As the framework components were derived and validated from literature that originated largely outside Australia, it seems reasonable to consider whether the framework can be applied to IS in world regions beyond Australia. It is premature to test the framework using data collected from IS in other world regions until it has been tested with data gathered in Australia, as modifications to the framework might be necessary. Examining the framework using data collected within Australia will be reported on elsewhere in this volume; however, the next section reports on a preliminary examination of the applicability of the framework to IS in world regions outside Australia, using the broad experiences of internationally known IS scholars from those regions.
Expert IS scholars from North America, the United Kingdom and Scandinavia were approached and were asked to comment briefly on the relevance of the framework to IS in their own region. The three international regions were chosen as they were viewed as being distinctive in their contribution, while also having had a major input to the development of IS. The framework chapter was sent to the international researchers, who read it before writing a commentary on the applicability of the framework to IS in their own region. The commentaries were broad ranging, and used the framework components to guide their discussion to a varying degree. Each of the commentaries is presented below, while a later subsection collates the views of the international commentators on the applicability of the framework to the three regions outside Australia. The contributions of professors Bob Zmud (giving a North American perspective), Frank Land and Antony Bryant (giving a perspective from the United Kingdom) and Karlheinz Kautz (giving a Scandinavian perspective) are acknowledged with gratitude.
It certainly is a fruitful exercise to apply (and, in doing so, assess) the proposed framework. The disciplinary status of the North American IS discipline has been a topic of great interest, as reflected in my article on the discipline’s ‘identity crisis’ (Benbasat and Zmud 2003) and the ensuing reaction to this article (King and Lyytinen 2006).
It is perhaps most important to begin by recognising the progress that has occurred in developing the North American IS discipline in the past four decades. When I completed my doctoral studies in business administration (combining organisation theory with computer science) at the University of Arizona in 1974, there were few IS faculty members in North America and, at most, two or three freshly started IS doctoral programs. In North America today, IS faculty members are well represented at the majority of comprehensive universities and colleges, in schools of business, information science and technology. As my own experiences have been solely with schools of business, I will limit the ensuing discussion to this context. This is important to note as an essay written from the perspective of schools of information science and technology would be somewhat different, though the overall message would likely be quite similar. This is a nice example of the framework’s ‘impact of local contingencies’ component.
The framework has four level-one components: mechanisms of control; core body of knowledge; impact of local contingencies; and degree of professionalism. This essay will unfold with my perspective of the North American experience with each of these. Concluding comments will then be provided on the usefulness of the framework in carrying out this exercise.
The IS discipline in North America has developed quite well—in fact, surprisingly so given the relatively short time since the discipline’s emergence—with regard to mechanisms of control and especially with regard to research. Mechanisms of control reflect the mechanisms put in place to facilitate the development, communication and regulation of research programs and the development, delivery and regulation of education programs and curricula.
The North American IS research community has achieved considerable success. The major conference, the International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS), is very successful and is recognised as a premier research conference. The major journals (MIS Quarterly and Information Systems Research) have achieved high Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) impact ratings, are respected by business school promotion and tenure committees and by institutions (Business Week, Financial Times) rating MBA programs, and are being cited increasingly by articles published in non-IS scholarly journals. In addition, a number of successful IS scholars are members of non-IS editorial boards.
The North American teaching community has also achieved success, though neither as consistent nor as substantial as observed with research. Information systems undergraduate and graduate degree programs are found in the majority of comprehensive universities and colleges, with a majority of business degree programs maintaining IS core requirements. While enrolments have gone up and down and up again in the past decade, this largely reflects the variability that characterises high-technology markets. Many universities and colleges have institutionalised IS faculties into their departmental structures; however, the control mechanism of accreditation processes has not shown much development. The widely adopted Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB) accreditation process pays, at best, modest attention to IS.
The IS discipline in North America remains surprisingly underdeveloped regarding its core body of knowledge. Essentially, a discipline’s core body of knowledge reflects the consensually agreed-on research topics, research methods and teaching topics that distinguish it from other disciplines. While consensual agreement is likely to exist around a very limited core of topics regarding research and teaching, much debate continues to arise as one pushes beyond this very limited core. The focus of research programs therefore varies widely as does the content of IS courses and IS curricula. Still, three trends can be observed. First, over time, these ‘limited cores’ have been expanding, though slowly. Second, in terms of teaching, greater consistency does exist at the undergraduate level than at the graduate level. Third, regarding research methods, the North American IS discipline is increasingly receptive to the view that any research method is appropriate given that it fits with the research question(s) asked and is executed and interpreted well.
Local contingencies are useful in understanding the developmental differences discussed above regarding mechanisms of control and the core body of knowledge. Again, the local context described is that situated within North American schools of business.
During the 1970s and 1980s, IS faculties in North American business schools tended to be associated with one or more of a limited number of scholarly societies: Operations Research Society of America/The Institute of Management Sciences (ORSA/TIMS; now the Institute for Operations Research and Management Sciences, INFORMS), the American Institute for Decision Sciences (AIDS; now the Decision Sciences Institute, DSI) and the Academy of Management. Each of these societies had strong research cultures and scholarly journals reflected the prevailing values and norms of faculty members across business disciplines. These values and norms were thus ingrained within IS faculties and institutionalised in the discipline’s conferences, journals and doctoral programs.
No such institutional structures, however, existed regarding teaching IS in schools of business. This lack of institutional structures was exacerbated by the varied training (economics, management science, computer science, organisation theory and so on) of the faculties, the lack of pedagogical role models within local institutions and a strong bias towards research (rather than teaching) within the North American IS discipline’s conferences and journals.
Recognising the applied nature of the IS discipline and the need to align itself with prevailing school of business values and norms, the North American IS discipline has strived (with varied success) to balance the objectives of being rigorous—that is, developing and communicating new knowledge within academic communities—and being relevant—that is, developing and communicating knowledge that is actionable immediately by practice communities (Benbasat and Zmud 1999). While local contingencies (for example, local institutional values and norms, association with practice communities) are again key to explaining situational differences, the North American IS discipline has generally exhibited a bias that has and continues to favour rigour ahead of relevance—a bias held, generally, by North American schools of business.
Gail Ridley has written a paper offering a framework for ‘developing and evaluating the IS discipline in Australia’. This is a laudable undertaking, but it immediately raises the question: ‘Why does the IS discipline need to be evaluated and developed?’ And what is specific to the Australian context?
At first reading, one of the specific features of the Australian context is that IS appears to be thriving. At least there is no indication of any crisis—unlike the situation in the United States and most of Europe, where there is a steep and continuing decline in student numbers, a continuing threat to IS departments and university posts, and also to funding for teaching and research.[1] We suspect that it is unlikely that Australian IS is bucking the trend, and if the decline has not yet started, it will soon do so. This might appear to undermine the effort of developing a framework, yet we would argue that it might make it even more pertinent and important. First, however, a few provisos are in order with regard to the paper itself.
Much of the first part of the paper is concerned with the extent to which IS can be regarded as a discipline, yet the title and the bulk of the paper beyond the opening section assume that it is. This evades some key issues that have been raised elsewhere (see for instance Bryant 2006) and even some of those addressed in the opening section of the paper; but since the main focus is on the framework this is, perhaps, understandable.
As it is presented, the framework falls between offering a descriptive account of the current situation in Australian IS and a prescriptive one advocating what IS should be or should become. It might then serve as a useful basis for these considerations elsewhere in the world. On the other hand, many of the issues raised are already fairly well known outside Australia.
Whether or not IS constitutes a discipline, it is evident that its status and role within the twenty-first century university is changing. Rather than seeking to fight some rearguard action to preserve whatever might make up the ‘home turf’ or territory of IS, it is far more important to raise awareness of the key issues around which IS-type activities—teaching, research and so on—gather. Some indication of these is given in the framework—for example, teaching, methods, theories and links to other disciplines. The next step might then be to offer some indication of the ways in which these foundations might be built on, within a recognised IS discipline and in cases and contexts where IS becomes (re)absorbed into one or other of its reference or kin disciplines—for example, business, management, computing and so on.
The paper in which the framework is presented discusses the issue of pragmatism—correctly distinguishing between the more common meaning of the term, in which something is pragmatic if it is of more-or-less immediate practical use and application, and the term used to evoke the work of American philosophers such as Peirce, Dewey and James, whereby concerns for truth and validity are seen against a background of practice and experience as well as against theories and concepts. Pragmatism is located within the framework in two respects; however, it is perhaps worth considering the framework as a whole from a pragmatic point of view. Does the core of the framework find any validity and authority among IS practitioners? Those involved in academic IS might spend a considerable amount of time agonising about disciplinary status, core concerns, reference disciplines and the like, but these are probably not even of passing interest to those working outside such narrow confines. Recent work in Germany on Wirtschaftsinformatik (WI) indicates that a practice-oriented discipline, gaining much of its findings and credibility from the commercial sector, continues to thrive. So a useful test of any framework might be its ability not only to capture this state of affairs, but to indicate how it might be applied elsewhere as well as be used in future developments. Ironically, reports on the current state of WI also suggest that in an effort to gain some international academic credibility WI academics are trying to mimic academic IS using the American-oriented approach, whereas precisely the inverse relationship appears to be the sounder strategy.
We offer the following example as an instance of the context that any framework or similar explanatory and exploratory project must seek to address. If we seek to understand the issues around Customer Relationship Management (CRM), our study will be concerned with the design of such a system, drawing on marketing theory and practice as well as systems theory and perhaps computer science and database theory. These ‘outside’ theories are not reference theories but part of our apparatus for the study. Moreover, if our study is intended to establish how effective a given CRM system has been, we will have to use different methods of analysis and draw on different theories to help in the explanation. These could include theories relating to the management of change and explanations of resistance to change. Further, they might have to link with theories of ethical behaviour.
There is another issue that arises from a consideration of the framework: the extent to which it focuses attention on the boundary between what is included within IS and what is excluded. In recent years, there have been various attempts to produce statements to this effect, and all have fallen foul of the complex interdisciplinary nature of IS itself. For instance, there would need to be some way in which attention was directed to topics such as computer games, including activities such as online casinos; also the impact of the market for online pornography on the development of information and communications technology (ICT). There is no evading the issue that many of the key technical developments in the 1980s and 1990s were clearly pushed through by the demand for sites with quickly loading graphics and secure online payment facilities—that is, porn sites. Similar advances have been achieved with gaming and gambling in mind. A host of antisocial applications ranging from pornography to spam and viruses to computer crime need to be seen as innovative and hugely successful application areas for IS, as well as features to be researched and overcome.
A framework must therefore include the capability of characterising the wide and complex nature of the phenomena that are being studied. Because the IS domain is undergoing constant change, as the paper notes—for example, the introduction of the phenomenon of mobile computing—what is in the framework under the heading ‘nature of the phenomenon’ is constantly changing. It could be that in such a friable context attempts to develop a framework are doomed from the start; on the other hand, a case might be made that in such circumstances it is imperative that some form of guidance and prescription is articulated. Perhaps the framework on offer here might serve as a useful starting point in such an endeavour.
Currently in the United Kingdom, IS departments are having to respond to considerable upheaval and change: the higher education sector is undergoing major transformation as a whole, and the number of students seeking IS-type courses, particularly at undergraduate level, is falling. On the other hand, demand for IS skills is likely to increase, but in combination with a range of other skills—technical, social and business oriented. In such an uncertain context, attempts to clarify key IS aims and characteristics are all the more critical.
Based on an intensive literature study, Ridley (2006) has developed a framework to characterise IS in Australia. Ridley considers whether related research undertaken by a group of researchers can be regarded as a discipline or a field. She has done so to support efforts that aim to determine whether IS is a scientific discipline. Such efforts are of course driven by the perceived need of some IS researchers to legitimise what they are doing, particularly in environments where such researchers are a minority grouping in university departments or schools and are permanently challenged by colleagues from other fields. Ridley’s framework consists largely of four components, which she puts forward to characterise Australian IS: mechanisms of control, a core body of knowledge, the impact of local contingencies and the degree of professionalism. The question arises whether the framework can also be used in, and for, other geographical regions.
My comments are provided from a Scandinavian perspective. In Scandinavia, discussion about IS as a discipline has never really been dominant. Instead, there has been discussion about whether there is a unique Scandinavian approach to IS research. Scandinavian researchers settle comfortably with Lee’s (2001) assessment that ‘research in the information systems field examines more than just the technological system, or just the social system, or even the two side by side; in addition, it investigates the phenomena that emerge when the two interact’.
Ridley sees social processes as operating through conferences, journals and academic departments; these have also been referred to as mechanisms of control. The social process is important for the Scandinavian IS community, where numerous academic institutions have independent IS departments. These are rarely called ‘department of information systems’. Although they operate under the name of informatics, information-processing science or information science, the majority of members of such departments feel like IS researchers and the different names might just be a matter of language, as all departments of course have names in the respective language of the country. The sense of community developed since as early as the late 1970s, while in 1978 the Information Systems Research Seminar in Scandinavia (IRIS) was founded. This working conference has been a meeting place for senior and junior researchers for nearly 30 years. The Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems (SJIS) has operated since 1989 and was started originally to give Scandinavian IS researchers their own voice.
Ridley’s second IS component, core body of knowledge, in which she distinguishes between research and teaching methods and standards, a unique symbol set, key research and teaching of IS topics, theory/laws, and rules and evidenced guidelines, can be discussed from a Scandinavian perspective and its strong commitment to the social process.
Historically, IS research in Scandinavia took its starting point in IS development as opposed to computer science and software engineering research. Being embedded in formerly social democratic countries, Scandinavian IS research traditions emphasise engagement with practice. Like the editorial policy of the SJIS, however, Scandinavian IS values and welcomes theoretical and methodological pluralism. Although Scandinavian research seems to favour qualitative, interpretive or even action-based research, quantitative research of high quality can also be found. Early on, Bansler (1989) had already identified three Scandinavian IS research schools: a systems theoretical tradition, a socio-technical tradition and a critical tradition. The question arises whether such pluralism should be considered as a coherent whole or as a set of scattered methods and standards (or symbol sets). If the former is the case, IS in Scandinavia might be considered a discipline or research field, while if the latter is the case, it might not. The answers to these questions will help decide whether these elements of Ridley’s framework make sense.
The key research topics in Scandinavian IS can also be examined. The SJIS—I am again citing its 2007 editorial policy statement—invites contributions on electronic commerce, IT diffusion, mobile and ubiquitous computing, organisational and societal issues, research approaches and methods and systems development methods, but explicitly states that the journal’s topics are not restricted to these. Consequently, the journal has published work on other topics as well. Interesting research themes, fads and fashions come and go, but as long as IS development and use (as broad as they are) are accepted as the underlying key topics, Scandinavian IS fulfils this criterion for being a discipline. This is, of course, as long as the criterion itself can be used in such an expansive way.
Research in a discipline should certainly contribute to the body of knowledge about a phenomenon. Theories, laws, rules or evidenced guidelines also clearly contribute to a discipline. In Scandinavia, practical relevance has always had an important role in legitimate research. There is no one such ‘theory of IS’ or ‘theory of IS development’ or ‘theory of IS use’, and it is debatable whether there is a commonly accepted set of laws, rules and guidelines in IS. Information systems research has provided insights, guidelines and rules, often through the use of theories from reference disciplines. Even if these activities do not define theories in their own right, they at least contribute to theory building.
Finally, Ridley proposes that local contingencies and professionalism help characterise the IS discipline in Australia, and even influence each other. It is true that local contingencies and professionalism have an influence on the local manifestation of the IS discipline, but it is debatable whether they can be used to characterise the IS discipline itself. Whether the concept of locality should be considered in an examination of the nature of the IS discipline is questionable. Even if there is ‘one’ IS discipline in Scandinavia, with local differences from country to country, and even from university to university, this is also the case in other disciplines where there is no debate about their existence.
Overall, IS in Scandinavia—as is explained above—is influenced heavily by its social democratic heritage and its preference for relevance. Both factors have had an influence on the degree of professionalism in Scandinavian IS research, in the sense that the term ‘professionalism’ is used in the framework. The outcome has been that more qualitative, interpretive and action-oriented approaches have been favoured in Scandinavian IS until recently, with less emphasis on the rigour and generalisability of the results.
Do the differences discussed above regarding IS in Scandinavia mean that IS in that region can be characterised differently to the IS discipline in, for instance, Australia or North America? Although local contingencies might influence local incarnations of a discipline, they do not necessarily challenge the general definition of the IS discipline. Thus, if in general Scandinavian IS is the same as Australian IS, the elements of a framework to characterise the nature of the IS discipline in Australia have to be used with some caution.
This section reviews the experiences of the four international IS scholars in applying the framework to IS in their own region, drawing on their own expertise. Bob Zmud stepped through the four top-level components of the framework before concluding that, at least at a high level of analysis, it appeared useful ‘in understanding the evolution and current state of the North American IS discipline’.
Tony Bryant and Frank Land from the United Kingdom questioned why the endeavour to characterise the IS discipline needed to be done for an Australian context. Consequently, their commentary focused on global issues, pointing to the need for IS to respond to pressures to change. These included the decline in student numbers and its impact on IS teaching and research, the status, role and structural location of IS, the connection with IS practitioners, the need for IS work to integrate with theory and practice from elsewhere and difficulties associated with the increasingly fluid nature of the boundaries of IS. Bryant and Land therefore considered that a framework of the nature of the IS discipline must be capable of ‘characterising the wide and complex nature of the phenomena being studied’ and, in particular, accommodating change, and they referred to aspects of the framework that noted some of these issues. While supporting the need for a framework to clarify key aims and characteristics for IS, the authors’ commentary also laid down some of the challenges of doing so.
Karlheinz Kautz considered how to apply the framework to a Scandinavian perspective, after pointing out that there had been more interest in evaluating whether there was a unique approach to Scandinavian IS research than considering the state of IS as a discipline in that region. Like Zmud, Kautz was able to use the four top-level framework components to review the nature of IS in Scandinavia; however, while being able to identify what appeared to be distinctive characteristics of IS in Scandinavia, Kautz questioned whether it was relevant to consider ‘local incarnations’ when attempting to characterise the nature of the IS discipline.
It can be seen then that three of the four international scholars query the purpose of characterising the nature of IS in Australia, implying that global influences on the discipline will be more important than regional ones. In two of the international regions, the framework components appeared useful to review the nature of the IS discipline in those areas. These two perspectives suggest that the framework has some value in characterising the IS discipline outside Australia and/or it should be capable of doing so. Neither position is surprising, given the development of the framework from the international literature. After the framework has been tested on a range of case studies set in Australian ‘states’ and reported on elsewhere in this volume—then modified where necessary—it will be interesting to test the refined framework against international settings, using broader data gathered in those settings. Future iterations of the framework might need to accommodate the requirements suggested by the international scholars who commented above.