark the contemporary subjects’ relationship to their multiple ecologies’ (Braidotti, 2013, p. 98). This new ontological perspective ‘shifts from conceptions of objects and bodies as occupying distinct and delimited spaces, and instead sees human bodies and all other material, social and abstract entities as relational’, and these ‘assemblages of relations develop in unpredictable ways’ (Fox & Alldred, 2014, p. 401, original emphasis).

Continental post–humanism has often ignored the prior existence of Indigenous knowledge (Bignall & Rigney, 2019). Although post–humanism has allowed a shift to de–centre humanist knowings, very few writers have taken a dive into sacred and spiritual meaning–making through Oceania canonising. Oceania critical theologian scholar of Tongan heritage Jione Havea (2017, p. 4) argues for postcolonial criticisms that enable intentional confrontings, seeking ‘some kind of relief’ for marginalised peoples. Another critical theologian of Tongan heritage, Nasili Vaka‘uta (2010) conceptualised Lau faka–tu‘a and tu‘a–wise as modes of alternative interpretations of the Bible that align with Indigenous, local and culturally relevant perspectives. From an Indigenous Māori lens, Carl Mika (2017, p. 2) argues that all things in the world are constituted by each other:

In indigenous thought, as I go on to say; that idea is a material entity … that is constituted by all other things in the world; it is as equal to the situation as my own neurological decision to think is. So, it should come at as no surprise—to me while writing, or to anyone else—that an idea should decide of its own accord to seemingly drift away and allow another to take its place … this ability to speculate is itself the convergence of both the human and non-human worlds, the latter including the world of the idea.

Sacred and spiritual meaning–making honours ecology as living in–relationship. Upolu Lumā Vaai (2021, p. 228), a theologian scholar of Samoan heritage, positions ‘ecorelationality’ as a critical consciousness that:

treats ecology not as an academic discipline or an interaction between religion and nature as ecotheology sometimes tends to push, but rather as a living relationship. Ecology does not come with a static body of knowledge. Rather it comes with relationship.

Like post–humanism, ecorelationality provides a shift away from a human-centric understanding and forces us to consider and wonder how the more–than–human world embraces vā as a living entity and its conditions being in–relationship eco–relationally with other entities in the world.

Vaai’s (2021) application of ‘ecorelational’ brings to the fore the complex interdependence of entities across ecologies, opening rich talatalanoa about ‘more-than-human ways of knowing, being, and acting’ (Bignall & Rigney, 2019, p. 159). Our tauhi vā responsibilities, as Pacific scholars in the diaspora intentionally working with Indigenous ideas4 like vā as well as thinking within Euro-Western philosophical canons, provide an ethics of care with which to reconceptualise post–human critical thinking. We are thus urged to ‘situate [ourselves] in and as part of the world, defending an idea of knowledge production as embedded, embodied, affective and relational’ (Braidotti, 2019, p. 143), as well as ecological, sacred and spiritually inspired (Vaai, 2021). Critical post–human scholars seek to unsettle binaries, decentre the human and problematise historical notions of human exceptionalism by ‘challenging the simplistic dichotomies of animal/human, nature/culture, object/subject’ (Malone & Kuby, 2022, p. 98)—that is, by calling attention to and disrupting the Cartesian divide between humans and others, the mind–body divide, and the divide between conscious thought or logic between humans and other more–than–human entities (i.e. fonua, moana, etc.).

Fakaivia i tu‘atonga: Post–human becoming as rhythmic speculations of personhood in tu‘atonga

My response to ‘humanism’ or the logic of humanism is informed by the diasporic contexts of tu‘atonga, specifically from–in–with Aotearoa New Zealand whenua (land, place). For me as a Tongan father, husband, uncle, educator and researcher, post–human becoming is grounded in critical yet hopeful speculations and an awareness of the histories I have inherited and continue to carry with me in my life. I utilise the extended hyphen (–) as a symbolic space of struggle, of the interconnected encounters associated with vā’s simultaneity, which hence require interrogation, negotiation and sense–making. Post–human becoming is not an afterthought for Indigenous Moana or Pacific scholars,5 but rather a space in which we can (re)engage with our sense–making of Indigeneity.6 Our decolonial intentions seek to privilege and centre Indigenous Moana–based thought in our meaning–making. Yet, at the same time, we are mindful not to perpetuate oppressive practices that could further marginalise other Indigenous communities whose whenua we occupy as migrants or settlers and whose governments are still constituted by their (neo)colonial rulers.

Indigenous7 peoples and communities have long understood their vā with nature and the environment. Vaai (2021, p. 228) speculates that the ‘earth has its own ecological system that is beyond human imagination and should be respected’. Many Oceania Island creation stories (i.e. cosmogonies) depict our coming ‘into being through cosmological relationships … the human being is perceived as a child of a cosmic union’. The construct of human identity is defined by this cosmic genealogy, for example:

I am not an individual; I am an integral part of the cosmos. I share divinity with my ancestors, the land, the seas and the skies … I belong to my family and my family belongs to me. I belong to my village and my village to me. (Vaai, 2021, pp. 228–229)

The term fakaivia i tu‘atonga (inspiration in the diaspora) refers to experiences of ongomālie (inspirational feelings) and vā–māfana (heart–warming connections) through Tongan people’s utilisation of their personhood becomings and ancestral knowledges and practices on other whenua or fonua8 in the diaspora of Aotearoa New Zealand (Ka‘ili, 2017; Manu‘atu, 2000). Vaai and Nabobo-Baba (2017, p. 1) claim that there is no distinct or ‘single conception of personhood in the Pacific, with all its spaces, countries, and territories’. They ground personhood in the Samoan concept of itulagi, the lifeworld of the people, their cultures and languages, which help to shape people’s personhood ‘as they live, see and imagine it to be’ (Vaai & Nabobo-Baba, 2017, p. 1). Rethinking and reconstructing Pacific personhood becomings, they appeal to relationality, which they believe is ‘fundamental to the faith and cultural traditions of the Pacific Islands’ (Vaai & Nabobo-Baba, 2017, p. 1). Itulagi, as the lifeworld of the people, takes into consideration the human being’s becoming as an intimate yet intricate part of its lifeworld. Matapo (2016) speculates ‘becoming posthuman’ as a new and alternative framing and conceptualisation of the human subject within Pasifika research. She deliberately uses ‘becoming Pasifika researcher’ to open research seeing, doing and knowing to difference and multiplicity (Matapo, 2016, p. 6), rather than just re–produce meanings in analysis.

Tā–vā’s place in vā’s beyond–ness–like nature

The Indigenous Moana tā–vā (time–space) theory of reality was first introduced to the academic world in 2001 by Hūfanga ‘Ōkusitino Māhina at a philosophy conference in Chico, California (Ka‘ili et al., 2017). Tā has various meanings, for example, to hit or strike the beat (pulsate, or rhythm) of one’s heart: ‘‘Oku fēfē ‘a e tā ‘o hono nima? (how is his pulse?)’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 436). Tā also means to draw a picture or object, to photograph or ‘to perform’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 436).

Ka‘ili et al. (2017) deliberately and strategically fakahoa (couple) tā–vā—this allows Moana scholars to consider the significance of tā (time) and vā (space) in their simultaneity, as well as the associated critical and in–depth sense–making and meaning–making. One key ontological and epistemological tenet of the tā–vā theory of reality is that ‘the inseparability of tā (time) and vā (space), like fuo (form) and uho (content), renders reality of tā–vā (time–space) to be four-dimensional and not three-dimensional’ (Ka‘ili et al., 2017, p. 3). Their descriptions of fuo and uho are largely framed in relation to art, architecture and faiva (see also Refiti, 2015). Fuo or form, in these time–contexts, reflects the arrangement of shapes in relation to the whole art or architecture piece, and uho or content consists of the elements created to convey key messages, or character, in relation to the whole. When making sense of vā–connections, fuo (form) and uho (content) conditions simultaneously inter–play. Fuo can also refer to shape, and to something that will lead to many or more (i.e. Na‘e fuo fiha ho fu‘u pīsi? How many fruit did your peach tree bear?), and uho can also mean core or centre (Churchward, 2015). To capture vā’s beyond–ness–like nature, I consider here the arrangements of vā–tā–fuo–uho (vā’s responsibilities, place and positioning in relation to time, form, content, shape, fruits) and their simultaneous interconnections (see Figure 21.1). This means that, when speculation begins with vā (space in between) as a central frame of analysis, the arrangement of tā, fuo and uho directs the ways in which vā can be projected, expressed, manifested or embodied across entities/places/spaces.

Figure 21.1: Vā’s rhythms and beyond–ness–like nature within, between and across entities

Figure 21.1: Vā’s rhythms and beyond–ness–like nature within, between and across entities.

Source: Author.

Vā, vaha, vaha‘a, vahanoa: Etymology and root words

Tevita Ka‘ili (2017, p. 121) defines vaha as ‘space between, space apart, space at sea; or long spatial distance’. The term vaha‘a translates literally as an ‘intervening space or time’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 528). When vaha‘a is deconstructed, individually the terms mean va (distance between or apart; attitudes, feelings, relations) and ha‘a (to be affected with) (Churchward, 2015). When coupled, vaha‘a has several meanings, ‘(1) intervening space or time; (2) relationship, mutual feelings, or attitude toward each other; and (3) short spatial distance’ (Ka‘ili, 2017, p. 121). As root words in Lea Faka–Tonga (Tongan language), vaha and vaha‘a highlight how vā as a life force can be projected across spaces and places and manifest in entities—material9 and non–material, seen and unseen, animate and inanimate.10 Although Ka‘ili (2023) does not distinguish entities as either animate or inanimate, his claim is that all things (or entities) in the world are living, based on the ecorelational worldview and practice of Talamalu ‘o e fonua—associated and grounded in Tongan cosmogonies or creation stories.

Vā is often theorised as predominantly socio–relational. Churchward (2015, p. 528) translates vā as a ‘feeling’, possessing laumālie (spirit). As a spirit or life force, vā is shaped by the connections (and disconnections) and distance (or space) between entities within. Vā’s rhythms, as a life force, manifest in entities like the fonua, moana (ocean), akau (tree), langi (sky) and more. For example, vā’s beyond–ness–like nature is evident in concepts like vaha‘ataimi (space or interval of time), vahaloa (wide expanse, especially of the sea), vahanoa (open sea space between islands), or vahatoka (space left between yam mounds) (see Ka‘ili, 2017, p. 121), to name a few. The idea of vahanoa, as used in this chapter is key to furthering vā’s potentialities. The notion of noa has several meanings, defined as ‘any kind of, common, ordinary … or purely imaginary’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 379). When vaha and noa are fakahoa, or coupled together, vahanoa is described as an open and expansive space, often unknown to human understanding. From a Tongan perspective, these Tongan concepts show vā’s potentialities—embodied not only in time–spaces in which people–to–people relations are present, but also in time–spaces in which fonua–moana or island–moana (see vahanoa), or yam–fonua (see vahatoka) relations can be understood.

Place, space and time: Vā’s rhythms, life force and spirit

For Frances Koya Vaka‘uta, the triadic framework of place–space–time is useful to understanding vā’s condition and the negotiations of cyberspace relations across place and time. She notes that ‘the triad of place, space and time … is integral to a deeper understanding of context, community and individual motives, beliefs, attitudes, behaviours and practices’ (Koya Vaka‘uta, 2017, p. 65). Place may be delineated into tangible (i.e. physical or geographic sites) and intangible (i.e. social constructs or worldviews, including cultural markers or boundaries delineating cultural status, relationships and the basic rules for engagement) sites or locations (Koya Vaka‘uta, 2017). Place can also be connected to or with land. This intimate and intricate connection between the human self/selves is developed in place–space–time–based talatalanoa. The diagram in Figure 21.1 shows how multiple spaces of interconnection intersect and how vā can shape (and be shaped by) the simultaneous encounters with/between places and time. The spatial arrangements of entities within the vā space, for instance, can be organised and understood based on the distance, proximity or closeness between entities within a particular context or place (i.e. people, mango tree, classroom in Tongatapu, the main Island of Tonga). These arrangements shape how vā or interconnected rhythms are expressed and embodied by human beings emotionally, and manifested spiritually by the more–than–human world. These simultaneous vā rhythms represent the vibrant, dynamic and fluid nature of relational space, and how vā as a life force (i.e. entity) seeks to find balance or harmony between other existing entities that occupy and share such relational space within a place or time–context (Ka‘ili et al., 2017; Kalavite, 2017; Seve-Williams, 2017; Tu‘itahi, 2005).

A story of vā’s shifting nature

Vaai and Nabobo-Baba (2017, p. 5) claim that:

decolonisation should focus not only on reinstating the sacredness and dignity of ecology but also on how the human economy [what people do and think, while addressing the needs of humanity as a whole] should be reframed in light of such connectivity and sacredness.

In this vein, the following story offers insights into vā’s shifting nature and potentialities beyond.

Maile and Laukau always liked hanging out under the mango tree at their primary school in Tonga. It was a place of comfort, a place they first met at when they started Kalasi Taha (Class 1) in 2017. In their mathematics class, Maile often struggled with the work, and it was a place where her teacher continued to remind her of her incapabilities. During lunch break, Maile met Laukau at their favourite spot under the mango tree. Maile’s fears from her maths class did not linger in her thoughts anymore. But when her mathematics teacher walked past them on his way to the staffroom, the feelings of fear came back. As the maths teacher disappeared, the mango tree and her friend Laukau made Maile feel better again.

How does this story make us think about the conditions of vā? How is vā carried, echoed, embodied by the people in the story? Does the mango tree contribute to the conditions of vā connections? Do places already possess vā, or forms of vā, even before people arrive or enter? Although I do not answer these questions directly in this chapter, I ask them to ue‘e loto mo e fakakaukau, ignite feeling and thinking around vā’s possibilities and potentialities.

Vā–projections: Beyond human speculation

‘Oku hā fēfē mai e fōtunga mo e ngaahi ongo ‘a e vā ‘ihe vahanoa? What does vā look, sound and feel like beyond? The term hā fēfē relates to how entities seemingly appear or come into sight or to the mind (Churchward, 2015). To ask this of the vahanoa is an Oceania–centred speculation—one that does not seek a definitive answer, nor an expectation that the vahanoa will succumb to our human desires to know all that is in the world. This way of Oceania–centred speculation into vā’s beyondness is tapu (sacred) because it honours vā as a living entity (Dyck et al., 2022; Iosefo et al., 2021; Suaalii-Sauni, 2017; Ualesi, 2021). Allen et al. (2022) explore the vā between educators’ pedagogical decisions and practices, and the colonial structures of the schooling classroom context in Aotearoa New Zealand. In a similar way, my exploration of vā’s projections is an attempt to understand the relational rhythms carried across into the online or cyberspace. The notion of space is often difficult to define; when two or more points are noted within the space, this makes it easier for the human mind to describe space based on the distance or closeness between one point from another and in relation to others within that particular space (Koya Vaka‘uta, 2017). The cyberspace, however, is often not so easily defined. The Tongan idea of vahaope is used to refer to the online or cyberspace, whereby ope is an intransitive verb meaning to ‘overlap or project beyond the edge or [perceived] end; to hang down over’ (Churchward, 2015, p. 395). Vahaope, therefore, refers to an open, expansive, yet unknowable space online whereby projections of physical, real–time and tangible relational connections move beyond into the intangible, online or cyberspace.

Vā–projections are the perceived expressions of vā as extensions of physical and tangible connection–making into the online space of engagement and learning. In vā’s case as an entity, or a life spirit, its projections are the felt, ignored or missed emotions experienced when striving to nurture the vā relational space online with other people and entities (Fa‘avae, 2021a, 2021b). My positioning of vā–projections within tauhi vā (nurturing ethical and respectful social relations and connections) and tauhi fonua (maintaining sacred and spiritual relations and connections with place, people and the spiritual world) (Ka‘ili, 2017) are opportunities to explore the multiple angles of ethical relations as we extend our physical and real–time desire to utilise digital tools to conveniently improve how we engage, interact and communicate with people, ancestors and other entities across time–contexts, places (i.e. geographic) and online spaces (Fehoko et al. 2022). These were evident in how kāinga (extended families) utilised digital tools and online social media during Covid-19 restrictions in Aotearoa New Zealand to not only farewell their dearly departed loved ones, but also connect their families in Australia, the US and other parts of the world to the sad occasion. Similarly, Zoom was used to conduct church services across Tonga, Australia and other parts of the world.

The feminist and post–humanist scholar Donna Haraway (2008, p. 3) claims that ‘we learn to be worldly from grappling with, rather than generalizing from, the ordinary’. The question as to whether vā has life beyond human imagination and representation is a critical philosophical concern, prompting criticism to grapple–with the ordinary, that is, the locally specific and domesticated ways in which Moana/Pacific/Pasifika scholars have predominantly framed vā as a social construct. To question vā’s becoming, which is a novel exploration, requires us to consider it as a living entity, framed within–beyond the ‘post’ era and condition. I draw from Lea faka–Tonga and Tongan concepts to guide and support me in the search for relevant tu‘atonga meaning–making.

Ko e hā nai e lea ko eni, ko e vā?

‘Oku vā–lelei mo fiemālie ‘a fakapotopoto

‘Oku fai ‘i laumālie e tala-‘uhinga ‘a vā–ofí

Ka ko e hā e mahu‘inga ‘o vā–tamaki, vā–kovi, mo e vā–mama‘ó na?

Vā—‘oku ou mālie‘ia ‘i ho‘o ngaahi fotu na

Vā—‘oku ongomālie mai ho‘o tou‘angá

Vā—ko hoku lotó ia ke talanoa‘i mo fefīliaki ho‘o ngaahi talá na.

What is this word, vā?

Wise people care for good and peaceful relations/connections

It is within spiritual work that you will find close relations/connections

What is the significance of distorted connections, bad relations and disconnectedness?

Vā—I am inspired by your forms

Vā—I hear good things about your workings

Vā—our intention is to story and think about your genealogy

Binaries within science and dualisms within philosophy often emphasise the quality or condition of oppositions in understanding. Tā–vāist scholars favour oppositional thought because it provides an opportunity to fakahoa and thereby interrogate dualities of meaning. When fakahoa takes place (i.e. the coupling of words or ideas) the notion of fenāpasi is often used to understand the outcome of the union. Churchward (2015, pp. 147, 169) defines the prefix fe– as ‘united or simultaneous action, collaborative, reciprocal, competitive’ and fenāpasi as an intransitive verb meaning ‘to occur at the same time’. This indicates that, through fenāpasi, there is opportunity to not only explore the consequence of the simultaneous encounter between ideas, including entities, but also the fruits of such a union. As noted earlier, fuo is used to mean shape but it also indicates something that will lead to many or more (i.e. Na‘e fuo fiha ho fu‘u moli? How many fruit did your orange tree bear?) (Churchward, 2015). Given that Indigenous Pacific people were never anthropocentric to begin with (Matapo & McFall-McCaffery, 2022; Vaai, 2021), I argue that Indigenous conceptualisations can further extend relationality and relational connections beyond dominant post–humanist traditions and oppositional framings. Moving vā speculations beyond the human (or humanism) is to highlight Indigenous Moana/Pacific wholism through a worlded philosophy centred on ecorelationality and an ethical onto–epistemological view of reality and Pacific personhood, a unique understanding that all things in the world are intricately and intimately inter–connected in complex, yet perplexed ways (Mika, 2017; Vaai, 2021).

Vā crossing boundaries—A tu‘atonga concern

As Moana/Pacific/Pasifika people are becoming more mobile and global travellers, vā’s presence and relevance continues to cross geographical and epistemological boundaries. The Samoan scholar Lana Lopesi (2021, p. 63) developed a theory of Moana Cosmopolitanism to explore ‘an identity rooted ancestrally in the Moana and routed globally’. She contends that ‘Moana Cosmopolitanism and Moana Cosmopolitan Imaginaries co-constitute each other. Meaning that one’s cosmopolitan experience determines how one imagines their subjectivity’ (Lopesi, 2021, p. 83). Projections of vā as expressions of felt, ignored or missed emotions across tu‘atonga as well as through cyberspace highlight how a Tongan person negotiates and navigates complex, dynamic, fluid and ongoing mobilities, as well as an economic, political, spiritual and collective responsibilities to their kāinga (extended families) and communities.

Vā continues to take form between places and spaces in tu‘atonga. I first came across tu‘atonga through Melenaite Taumoefolau (2021, n.p.) Tongan linguist and scholar:

Ko kitautolu Tonga, ‘oku tau pehē tautolu ko ‘etau fo‘i culture pe. Pea ko etau mo‘ui faka–Tonga pe ko ‘etau tui faka–Tonga pe koia kae ngalo ‘a tu‘atonga ia … ‘Ae hū mai koe ‘a e human rights ‘ihe 1948, na‘a nau omai ai e tu‘utu‘uni koe kihe human rights—‘totonu e tangata’. Aia pea hanga e au o fakafōtunga ia, hange ia hatau hū ki ha fonua e taha. Ko tautolu Tonga ‘oku totonu ketau ‘ilo ‘oku iai etau fonua ‘e taha—ko tu‘atonga ia. Koe human rights, ‘oku iai ‘a e totonu ia pea moe faka‘ei‘eiki ‘ihe kakai kehe. Aia koe ‘uhinga‘aki ia koe palopalema koe, pe fakamali‘i fēfē? Etau tui kalisitiane ‘oku ikai ketau tali ‘ihe tui e taha. ‘Oku ikai ketau tali ‘a e kakai ‘oku gay. ‘E fakamali‘i fēfē‘i kae hili ia, koe kakai koia ‘oku iai enau totonu. Ka koe kehekehe pe koe kehekehe fakatui pe. Ka ‘oku totonu ketau omai.

As Tongan people, we think it’s our culture mainly. And our Tongan ways of living are what we believe it’s all about, yet we forget tu‘atonga … The arrival of human rights in 1948, they gave us directions about human rights—‘the rights of human beings’. My framing, it’s like going to a new place. As Tongan people, we need to know of our other place—that is tu‘atonga. The human rights, it has truth and value for other people. That’s the problem, how do you marry them? Our Christian beliefs and the non-acceptance of other values and beliefs. Our non-acceptance of gay people. How can they be bounded together [Tongan values/Christian beliefs and gay rights], yet they have their own rights. But the difference is in our different beliefs. But we need to consider it.11

Tu‘atonga is not only symbolic of a physical space. It also represents a knowledge space where Tongan bodies of knowledge, ideas and practices encounter other foreign lore, and come to dwell as metaphoric or figurative knowledge within dominant Euro-Western ideas. Here, Tongan vernacular and worldviews are learning to adapt, morph, evolve, weave, integrate—often alongside other bodies of knowledge.

Mika is known for his provocative and ‘out-of-the-box’ speculations. At his 2021 keynote during the Oceania Comparative and International Education Society conference, Mika positioned wā as being more than time and space for Māori. He argued that thinking of wā as time and space imposes an orderly and linear frame of analysis, and with it a ‘colonising gloss’ that separates ‘things in the world from each other’ (Mika, 2021, n.p). To ensure wā’s holistic nature is retained, he adopted Henri Bergson’s (2007) term ‘duration’, a measurement of the trajectory of a body in motion. According to Bergson (2007, p. 2), ‘time is mobility. The line is made, it is complete; time is what is happening, and more than that, it is what causes everything to happen’. For Mika (2021, n.p.), wā can refer to the ‘overwhelming convergence of all things in the world: they are in the sphere of the Now. In Now-ness, things are stupendous rather than manageable: excessive rather than knowable.’ In wā, as with several other Māori phenomena, ‘the self is repositioned within the dramatic current of the All rather than ejected from it’ (Mika, 2021, n.p.).

It is within the grounded and generative conditions of mālie (inspiringly impressive, or ongomālie as excessive soul–fulfilling excitement) and māfana (excessive internal warmth and heartwarming) that I embrace the notions of stupendous/impressiveness and excessiveness/extending beyond the limits so that vā’s possibilities are visibilised, enabled and activated.

Vā’s possibilities: A space that binds entities together

Albert Wendt (1999, p. 402) defines vā as a space that relates and binds separate entities together in the ‘Unity-that-is-All, the space that is context, giving meaning to things’. Within the vā space, ‘the meanings change as the relationships and the contexts change’ (Wendt, 1999, p. 402). In communal cultures, the vā space that binds relies on ethical conditions guided and maintained by, for example, ia teu le vā (Samoan: cherish, nurse, care for the vā, the relationships) and tauhi vā (Tongan: nurturing and caring for vā) (Wendt, 1999). Iʻuogafa Tuagalu (2008) has explored the difference between social space (i.e. vā fealoa’i) and worship space (i.e. vā tapua’i) within the context of the Samoan village. Tuagalu (2008, p. 118, original emphasis) asked an important question: ‘what can the va teach me?’ A key point is that vā fealoaloaʻi and vā tapuaʻi are ‘closely entwined … The spiritual connections are fundamental and seem to underlie and act as foundation to all permutations of va relations between people’ (Tuagalu, 2008, p. 118). When adopting Wendt’s (1999) definition of vā as a space that binds entities together (i.e. fonua and moana, or land and people), it makes sense to suggest that vā is active as a life force or spirit with/between entities that occupy space together. This suggests that, as part of entities, vā is already present in spaces. The uncertainty is how vā as a life force or spirit occupies and flows across the relational space. In other words, when humans enter the vā space between the mango tree and the fonua (land), for instance, the life force within that space can shift, thus changing vā’s flow and relational condition in ways that are projected as vālelei (good relations), vāmāfana (heartwarming connections), vākovi (bad relations), vātamaki (disharmonious relations), vāmama‘o (distanced connections), vāofi (close connections) and more (Ka‘ili, 2017; Paea et al., 2023; Tu‘imana, 2022).

Vā’s possibilities lie in the relational flow across entities within the space of connecting. The flow of vā can be projected between fonua–moana–tangata. The holistic approach to capturing vā’s rhythms and projections within and across time–contexts, places and spaces provide generative ways of being–knowing–seeing–feeling–doing vā’s possibilities (Fa‘avae, 2021a, 2021b). These possibilities are indicated in some important Tongan expressions: Vā moe fonua (relations with land, people and place), for example, attributes connections and relationships with/between land (Fijian: vanua, Samoan: fanua, Māori: whenua, Rarotongan: ‘enua) (Tu‘itahi, 2005) and its people. Tongan people make sense of wellbeing through the ‘intricate web of [inter]connected, on-going relationship between the entire physical and social environment and humanity, and between man (and women) and his fellow human beings’ (Tu‘itahi, 2005, p. 19). Taufe‘ulungaki (2004, p. 3) defines health as the wellbeing ‘of the whole person: that is his/her spiritual, mental and physical wellbeing, which is an interpretation that is consistent with the Pacific’s holistic worldviews’. For her, fonua symbolises the community in Tonga (and other parts of the Pacific), highlighting the intimate, intricate, interdependent and reciprocal vā or relations that bind communities, individuals, nature and the spiritual world together. Vā moe fonua, vā moe tangata, vā moe loto and vā moe moana share mutual (and opposing) connections that symbolise vā’s fluid and dynamic relational tendencies, often embodied and manifested in various forms (i.e. uho/core or content, fuo/form or shape, tā/to perform) by other entities sharing space or place

Vā moe to‘utangata (intergenerational connections), hohoko (genealogy) and tukufakaholo (inheritance) are linked to intergenerationalism. Vā moe to‘utangata refers to the philosophising and theorising of the layered interconnections between generations of people, their stories of vā with/between ancestors and other entities around them. Hohoko and tukufakaholo are traditions and conditions of vā–relatings that depend on the arrangements of to‘utangata across fonua in the moana. Such intergenerational arrangements are rhythmically rooted in our local vā–relatings and globally routed through our ongoing mobilities with/between places and spaces.

My paternal grandfather, Sione Taufui Mikato Faʻavae, was the youngest of three brothers and sibling among a family of seven. He was the reason why my parents and uncles and aunts left Tonga in search of a better life. He gave a lot and served a lot for his brothers, siblings and kāinga. There were instances when his obligation to his older brother and kāinga did not always align with my grandmother’s views of what was best for their own little family. Being from Tonga, a nation in which the eldest son inherited his father’s land, those to follow would not directly benefit from the tukufakaholo (inheritance). In terms of social status, we are tu‘a, of the commoner class. As a carpenter by trade, and despite not receiving formal training, my grandfather acquired his carpentry skills mostly through hands-on experience. He helped build churches in Tonga and willingly volunteered to do this because of his love for his older brother who was one of the church leaders at the time. The move to the Island of Niue from Tongatapu, Tonga’s main island, in the mid-1970s was a chance to not only build economic stability that was not available at the time, but also to provide further opportunities for his children and grandchildren to come. The late Epeli Hau‘ofa (1994) also alluded to why the search for economic opportunities was a goal for many Pacific families who left their ancestral home nations to other places in Te Moana-nui-ā-Kiwa. My kāinga’s migratory movement, however, did not stop there. My own father, Sio Milemoti Fa‘avae, followed a similar life pattern. We lived among our kāinga in Niue. I was ohi (adopted) by my grandfather and my aunt, my dad’s younger sister. My father too is a hard-working man. He used to be an automotive mechanic by trade. He also has a love for music and art.

The talatalanoa provocations shared in this chapter are ongoing, and so is vā’s possible becoming in tu‘atonga. From a mo‘ui lelei (flourishing and thriving harmoniously in the world) and tauhi fonua (nurturing ethical relations) life philosophy Tongan worldview (see Ka‘ili, 2017; Tu‘itahi, 2005), variants of vā—like veitapui (sacred space), vahaope (space beyond, cyber or online space) and vahanoa (open sea space between islands)—affirm its beyond–ness–like nature. From a worlded philosophy (Mika, 2017) vantage point, vā’s rhythms are projections of the flow and shift of a life force within its relational ecology—shaped by the arrangements of entities/objects. From an Indigenous Moana/Pacific/Pasifika as well as critical post–human lens, the vā rhythms are projections of the interconnections between entities in nature (i.e. motu and moana).

To think and frame vā mainly as a social construct can ignore the ebbs and flows of vā as an entity, having vibrant, dynamic and fluid projections and rhythms across into the more–than–human world. The search for balance and harmony, a tenet advocated in tā–vā negotiations, also represents the vā negotiations between the motu (island) and moana (ocean). When tangata are added to the mix (i.e. motu–moana–tangata), vā’s fuo (form, shape, fruits) and uho (content, core or centre) shift due to the multiple and simultaneous encounters within its relational ecosphere. When entities become less active during their encounters in relational spaces, vā’s rhythms (i.e. fuo and uho) and flow again change and shift, impacting vā’s presence and ivi (strength). Vā’s future and possibilities can be understood across tuʻatonga and in our local and global becomings.

Tongan Enough: Becoming in the Vā (June 2022)

Is our becoming Tongan, enough?

like young children during the month of May

standing all dressed in their Sunday best

ready to recite their bible verses for the first time

Tongan enough is in learning to fulfill church expectations

Is our becoming Tongan, enough?

like a dissatisfied fa‘e (mother)

disappointed at her son failing to provide for her annual misinale (tithing)

comparing him to her other children just to make her feel better

‘give your all no matter what’, he’s told

Is our becoming Tongan, enough?

like a young girl learning to tau‘olunga (dance)

gracefully pacing her movements

ready yet petrified at the punake’s (choreographer’s) glaring eyes and soul-breaking comments

‘move to the back’, she’s told

Enough is sometimes too much

like a parent running on the sidelines at a rugby league game

ready to protect their child from harm

armed with powerful yet harming words like tui‘i ke mate (tackle and destroy)

pain is in our becoming, Tongan

Learning to become Tongan in the vā space is more than enough!

Acknowledgements

I sincerely acknowledge Siosaia Sisitoutai for his generosity with translation, mālō ‘aupito Saia.

References

Allen, J. M. U., Fasavalu, T. M., Iosefo, F., Ualesi, T. Y., Fa‘avae, D. T. M. & Cunningham, E. (2022). Collective Indigenous approaches to centring Pacific voices of leadership for our futures. Ethnographic Edge, 5(2), 1–23. doi.org/10.24135/ethnographic-edge.v5i2.249.

Bergson, H. (2007). The creative mind: An introduction to metaphysics. Dover Publications.

Bignall, S. & Braidotti, R. (2019). Posthuman systems. In R. Braidotti & S. Bignall (Eds.), Posthuman ecologies: Complexity and process after Deleuze (pp. 1–16). Rowman & Littlefield International.

Bignall, S. & Rigney, D. (2019). Indigeneity, posthumanism and nomadic thought. In R. Braidotti & S. Bignall (Eds.), Posthuman ecologies: Complexity and process after Deleuze (pp. 159–181). Rowman & Littlefield International.

Braidotti, R. (2013). The posthuman. Polity Press.

Braidotti, R. (2019). Posthuman knowledge. Polity Press.

Churchward, C. M. (2015). Tongan dictionary. The Government of Tonga.

Collins, P. H. (2019). Intersectionality as critical social theory. Duke University Press.

Dyck, D. V., Matamua, C. S. F., Fa‘avae, D. T. M., Sisitoutai, S. & Fa‘avae, I. A. (2022). Mānava ‘i he loto manava: Creatively critical Tongan sense-making in the glocal south. Knowledge Cultures, 10(3), 35–55. doi.org/10.22381/kc10320223.

Fa‘avae, D. T. M. (2021a). (Re)turning to loto, igniting mālie and māfana: Tongan maau and faiva as expressed rhythmic entanglement. The International Education Journal: Comparative Perspectives, 20(3), 71–80.

Fa‘avae, D. T. M. (2021b). Vā and veitapui as decolonial potential: Ongoing talatalanoa, re-imagining doctoral being and becoming. In C. Badenhorst, B. Amell & J. Burford (Eds.), Re-imagining doctoral writing (pp. 167–183). University Press of Colorado. doi.org/10.37514/INT-B.2021.1343.2.08.

Fehoko, E., Fa‘avae, D. T. M., Tecun, A. & Siu‘ulua, S. A. (2022). Digital vā: Pacific perspectives on the shift from ‘ordinary practices’ to ‘extraordinary spaces’ during the Covid-19 pandemic in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Anthropological Forum, 32(4), 307–324. doi.org/10.1080/00664677.2023.2172549.

Fox, N. J. & Alldred, P. (2014). New materialist social inquiry: Designs, methods and the research-assemblage. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 18(4), 399–414. doi.org/10.1080/13645579.2014.921458.

Haraway, D. (2008). When species meet. University of Minnesota Press.

Havea, J. (2017). Postcolonize now. In J. Havea (Ed.), Postcolonial voices from downunder: Indigenous matters, confronting readings (pp. 1–14). Pickwick Publications.

Iosefo, F., Hawkins, H. & Fa‘avae, D. (2021). Wayfinding the ‘tapu’ in critical autoethnography. In T. E. Adams, S. Holman Jones & C. Ellis (Eds.), Handbook of autoethnography (pp. 483–492). Routledge. doi.org/10.4324/9780429431760-49.

Ka‘ili, T. O. (2017). Marking indigeneity: The Tongan art of sociospatial relations. University of Arizona Press. doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1t89kr9.

Ka‘ili, T. O. (2023, 1 August). Tauhi fonua and pukepuke fonua: Tongan cosmogonies as a foundation for socio-ecological responsibilities. AUT Vā Moana Research Centre. www.vamoana.org/news/va-korero-tevita-o-ka-ili.

Ka‘ili, T. O., Māhina, ʻŌ. & Addo, P. (2017). Introduction: Tā–Vā (time-space)—The birth of an Indigenous Moana theory. Pacific Studies Journal, 40(1/2), 1–17.

Kalavite, T. (2017). Tā–Vā Kāinga, time-space relationships theory of reality and Tongan students’ journey to academic achievement in New Zealand Tertiary education. Pacific Studies Journal, 40(1/2), 79–104.

Koya Vaka‘uta, C. F. (2017). The digital vā: Negotiating socio-spatial relations in cyberspace, place and time. In U. L. Vaai & U. Nabobo-Baba (Eds.), The relational self: Decolonising personhood in the Pacific (pp. 61–78). University of the South Pacific & The Pacific Theological College.

Lopesi, L. (2021). Moana cosmopolitan imaginaries: Toward an emerging theory of moana art [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. Auckland University of Technology. hdl.handle.net/10292/14298.

Malone, K. & Kuby, C. R. (2022). Posthumanism. In K. Murris (Ed.), A glossary for doing postqualitative, new materialist and critical posthumanist research across disciplines (pp. 97–99). Routledge. doi.org/10.4324/9781003041153-49.

Manu‘atu, L. (2000). Tuli ke ma‘u hono ngaahi mālie: Pedagogical possibilities for Tongan students in New Zealand secondary schooling [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of Auckland.

Matapo, J. (2016, 8–12 December). Becoming posthuman: Navigating Pacific epistemology in Pasifika research [Unpublished conference paper]. PESA Conference Proceedings: Knowledge Ecologies, Fiji. researchgate.net/publication/311714748_Becoming_Posthuman_Navigating_Pacific_Epistemology_in_Pasifika_Research.

Matapo, J. & McFall-McCaffery, J. T. (2022). Towards a vā knowledge ecology: Mobilising Pacific philosophy to transform higher education for Pasifika in Aotearoa New Zealand. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 44(2), 122–137. doi.org/10.1080/1360080X.2022.2041258.

Mika, C. T. H. (2017). Indigenous education and the metaphysics of presence: A worlded philosophy. Routledge. doi.org/10.4324/9781315727547.

Mika, C. (2021, 2 December). Being and convergence within wā: Excessive and stupendous interconnection [Unpublished keynote presentation]. 49th Annual OCIES Conference.

Paea, M. K., Manu‘atu, L., Rohorua, H. T., Rohorua, F., Fa‘avae, D. T. M. & Paea, S. (2023). Talanoa he vā māfana: An indigenous Tongan approach to leadership. Pacific Dynamics: Journal of Interdisciplinary Research, 76(1), 374–392.

Refiti, A. (2015). Mavae and Tofiga: Spatial exposition of the Samoan cosmogony and architecture [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. Auckland University of Technology. hdl.handle.net/10292/9248.

Seve-Williams, N. (2017). Reading realities through Tā-Vā. Pacific Studies Journal, 40(1/2), 180–192.

Stewart, G. (2018). What does ‘indigenous’ mean, for me? Educational Philosophy and Theory, 50(8), 740–743. doi.org/10.1080/00131857.2017.1302050.

Suaalii-Sauni, T. (2017). The vā and Kaupapa Māori. In T. K. Hoskins & A. Jones (Eds.), Critical Conversations in Kaupapa Māori (pp. 161–178). Huia.

Taumoefolau, M. (2021). Fetu’utakí. Fola-he-Ngalú (Ep. 01) [Video]. youtube.com/watch?v=76eBHUG_04w&feature=youtu.be.

Taufe‘ulungaki, A. M. (2004, 1 December). Fonua: Reclaiming Pacific communities in Aotearoa [Unpublished keynote presentation]. Pacific Health Symposium, Auckland.

Tuagalu, I. (2008). Heuristics of the vā. AlterNative: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples, 4(1), 107–126. doi.org/10.1177/117718010800400110.

Tui Atua, T. T. T. E. (2017). Foreword. In U. L. Vaai & U. Nabobo-Baba (Eds.), The relational self: Decolonising personhood in the Pacific (pp. xi–xiii). University of the South Pacific & Pacific Theological College.

Tu‘imana, ‘E. (2022). Tauhivā ako: Engaging Indigenous relationality in school leadership. Ethnographic Edge, 5(2). doi.org/10.24135/ethnographic-edge.v5i2.253.

Tu‘itahi, S. (2005). Langa fonua: In search of success. How a Tongan kainga strived to be socially and economically successful in New Zealand [Unpublished master’s thesis]. Massey University.

Ualesi, Y. M. (2021). Culturally responsive, sustaining and safe youth mentoring practice in Aotearoa New Zealand: A va relational approach [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of Auckland.

Vaai, U. L. (2021). The ecorelational story of the cosmic aiga: A Pasifika perspective. In E. M. Conradie & P-C. Lai (Eds.), Taking a deep breath for the story to begin … (pp. 225–240). AOSIS Publishing. doi.org/10.4102/aosis.2021.BK264.11.

Vaai, U. L. & Nabobo-Baba, U. (Eds.) (2017). The relational self: Decolonising personhood in the Pacific. University of the South Pacific & The Pacific Theological College.

Vaka‘uta, N. (2010). Lau Faka-Tu’a: Reading the Bible Tu’a-wise. In E. Wainwright, D. Irarrazaval & D. Gira (Eds.), Oceania and Indigenous theologies (pp. 45–50). SCM Press.

Wendt, A. (1999). Afterword: Tatauing the post-colonial body. In V. Hereniko & R. Wilson (Eds.), Inside out: Literature, cultural politics, and identity in the new Pacific (pp. 399–412). Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Wilson, S. (2008). Research is ceremony: Indigenous research methods. Fernwood Publishing.


  1. 1 Māori are the people of the land in Aotearoa New Zealand.

  2. 2 Settler colonialism is Aotearoa New Zealand’s ongoing colonial condition. This is a consequence of the early settlers’ appropriation of land and the subsequent attempts at assimilating tangata whenua. Palangi and other migrants have since settled on whenua and shaped the ways in which schooling and politics are decided and conducted.

  3. 3 The Anthropocene is an era in which humans have had a substantial impact on our planet (Braidotti, 2013).

  4. 4 Not all Pacific/Pasifika-heritage scholars opt to work Indigenous ideas or techniques together with Euro-Western ideas. I see the value of both. For example, my use of the extended hyphen/en dash (i.e. –) is intentional because it is symbolic of the space in–between, likened to vā as an in–between space of connections.

  5. 5 Within the context of Indigenous scholarship and theorising in Aotearoa New Zealand and in the moana, ‘Indigenous Moana/Pasifika scholars’ refers to academics who are deliberate about their positionality as Moana or Pasifika scholars.

  6. 6 Indigeneity has a different meaning for Māori, who are tangata whenua, and for our realm nations—that is, Niue, Cook Islands and Tokelau—who share a unique political relationship with Aotearoa New Zealand. Indigeneity for a Tongan scholar born and raised on Aotearoa New Zealand whenua will look, feel, sound different to a Tongan scholar born and raised in Tonga. These Indigeneity subtleties and specificities are to be recognised when using ‘Indigeneity’ as an identity marker in higher education.

  7. 7 Shawn Wilson (2008) reminds us of the political connotations associated with ‘Indigenous’ with the capital ‘I’. Not all Indigenous peoples share similar colonial experiences. Some continue to face and experience ongoing colonial and neo-colonial practices and processes within their own settler-colonial nations.

  8. 8 Māori and Tongan notions of land (whenua/fonua) refer to more than the actual physical entity that is delimited in surveys and maps.

  9. 9 ‘Material’ relates to physical and tangible entities, rather than the mind or spirit; ‘non-material’ relates to the mind, spirit, intellect.

  10. 10 ‘Animate’ refers to something that is alive or has life, something organic. ‘Inanimate’ refers to entities that are deemed not alive (e.g. stones, rocks, etc.).

  11. 11 English translation is my own.


Previous

Updated:  11 August 2026/ Responsible Officer:  / Page Contact: