4. The information systems discipline in Australia’s capital

Shirley Gregor

School of Accounting and Business Information Systems

The Australian National University

Edward Lewis

School of Information Technology and Electrical Engineering

University of New South Wales at the Australian Defence Force Academy

Craig McDonald

School of Information Sciences and Engineering

University of Canberra

Abstract

The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) is the seat of Australia’s federal government. The three universities studied—the University of New South Wales at the Australian Defence Force Academy (UNSW@ADFA), The Australian National University (ANU) and the University of Canberra (UC)—are all located in the nation’s capital city, Canberra. Each group has a distinctive background that reflects this setting. The UNSW@ADFA is essentially a private university for the Australian Defence Organisation; the ANU was set up to be a national research institution; and the UC group for many years focused on meeting the training needs for computing professionals for the federal government. Despite these distinguishing characteristics, the information systems (IS) groups studied have some commonalities. Pedagogical approaches, epistemological approaches and research topics are all recognisably within the bounds of what is regarded as legitimate for the IS discipline. There is also a degree of commonality in the core knowledge topics offered to students. There are, however, also aspects that detract from the degree to which IS has developed as a discipline. Our field is not regarded as socially prestigious and there are few signs of mechanisms of control. A unique symbol set does not exist to exclude outsiders. The placement of the organisational units within the universities is a result of local contingencies, as is, to some extent, the nature of research undertaken.

Table of Contents

Introduction
The research method
The theoretical framework guiding the study
The universities in this study
Overview of the IS presence in the ACT universities
ADFA
The ANU
The UC
Distinctive features of the IS curriculum
ADFA
The ANU
The UC
Distinctive features of IS research
The UNSW@ADFA
The ANU
The UC
Key figures who have influenced IS in ACT universities
The status of IS as a distinct discipline in ACT universities
Mechanisms of control
Knowledge base
Impact of local contingencies
Degree of professionalisation
Conclusions
Select bibliography

Figure 4.1 Location of the Australian Capital Territory within Australia

Figure 4.1 Location of the Australian Capital Territory within Australia

Introduction

A study of the state of the IS discipline in the Australian Capital Territory could be expected to show some distinctive characteristics, as all universities are relatively small and are situated in Australia’s national capital, Canberra, which is the home of the federal government. With this proximity to government and national institutions it would perhaps not be surprising to find the impact of local contingencies stronger than in other states.

In this chapter, we present our analysis of IS in three universities in the Australian Capital Territory, allowing for a comparison with other states in an accompanying chapter in this volume. The aim of the ACT study is to document commonalities and differences across the three universities in terms of teaching and research, to identify significant influences on the discipline and to consider emerging trends. The chapter concludes with an assessment of the degree of professionalism exhibited in the IS discipline across the ACT universities, based on a modified form of Ridley’s (2006) framework.

It should be noted that the Australian Capital Territory differs from the Australian states in that it is a ‘territory’ rather than a state—a distinction shared also by the Northern Territory. The Australian Capital Territory was chosen as the seat of the Australian government and the home for Canberra in 1908. A neutral location for the capital and the new territory was selected between Sydney and Melbourne, because of the rivalries among the states that federated to form the nation of Australia in 1901. The territory covers just 2538 square kilometres and is tiny compared with the large state of New South Wales that surrounds it. The population of the Australian Capital Territory is approximately 300,000 and almost all its inhabitants live in Canberra, which is home to the three university institutions described in this report. The descriptions of the institutions should be read against this common background of being situated in a relatively new, planned, government city with a smaller population than all but one of the capital cities in the other states in Australia.

The three institutions represented are The Australian National University (ANU), the University of Canberra (UC) and the University College of the University of New South Wales (UNSW) at the Australian Defence Force Academy (UNSW@ADFA). The Australian Capital Territory also has campuses of the Australian Catholic University and Charles Sturt University but, as they do not have IS programs, they are not included.