There is a body of knowledge that suggests that many of the characteristics of IS are consistent with those observed across emerging disciplines in the early stages of their development. For example, some of the characteristics that manifested themselves in the early evolution of management as a discipline have been seen more recently in the development of IS.
The framework proposed by Ridley (see Chapter 3) is based on two constructs: 1) the degree of professionalisation as a discipline, and 2) maturity as an academic discipline. Both are derived from Whitley’s theory of scientific change (1984a, 1984b).
The first construct concerns the degree of professionalisation of the discipline, which is expected to increase as the impact of local contingencies decreases. Where a discipline is not highly professionalised, local contingencies such as political pressures have a high impact. Consequently, the degree of professionalisation of IS can be indicated by the extent of variation in the nature of IS curriculum and research.
The second construct—maturity as an academic discipline—has two components: mechanisms of control, and a core body of knowledge. The framework proposes increasing maturity as a discipline being characterised by increased control and prestige, as well as increases in the core body of knowledge associated with the discipline. The core body of knowledge, in turn, is viewed as having four dimensions:
a common set of research and teaching methods and standards
a unique symbol system that allows the exclusion of outsiders and unambiguous communication between initiates within the discipline
a coherent set of key research and teaching topics
a set of laws, rules and evidenced guidelines—some form of theory base.