Conclusions

A body of literature exists that examines the theory of the development of disciplines. This literature suggests that the development of IS in Australian universities should not be viewed as a unique case, but instead a range of pressures need to be considered, which act on the discipline. A brief overview of the early development of the management and computer science disciplines was presented to illustrate the development of two disciplines related to IS. Although some reference has been made in IS to theory on the nature and development of disciplines, very little use of the material has been made to provide a context within which to view the past and present nature and position of IS in Australian universities.

The project reported on elsewhere in this monograph gathered data across a range of dimensions for universities in each large region in Australia. It has been argued that if such data collection is to be utilised in a strategic way to increase access to resources for the IS discipline, it will be necessary to integrate the data and findings from regions across the dimensions, so that the relationships within, between and among the regions and dimensions can be analysed, and the contributing factors better understood. A theoretical framework to guide data collection and analysis was developed from an analysis of the IS and non-IS literature on the development of disciplines and presented in this chapter. As the framework’s components could be derived independently from the IS and non-IS literature, this characteristic strengthened the validity of the framework. The framework will integrate different aspects of the broader study and provide a common way of looking at data collected over a range of dimensions from a range of regions and Australian universities.

Data gathered from universities in the regions around Australia can be used to assess the extent to which mechanisms of control have been established in Australian IS, along with the four components of the body of knowledge (research and teaching methods and standards, the existence of a unique symbol set, key research and teaching topics and laws, rules and evidenced guidelines). In addition, the relationship between the impact of local contingencies and the degree of professionalism can be evaluated through an analysis of the extent of variation in the nature of IS in universities among the states of Australia over time and at present. Together, these two constructs will provide a means of tracking progress in the state and development of the IS discipline in Australian universities in the past and future, and will identify those issues that hinder progress.

The discipline of IS is subject to frequent change, including new research and teaching topics and methods. Pragmatism is one example of a recent development in the IS and related literature. The framework was examined to see whether it was capable of accommodating new developments in IS, such as pragmatism, without modification. As the framework remained robust as a result of this test, the results were interpreted as a further validation of the framework.

Future work will analyse the utility of the framework, based on its effectiveness to characterise the development of IS in Australian universities. This utility needs to consider more broadly whether change to IS can be fitted within the framework. The external view of the development of IS from those who are not IS academics will also need to be evaluated in future. Before applying the framework to examine the development of IS in other regions of the world, it might be necessary for further refinement, based on the outcomes from the framework’s application to the Australian study.