In common with the other chapters in this volume, our chapter utilised the framework proposed by Ridley (2006) for assessing the development of a discipline. This framework draws on Whitley’s theory of scientific change (1984a, 1984b) and Fitzgerald’s views (2003) on the different knowledge types in a discipline. Ridley’s framework is relatively new and its use in the series of case studies in this monograph provides a means of assessing its applicability and for suggestions for potential refinement. We discovered in using the framework to analyse our own cases that some minor modification to the framework allowed our data to be better represented and we have used this revised framework.
The original work by Whitley (1984b) saw some sciences as highly professional, with high task certainty, routinisation of activities and division of labour. Where a discipline was not highly professional, local contingencies had more influence—for example, with the impact of local political pressure. Further, Whitley (1984b) suggested that three conditions underlay the establishment of distinct scientific fields, namely:
scientific reputations become socially prestigious and are used to control ‘critical rewards’
standards of research competence and skills are established
a unique symbol system allows exclusion of outsiders and clear communication between initiates within the field.
Further input to the original Ridley framework (2006) came from the work of Fitzgerald (2003), who characterised the ‘body of knowledge’ in the disciplinary units as being of different knowledge types:
rules or laws (as in the natural sciences)
evidenced guidelines
normative guidelines.
Table 4.1 shows the adapted Ridley framework as we have used it in this study. Note that although this revised framework is presented at the outset of our chapter, it arose during the course of our data analysis, where we adapted the labels and definition for the categories as a result of insights gained in studying our data—a process in keeping with the grounded-theory approach (Glaser and Strauss 1967).
The term ‘knowledge base’ was used as an overarching term for the category that included a number of elements relating to a knowledge base, including teaching methods. The term ‘core body of knowledge’ was not felt to be appropriate for the overarching construct as this term was reserved commonly for the core ‘topics’ or ‘domain’ of a discipline, as in the ‘core body of knowledge’ defined by the Australian Computer Society (ACS) (Underwood 1997)—that is, for element (d) within the overarching knowledge base construct (Table 4.1). Within the knowledge base construct, pedagogical approaches were separated from epistemological approaches, as our data analysis indicated that these were distinct sub-categories.
We have used this framework in our analysis, although we do not necessarily endorse the use of the words ‘science’ or ‘scientific’ to describe the IS discipline. This is not to say that IS research should not be rigorous, but the word science has many connotations and at least some of the work done in IS does not conform to common understandings of what makes a science, in terms of the natural and behavioural sciences (for example, see Nagel 1979).
|
Framework component |
Definition |
|---|---|
|
Mechanisms of control |
Scientific reputations become socially prestigious and are used to control ‘critical rewards’ (Whitley 1984b). |
|
Knowledge base |
|
|
a) Recognised pedagogical approaches |
There is a common understanding of the methods needed to impart knowledge, whether experiential, laboratory, didactic and so on. |
|
b) Recognised epistemological approaches |
Established standards for research competence and skills exist (Whitley 1984b). There is some agreement on epistemological questions as they relate to the discipline. How is theory constructed? How can scientific knowledge be acquired? How is theory tested? What research methods can be used? What criteria are applied to judge the soundness and rigour of research methods (Gregor 2006)? |
|
c) Unique symbol set |
A unique symbol system allows exclusion of outsiders and clear communication between initiates within the field (Whitley 1984b). |
|
d) Agreement on core knowledge domain topics |
There is some agreement on the phenomena of interest in the discipline, the core problems or topics of interest and the boundaries of the discipline. As an example, Benbasat and Zmud (2003) proposed a core set of phenomena to define the IS field. See also Underwood (1997). |
|
e) Range of knowledge types |
A range of knowledge types are present: laws, rules and evidenced guidelines (theory) (Fitzgerald 2003). |
|
Impact of local contingencies |
The degree to which local conditions in regions, communities or nations influence the manner in which the discipline operates and is understood (Whitley 1984b). |
|
Degree of professionalism |
The extent of variation in the nature of IS research. The degree to which there is task certainty, routinisation of activities and division of labour (Whitley 1984b). |