Results

The next sections summarise and discuss the responses under the headings adopted by the survey instrument that is presented in Ridley (2006).

Relative size of IS presence

Students undertaking strongly identified IS undergraduate degrees can be found only at the UNSW. The UTS has an IT degree with IS as an ‘equal’ component, and a cross-faculty business/computing degree. These universities also offer a variety of majors in non-IS programs. This format—majors in other programs—is the bread and butter of IS in all the other universities. The size of the IS presence therefore depends on the university’s enrolment in the core programs that offer the majors and the extent of compulsory subjects in those programs. Large accounting programs mean that many students will need to do IS and larger staff numbers are entailed. With more than 1000 students in commerce at the University of Sydney, a larger IS unit is created.

Another characteristic is the fragmentation of IS academics across departments or faculties.

Administrative placement of IS

With the growth of enrolments in commerce in the past 20 years, there has been some advantage to those IS units that are placed in that faculty; however, a variety of locations, especially science and computer science, persist. Most IS groups remain as ad hoc or informal groups within larger departments.

Local contingencies

It is noteworthy that when asking participants about ‘local contingencies’, responses reflect ‘very local’ issues, such as organisational politics, nearby employers and competitors. There were no ‘NSW’ issues that came up—for example, Wollongong’s support from BHP, alternative perspectives at the UTS and the UNSW, or faculty rules at Sydney.

IS as a separate field

While the four universities highlighted had some structural recognition of IS as a separate field, it was held widely that this did not extend to the wider university communities. Indeed, the interviewees would be challenged to agree on a definition of IS that was mutually satisfactory. For example, the International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS) and the Australasian Conference on Information Systems (ACIS) were not universally agreed on as central conferences. The fragmented state of IS at Macquarie University (an ad hoc IS group in computing, an accounting IS group in accounting, information management taught in statistics and IS management in the management school) is symptomatic.

Distinctive IS curricula

The language technology emphasis in one group at the University of Sydney is the most distinctive. Support classes within commerce programs are possibly the least distinctive across universities. The UTS has systematically innovated with specialist programs over the years, especially at the Masters level. ‘Cooperative’ programs—that is, with an industrial training component—are offered only at the UTS and the UNSW.

Distinctive features of IS research

The IS group at the UNSW has been productive for a long period, particularly in quantitative aspects (some would describe this as software engineering). This emphasis has declined and qualitative research is growing there. Each group at the University of Sydney is pursuing independent research strategies, with the scam-detection project of Jon Patrick very large, although not labelled as IS. At the UTS, Igor Hawryszkiewycz leads a large continuing project on collaborative systems software, but few full-time IS staff are involved in this project. Ernest Edmonds’ new ‘creativity and cognition’ studio is under the IS umbrella, but works with computer scientists as much as with other IS academics. Large research projects in IS are otherwise few in number. Research activity tends to be fragmented and diverse.

Small research groups, especially of doctoral students, at the AGSM and Macquarie Graduate School of Management (MGSM) have existed without undergraduate programs to build the staff numbers to critical mass.

Perceptions of other universities

The founding roles of the UNSW, UTS and Sydney were recognised widely although there was also some recognition of interstate universities and researchers.