Review of findings

While the study pointed to a considerable diversity in IS across the nine universities in Queensland, there was little evidence of sharply different ‘philosophies’ of IS, as was reported from a survey of IS in 18 European countries (Avgerou et al. 1999). The European study had, for instance, highlighted the strong socio-technical stance of the Scandinavian countries, in contrast with a pragmatic technical emphasis in German universities. In the curricula and research emphases of the Queensland universities there was evidence of an eclectic melding of the various European and American approaches. Only at the University of Queensland and at Griffith University—both of which maintain two strong IS groups, one ‘technical’ and the other ‘business-focused’—is this blending of approaches to IS not in place in a single administrative unit.

In relating the Queensland data to Ridley’s (2006) framework for assessing the maturity of IS as a discipline, it has to be said that the evidence from Queensland universities does not fully support IS being recognised as a mature discipline. Certainly, the data suggest that the IT field in Queensland is characterised as being subject to the high impact of local contingencies. According to Ridley’s framework, this characteristic is typical of a field lacking a high degree of professionalisation.

Ridley’s first criterion for maturity as a discipline—that those in the discipline have a high level of control, associated with the potential for prestige and power—would appear to be met at least partially. At several of the Queensland universities, where senior IS academics are recognised by their universities as Professor of Information Systems, these individuals are recognised, by virtue of their achievements in IS, as warranting the same prestige and decision-making power in the university as their colleagues in long-established disciplines. Similarly, the control that comes with increased autonomy is evident in many Queensland universities, where IS academics have significant control over resources, IS curriculum content and IS research.

In relation to the second maturity criterion—that there should be evidence of a core body of knowledge for that discipline—the Queensland data indicate that no such clear core body of knowledge is identifiable. Information systems curricula are very diverse across Queensland universities, as are IS research topics and methods. Further, as reflected in debate within the wider IS community, there is little evidence in Queensland (or elsewhere) that IS yet possesses the ‘theory base’ that is also among Ridley’s indicators of discipline maturity. Again, in relation to Ridley’s criterion of a unique symbol system that allows the exclusion of outsiders and unambiguous communication between initiates within the discipline, there is limited evidence from the data to suggest that IS academics in Queensland share such a common unique symbol system. The wide variability in curriculum content and research foci would alone argue against this unique basis for communication among the IS academics.

In summary, the features of the IS activities observed in Queensland universities have much in common with features reported by Whitley (1984a) in relation to the early stages of the development of management as a discipline area viz.

Whitley uses the term ‘fragmented adhocracy’ to describe this immature stage of the development towards a distinct discipline.

The existence in each of two Queensland universities of separate IS groups, under the administration of different faculties and with quite different curricula and research foci, highlights the relative immaturity of the IS discipline in Queensland. Nonetheless, evidence of recent collaboration and cooperation between these previously rival IS groups suggests progress in this pursuit of discipline maturity.