It proved surprisingly difficult to obtain accurate figures for IS student numbers at the three universities—largely because statistics were not available for IS in isolation and therefore had to be extrapolated from combined computing or commerce student numbers. Table 7.2 summarises the ‘best guess’ numbers provided by each of the universities. For this reason, numbers in this study are reported as ‘students’, rather than effective full-time student load (EFTSL).
|
University |
No. of IS academics |
No. of IS students |
|---|---|---|
|
University of South Australia |
12 |
>1 500 |
|
Flinders University |
Not available |
Not available |
|
University of Adelaide |
3 |
>500 |
At the time the UniSA was founded, some members of antecedent organisations decided to form a School of Information Systems within the new Business Division. Some of these staff members came from the Institute of Technology, while others had previously been a part of the South Australian College of Advanced Education. One study participant commented:
We had all been in Business Schools teaching IS topics. We believed it worthwhile to have an IS concentration and develop the area academically as it was useful for the uni and the citizens of SA. At the time IS had quite a high profile. I was a founding member along with approx 21–23 others. We were the first and only School of Information Systems in SA. Flinders University had nothing in the way of IS and Adelaide University had one subject in Computing Science. We developed a range of undergraduate programs which [was] very well received.’
In 1996, the university reduced funding to the school, which resulted in staff cuts and redundancies. In 1996, there were cuts across the Business Division, and IS staff were advised that the annual budget had been reduced from $2.8 million to $1.8 million. The group had significant financial problems at the time, although it had developed a successful industry placement program with about 40 industry partners and earned a very positive reputation for its engagement with industry. At least one respondent (now retired) believes the group had a mixed relationship with the Division of Business from its inception, claiming there were several attempts to move the discipline out of the Business Division. In that year, the IS discipline group was moved into an accounting and IS school, which also included a group of staff from the administrative management area, which had originally taught secretarial studies and was slowly evolving towards a new focus on the management of corporate administrative functions.
In 2004, a review of the Division of Business resulted in the restructuring of all the schools within that division. This review, combined with a strategic university-wide decision to combine all computing-related disciplines into one school, led to the IS discipline as a whole being transferred to the School of CIS, located within the Division of Information Technology, Engineering and the Environment, which had existed for the life of the university and was already a very much larger school. This merger has resulted in a large and vibrant computing school, based on two campuses (and with teaching offerings on four campuses), with a wide variety of programs covering the full range from computer science through software engineering and IT to IS.
Although some respondents believe that the IS group is smaller and less visible as a result of this merger, it now has three full-time IS professors and one associate professor—in addition to two European adjunct professors who are also IS focused. The combined School of CIS launched a Bachelor of Information Systems for the first time in the history of the university after the merger, and all degree programs offered by the school were reviewed and completely revamped, with significant changes taking place in all degree offerings.
The merger also allowed the UniSA to rationalise the location of the IS staff. Before the move to CIS, the majority of the IS discipline staff (12 academics) were based in the School of Accounting and Information Systems at the City West campus, which comprised three discipline areas: accounting, IS and administrative management. Some of the IS courses (those with an ‘INFS’ prefix) were taught by administrative management staff, while some of the administrative management courses were taught by IS staff. These blurred lines of control had simply evolved over time, but were rationalised at the time of the merger.
During the merger discussions, 11 of the 12 IS academic staff agreed to move to the new school and one of the former administrative management staff joined the group moving to CIS. Before the merger, some five IS academics were located in the ‘old’ CIS at the Mawson Lakes campus in the north of Adelaide, and their courses became part of the revised degrees offered by the enlarged, combined school.
The majority of the IS teaching takes place at the City West campus of the UniSA, where most of the IS staff are still located, with some (predominantly graduate) IS courses also being offered at Mawson Lakes. A number of the largest IS courses are also offered face to face at the Whyalla and Mt Gambier campuses, as well as being taught offshore as part of the transnational degrees being offered in Hong Kong and Malaysia.
The school has an industry advisory group, which has been very supportive of IS programs and has an excellent reputation with local business and with the public sector.
There is one major similarity between IS at the Universities of South Australia and Adelaide: both universities (as is common around Australia) offer a major, first-year subject to students enrolled in a business or commerce degree. In the case of the UniSA, this subject has an average annual enrolment of approximately 2000–2500 students and is taught over nine separate delivery channels (on-campus/off-campus in Adelaide; through Open University Australia; on-campus in Whyalla and Mt Gambier; as a service teaching offering through the business colleges of the South Australia Institute of Business and Technology [SAIBT] and EBIT; and on-campus in Hong Kong and Malaysia). Running a subject of this size through so many varying delivery methods is a major logistical exercise and involves two academic staff members. A senior member of teaching staff oversees the subject and provides the face-to-face and video-taped lectures, while a more junior member of staff is occupied full time as course manager, coordinating the tutors and off-site lecturers, tutorial material and coordinating/overseeing student contact activities.
Since many of the students enrolled in this subject are taking an accounting degree, the syllabus is influenced strongly by the requirements of the CPA, which accredits the Bachelor of Commerce degree. Nonetheless, this subject is designed and taught by full-time IS academics, who ensure that it provides a thorough grounding in IS for all business students.
|
Undergraduate courses offered |
Postgraduate courses offered |
No. of students enrolled in IS subjects |
|---|---|---|
|
DBBI, DBEB, DBIN, DBIT, DBMS |
DCMI, DGEC, DGMI, DMEC, DMIS, DMMI, LMCT |
1 500 approx. |
The bachelor degrees identified in Table 7.3 are all IS focused—DBIN is a complete Bachelor of Information Systems degree, while the other three are business degrees with an IS focus. The postgraduate offerings vary from being entirely IS focused (for example, DMMI) to having a major IS focus.
Information systems is located within the School of Commerce at the University of Adelaide and is considered a separate discipline with its own head. With a staff of only three (including the discipline head), IS is focused largely on the core foundation course for the accounting and business IT degrees. We were unable to interview the head of the discipline, and one of the staff members had arrived in South Australia only for the start of the first 2007 semester. The other staff member has been teaching IS for the past three and a half years and was a PhD student at the University of Adelaide before that appointment.
The IS subject is accredited by the CPA as a core component of the commerce degree and therefore has a large undergraduate enrolment (more than 500 students). At postgraduate level, IS is offered in the form of a number of elective subjects, with a current overall enrolment of about 250, including five Masters students and one PhD student. The university does not offer any degree majoring in IS and IS is regarded as a supporting area to other disciplines.
Interestingly, there was a 30 per cent growth in IS numbers in the first semester of 2007, which staff attributed to a combination of the recent lowering of the Tertiary Entrance Requirement (TER) and the university’s status as a member of the Group of Eight. In addition, this growth reflects the increase in international students, particularly from China, studying IS.
Information systems at the University of Adelaide is of marginal status, reflected in the comparatively small number of staff and the lack of any IS degrees at either undergraduate or graduate levels. Although there is a compulsory IS subject for some degrees within the School of Commerce (generally for accounting students), its visibility as a discipline or field appears to be in decline at the University of Adelaide. Those teaching IS are strongly business oriented and are convinced of its supportive role within the school—and are not connected to the wider IS community, with the result that they are unaware of the discipline’s struggle for survival in other universities. Unfortunately, no information could be gathered relating to the history of IS at this university so it is unclear whether IS has played a more important role in the past.
The final section of this chapter focuses on influences and issues specific to IS within South Australia. Much of this material relates to activities at the UniSA, because IS at the University of Adelaide is predominantly service teaching for the accounting students and is therefore driven by the needs of the accounting profession and its accreditation practices.