In conducting this Queensland study, there was recognition by the researchers of the intention to reflect on the procedures followed and the outcomes achieved; this and the other Australian studies were to inform subsequent, broader studies into the IS discipline. A similar study into the IS discipline in universities in the countries of the IS Pacific-Asia region is in progress, drawing to some extent on the Australian experiences. It is envisaged that similar studies of the IS discipline be carried out in other regions of the world. This might ultimately allow a useful global analysis of the discipline, highlighting regional similarities and differences.
A useful finding from the Queensland study relates to the approach to data gathering that was proposed in the study protocol. The intention was to have interviews with at least one key person from each university in the state as the prime source of data. These interviews were planned to take about one hour each. In the event, arranging face-to-face interviews at two of the Queensland universities proved impractical. For James Cook University and the ACU, telephone interviews were used, followed up with interview notes and other exchanges by e-mail between the researcher and the interviewees.
For future studies elsewhere, a revised study protocol has been prepared to accommodate telephone interviews. In addition, in recognition of the large time requirements for interviewing where there are many universities involved in the study, a survey instrument has been prepared as a substitute for each interview. The instrument attempts to provide some of the richness of an interview by minimising questions seeking specific numerical responses, in favour of questions teasing out the distinctive characteristics of the university. In recognition of a study environment in which, on the other hand, there are very few universities in the study, a guideline for conducting focus groups, based on the standard data-gathering framework, has been added to the study protocol.
The use of a theory framework to guide the data gathering and analysis, based on ‘the emergence of a discipline’, proved most helpful to conducting the Queensland study. It is envisaged that the Ridley framework will prove valuable to similar future studies.