Overview of the IS presence in NSW universities

As some universities have more than one administrative entity that is concerned with IS, these are shown separately in Table 5.1.

The UNSW has had a historical place in the development of IS in Australia going back to the leadership of Cyril Brookes. This place has wavered over time but the school remains a significant player in IS research and education. The UTS also has a long history of IS that has complemented and competed with the UNSW. Both of these have organisational units with names including IS and the only other such unit is the formal ‘discipline’ of IS at Wollongong. This alone merits their in-depth treatment. The only other university that is considered in detail is the University of Sydney—for two reasons: first, the relatively recent establishment of a ‘discipline group’ of IS in the Faculty of Commerce is seen as a strategic move warranting consideration; and second, because of the significant status and historic role of the Department of Computer Science and its IS members. Charles Sturt University has long had IS-related courses and has been a major provider of distance learning. Here we discuss mainly the Riverina operation, which has been associated closely with library studies.

Dealing with the other units in turn, the University of Western Sydney (UWS) had a long-term role going back to data-processing days, but this has been much reduced today. Macquarie University has several IS degrees, including majors in the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA), but the few IS faculties remain fragmented. Southern Cross University (SCU) has significant distance education enrolments and is a relatively new entrant in the market-place, with some significant innovation. Its influence on the discipline in New South Wales is as yet not large, but the research activity at SCU in particular could establish a future place for it. The University of New England (UNE) and Newcastle University are underdeveloped in terms of IS. We now present an outline of the five identified universities.

Table 5.1 IS presence in NSW universities

University

Administrative entity

Home faculty

No. of IS academics

UNSW

School of Information Systems, Technology and Management

Commerce and Economics

20

UNSW

Group

Australian Graduate School of Management (AGSM)

1

University of Sydney

Group in School of Information Technology (IT)

Science

ca. 5

University of Sydney

Business IS ‘Discipline’ in School of Business

Faculty of Business and Economics

12

UTS

Department of IS

Information Technology

20

University of Wollongong

‘Discipline’ of IS in School of Economics and Information Systems

Commerce

15

UWS

Group in School of Computing and Mathematics

Health and Science

ca. 10

Macquarie University

Group in Department of Computing

Information and Communication Sciences

ca. 5

Macquarie University

Group in Department of Accounting and Finance

Economic and Financial Studies

ca. 3

Macquarie University

Group

MGSM

1

Charles Sturt University

Group in School of Information Studies

Science and Agriculture

10+

SCU

Group in School of Multimedia and IT

Commerce and Management

12

UNE

Nil [?]

   

University of Newcastle

Group in School of Design, Communication and IT

Science and IT

ca. 3

The UNSW

The School of Information Systems, Technology and Management (SISTM) has a long and varied history (there was a Department of Information Systems in the early 1980s). Today, it is placed within the Commerce Faculty but does not have a core unit in that faculty’s flagship BComm program. It has its own BSc in IS as well as a major in IS available in many degrees. High entrance scores are required in all programs. The distinctive BIT degree has industry training (which entails students spending time working in industry during the degree studies), industry-funded student scholarships and includes an Honours year. A Master’s degree in IS is being established but there is support teaching for other Masters degrees.

The school has long been active in research, with strong performances in quantitative aspects of IS, especially in the 1980s and early 1990s. There have also been strong performances in major research grants and doctoral student completions. With the appointment of a new head of school (Dubravka Cecez-Kecmanovic), qualitative research methods in IS are likely to become more prominent. Highly rated IS research in management areas is conducted at the Australian Graduate School of Management (AGSM), but there is no collaboration with SISTM. SISTM is seen to be distinct from computer science within the UNSW.

The University of Sydney

As a traditional university, the University of Sydney has until recently located IS primarily in computer science, with a Sybase Chair in Information Systems appointed there in 1998—although the position is now called ‘language technology’, reflecting the interests of the incumbent. Other areas, such as librarianship and informatics (in the Faculty of Arts), have developed independently. The major in IS offers the same units to various degrees. There are now some 30 students (out of 100) doing an IS project in their BSc Honours degree—the largest honours group in New South Wales. The computer science department is developing a masters in IT that will have an IS major.

In contrast, the newly established business IS ‘discipline’ (one of 10) in the Faculty of Commerce teaches the IS core to some 1000 students in the BComm program, aiming to recruit them to the IS major. Students in the accounting stream take additional IS units, also in MBus and MComm. A new MBusIS degree started in 2006. The establishment of this discipline was seen as a strategic move by the dean, to provide visibility and to promote interdisciplinary research. Five research areas have been selected to build strength in the group.

There is not much visibility of IS (in either incarnation) in the wider university community.

The UTS

From the days of the NSW Institute of Technology—the UTS predecessor institution—vocationally oriented programs have been developed. At the undergraduate level, all courses were in either part-time or ‘sandwich’ mode, requiring students to spend usually one year in suitable paid employment before graduation. In response to an increasing number of international students and the decline of employment opportunities, industrial experience became optional in 2002, and the number of students graduating with work experience has gradually decreased. To some extent this experience is now ‘simulated’ in a large group-systems development project.

Since 1968, computing has been taught in a variety of science-oriented faculties; a second Business Information Systems group developed within the Faculty of Business. These two groups were brought together in about 1980 in a Faculty of Mathematical and Computer Sciences; this faculty became the Faculty of Information Technology in 2000. A number of conflicts between the ‘science’ and ‘business’ groups in the 1980s are still having an impact on the faculty. In the Faculty of Information Technology, IS was established as one of three departments but with limited autonomy. As a matter of policy, all faculty courses are interdepartmental, as the ‘integration’ of computer science and IS is seen as a key strength of the UTS. In the late 1990s, the faculty grew rapidly and was a strong contributor to UTS income, but the faculty is now suffering from the reduced enrolments in IT common across the sector. This has impacted particularly on the IS department as it had a large number of students from the Faculty of Business enrolled in IS majors. In terms of research profile and general visibility within the university, the IS department remains relatively weak alongside the other departments. Research in the IS department has taken a lower profile historically and, even today, the proportion of staff without doctorates is comparatively high.

The University of Wollongong

The IS discipline has some 400 equivalent full-time students units (EFTSU) at the moment, making it probably the largest outside Sydney; there are undergraduate and graduate programs. Its history goes back to 1984 when an IS group from the then Wollongong Institute joined the commerce faculty. In 1991, a Faculty of Informatics was created but IS stayed with commerce. Programs were supported by the local presence of BHP, one of Australia’s largest companies, and some research success was achieved in the 1990s. Currently, the discipline is perceived as suffering somewhat from the increasing proportion of overseas students, difficulties in attracting research students and lack of distinctive recognition within the university.

Charles Sturt University, Riverina

Charles Sturt is a multi-campus regional university, so the administrative position and visibility of IS depends to a large extent on cross-campus structure and politics. At present, IS lies within the Faculty of Science and Agriculture, which controls staffing, major funding and course and subject design. At Wagga Wagga, on the other hand, arrangements have remained fairly stable, with IS as a ‘discipline area’ in the School of Information Studies. In the past, this placement has encouraged an emphasis on the ‘information science’ aspects of IS (an aspect largely ignored elsewhere) but this specialisation is diminishing.

As a regional university, Charles Sturt has a majority of students studying in distance mode, and has good relationships with the community, TAFE and local business (which is not strong). Research projects are mainly individual, and a number of full-time academics are currently enrolled in PhDs. Collaboration tends to be with universities in the nearby Australian Capital Territory rather than with the rest of New South Wales. Researchers do not identify (or feel the need to identify) particularly with IS as such. There is a feeling that regional universities are (for political reasons) less threatened than others by fluctuations in student demand and research fashion.