The administrative placement of IS in Queensland universities

Across the nine Queensland universities there is remarkable variability in the administrative location of IS academic staff in the university structure. Table 6.3 shows, first, the administrative entity with which the IS academics at that university are affiliated. It should be noted at this point that it is common to find academics involved with aspects of IS across a range of departments, schools and faculties in a given university—for example, health informatics in a health faculty, IS auditing in a school of accounting, and so on. In this study, data were collected only on groups who self-identified as teaching and/or researching IS in each university.

A feature of IS in Queensland universities (perhaps not distinctive to Queensland) is that from late 2004 to mid-2006, many of the IS groups had either just participated in restructuring or were about to begin a restructuring process. The CQU, Griffith, James Cook and USQ IS academics were about to begin a review process; Bond University IS staff members were involved in restructuring in June 2005 and QUT IS academics were in the midst of a restructuring. The downturn in demand for IT courses was cited as a major stimulus for restructuring.

It can be seen from Table 6.3 that five of the nine Queensland universities have IS academics in a separate school or department. A separate identity for IS might be associated with a higher level of academic control by the IS academics and with a higher level of prestige for the IS group. Interestingly, no two of these five universities use exactly the same terminology to describe their IS administrative entity. The remaining four universities—Bond, James Cook, the University of Queensland and the USC—have IS academic staff placed in administrative entities within other departments, schools or faculties. In these four instances, the administrative entities are identified as discipline groups.

Table 6.3 Administrative placement of the IS group in Queensland universities

University

Administrative entity

Home faculty

Australian Catholic University

School of Business and Informatics

Arts and Sciences

Bond University

Informal IS group within School of Information Technology

Business

Central Queensland University

School of Information Systems

Informatics and Communications

Griffith University

School of Information Communications and Technology/informal IS group in School of Management

Engineering and Information Technology/Business and Law

James Cook University

Informal IS group in School of Business

Law, Business and Creative Arts

Queensland University of Technology

School of Information Systems

Information Technology

University of Queensland

Information Systems Cluster in Business School; Data and Knowledge Engineering Division in School of Information Technology and Electrical Engineering

Business, Economics and Law/Engineering, Physical Sciences and Architecture

University of the Sunshine Coast

Information Systems Discipline Group in Faculty of Business

Business

University of Southern Queensland

Department of Information Systems

Business

In turn, the ‘home’ faculty for each IS group also shows some variability across the nine Queensland universities. At James Cook, Bond, USC and USQ, the home or parent faculty for the IS academics is business (or some variant of that title). At QUT, the home faculty for IS academics is a Faculty of Information Technology. Griffith University and the University of Queensland are distinctive in two respects in relation to the administrative placement of their IS academics: first, both universities are characterised by two separate IS groups. At Griffith, the smaller of the two groups is within the School of Management in the Faculty of Business and Law. The second, and larger, IS group at Griffith University is distinctive in being administratively alongside engineering, in a Faculty of Engineering and Information Technology. At the University of Queensland, the larger of the two IS groups is in the Business School, while the second IS group, somewhat akin to Griffith, is within a School of Information Technology and Electrical Engineering. The placement of the IS group at the ACU within a Faculty of Arts and Science appears anomalous until it is observed that ACU has only three faculties, the other two being health and education.

In terms of independent status for IS groups in Queensland universities, there is evidence of two contradictory trends. On the one hand, at such universities as the CQU, Griffith and QUT, IS academics have moved into separate, identifiable schools of IS. On the other hand, at the USQ, a separate School of Information Technology, formed in 1990 to include IS and computer science, was broken up in 1993, with IS returning to the business faculty. Similarly, the Faculty of Information Technology at Bond University, which incorporated the IS group (and computer science), was disbanded in June 2005, with all IT being absorbed into the Faculty of Business as a new School of Information Technology. Thus, while some IS groups have been moving out of business faculties in Queensland, others have been moving back into business. The moves cannot be linked easily to broad outside forces; while the movement to business at Bond seems clearly linked to the decline in demand for IT, at the USQ the move back to business occurred at a time when IT demand was booming.

Sherer (2002) asserts that the theoretical basis of the discipline and the curricular needs of the professional community influence the organisational placement of the IS group. The assertion seems most plausible. If we assume that the theoretical basis of the discipline and the perceived curricular needs of the local community are two significant determinants of the administrative placement of IS groups, it is possible to make inferences about these factors from the differing placements in universities across the state. These inferences can provide useful insights regarding the maturity of IS as a distinct academic discipline. The administrative placement of the IS group is significant in relation to the acquisition, by the IS group, of mechanisms of power—a prerequisite for maturity of a discipline within the Ridley framework. This matter of the maturity of the discipline is analysed in a later section of the report.