6. The information systems academic discipline in Queensland

Bob Smyth

School of Information Systems

Queensland University of Technology

Guy G. Gable

School of Information Systems

Queensland University of Technology

Abstract

Relative to its population, Queensland has a large number of universities, each of which is engaged in information systems (IS) teaching and research. As elsewhere, powerful external forces have wrought substantive change to the IS discipline in Queensland in recent years. The highly decentralised nature of Queensland has also had an enduring impact on the IS discipline in the state. Nonetheless, beyond several instances of adaptation to distance and decentralisation, the study reveals little evidence of a distinctive Queensland flavour of IS. Rather, there exists a diversity of curriculum approaches and an equally broad range of research foci and approaches to research. Two of the state’s regional universities are notable for the relative strength of their IS presence, in terms of the number of IS staff, the number of IS students and the range of campuses across which IS is taught. The breadth of topics and approaches to IS in Queensland is evidenced by the existence of separate, competing IS groups in two of the largest universities; in each case, one of the IS groups is highly technical in orientation while the other is business oriented. Across the nine Queensland universities there is wide variability in terms of the administrative location of IS academic staff in the university structure. The study assesses the state of IS in Queensland universities in relation to criteria indicative of the maturity of a discipline. Measured against these criteria, IS in Queensland universities cannot yet be considered a mature, distinct academic discipline. Profiles are presented of three people prominent in the development of the IS discipline in Queensland.

Table of Contents

Introduction
Purpose of the Queensland study
The research method
Theoretical framework guiding the study
The universities in this study
Relative size of the IS presence in Queensland universities
The administrative placement of IS in Queensland universities
Distinctive features of the IS curriculum
Distinctive features of IS research
Key figures who have influenced IS in Queensland universities
Vignette—Ron Weber
Vignette—Ed Fitzgerald
Vignette—Alan Underwood
The status of IS as a distinct discipline in Queensland
Review of findings
Limitations and future research
General findings from the Queensland study
References

Figure 6.1 Location of Queensland within Australia

Figure 6.1 Location of Queensland within Australia

Introduction

For the IS community world-wide, this is a period of great turbulence. In 2002, there was an unprecedented downturn in demand for information technology (IT) skills, resulting in a sharp decline in student entry to university IT courses. Information systems courses have been among those affected by the downturn. The impact of the decline in demand for IS skills has been heightened by the fact that, unlike engineering for example, IT had never previously experienced anything but continuing growth. Indeed, in the years leading up to the IT downturn the demand for skills had been overwhelming, fuelled by the dotcom boom and the perceived Y2K crisis.

After the drop in demand for IS courses, there has been a major re-examination of IS. Old insecurities about the status of IS as a separate academic discipline have emerged. In universities in Queensland, as elsewhere in the world, IS curricula have been re-analysed with a view to repositioning IS in response to the fall-off in student demand. The changes to IS curricula have been accompanied in some instances by administrative restructuring of IS academic staff, driven by the goals of rationalising and economising.

In Australia, proposed Commonwealth government policy on research in universities has also had a profound effect on the IS discipline. The Howard government’s proposed Research Quality Framework (RQF) caused IS groups in Australian universities to reassess academic staffing profiles and to reconsider research priorities.

In this setting of introspection and change, there is value in analysing IS in Queensland universities. From a position of soundly based understanding of the current status, and some feeling for how this status was arrived at, IS academics are better placed to plan to take advantage of emerging opportunities and to minimise the impact of identified threats to the IS discipline, to IS academics and to the programs of teaching and research guided by these academics. This chapter reports on such a study into the IS discipline in universities—in this instance, universities in the state of Queensland.