South Australia has very few corporate head offices; instead, it has a number of very innovative and successful smaller businesses working in the ICT sector. Even EDS, which had a sizeable representation in Adelaide under the former government (having won a contract to handle all government ICT outsourcing), has now ‘right-shored’ its South Australian operations to a significant extent, after the current state government’s change of its outsourcing policy to one in which government ICT activities are outsourced predominantly to interstate and offshore companies. The lack of a single minister responsible for ICT activities in the state (South Australia has six ministers who share the various aspects of the ICT field) has also helped to create an unusual profile for IS in the state—with many IS activities focused on the activities of imaginative and innovative small companies in such areas as computer gaming, defence or consultancy.
The major ICT group within South Australia is, of course, the defence industry. The decision to build ‘smart ships’ (air warfare destroyers) in Adelaide has bolstered the existing activities of many high-tech defence companies, which had been working with ASC (formerly the Australian Submarine Corporation) on the development of the Collins-class submarines.
Although the curriculum is naturally affected by industry requirements, IS academics also endeavour to provide industry leadership, rather than simply responding to industry demand.
Local demand does affect IT and IS teaching structure within the state, particularly in terms of content, because students must have certain skills to be employed by local and interstate businesses. It is, however, probably no more affected by industry than other applied disciplines, such as tourism or oenology.
The UniSA has made significant structural changes that affect the teaching of IS—specifically, the move of the IS group from the School of Accounting and Information Systems within the Division of Business, to the School of Computer and Information Science within the Division of Information Technology, Engineering and the Environment. This has enabled the development of a Bachelor of Information Systems degree (IS was formerly offered only as one alternative within the Bachelor of Business degree). As it is the only university in South Australia offering IS degrees, there is little (if any) political pressure on the school to provide any particular offerings, although the BBIS/MBIS program (a funded joint program with industry, which takes high performers and fast-tracks them via a combined academic/industry placement scheme) has had an influence on academic outcomes, as most of the brightest students choose this alternative in place of doing an Honours degree.
Like all other Australian states, South Australia has suffered from the ICT downturn in terms of local student numbers. Employment in South Australia in the ICT industry is particularly difficult because of the lack of large corporate head offices (the majority of which are still located in Sydney or Melbourne), and the current state government’s decision to outsource major ICT developments to interstate and/or international companies has made this situation still more difficult. Many South Australian graduates are forced to seek work in other states, so that we are probably suffering more from the downturn than any other state in the sample. Recent moves to source staff for major Commonwealth government projects from South Australia are, however, likely to have a positive impact on student placements and have been welcomed warmly.
Recent events, such as the large defence contractor presence in South Australia and the South Australian government’s memorandum of understanding with the defence studies arm of Cranfield University and the public policy and ICT programs of Carnegie Mellon University have the potential to be advantageous to all South Australian IS programs.
The status of IS within the School of Commerce is complex and contradictory. Staff were unaware of funding issues affecting IS and did not feel its status was inferior to that of any other discipline within the school, with one member commenting, ‘Status is what you make it. You have to earn it.’ Information systems is not, however, listed as a separate discipline on the university web site under the School of Commerce and appears only as a separate area when conducting a search of staff and contacts within the school. Although one staff member definitely considered IS a discipline rather than a field, he was also keen to emphasise that IS was only a supporting course of management, accounting and marketing.
The location of IS within the School of Commerce appears to be unproblematic. The CPA broadly controls its curriculum and there is therefore little opportunity for substantial debate or change in its structure and content. It would appear that IS at the University of Adelaide confirms the view of IS as fragmented and lacking a ‘set of shared assumptions and language’ (Hirschheim and Klein 2006:94), which has led to its virtual dissipation within the School of Commerce.
In contrast, IS at the UniSA has a long and rich history originating from its development as part of the Graduate School of Management, through to its current incarnation in the School of Computer and Information Science. This reflects IS as a dynamic field, with a flexible identity referencing a plethora of academic disciplines (Markus 1999; Galliers 2006; Robey 2006). The shift in IS from the School of Business to the School of CIS signifies what Lyytinen and King (2006) refer to as a ‘market of ideas’ where free-flowing views regarding the management of information and affiliated technologies are exchanged. Instead of IS being fixed rigidly in its curriculum and research practices, it is positioned ideally as a more fluid concept capable of adapting to change and keeping abreast of industry.
In its former existence as part of the School of Accounting and Information Systems and in its current existence as part of the School of CIS, IS at the UniSA has been a component of a larger school; it has been many years since there was a School of Information Systems at the UniSA. To a large degree this can be traced to the comparative lack of local student interest in IS; the fact that neither the University of Adelaide nor Flinders University even bothers to offer IS at all provides further evidence for this atypical lack of interest, which pre-dates the current IS student crisis. This is in stark contrast with the West Australian situation, where all four of the universities offer an IS degree and see IS as an area of strategic importance. Since these two states have a number of common features (distance from the east coast ‘power base’ and a strong focus on the resource and agriculture sectors, for example), it is curious that such a markedly diverse attitude to the importance of IS has arisen over such a long period.
The move from the Business Division to the Division of Information Technology, Engineering and the Environment forced the UniSA IS group to think very carefully indeed about the composition of its degrees. The School of CIS went through a complete degree restructuring in 2004–05 and now has an entirely new suite of offerings right across the field of computing: CS/SE/IT/IS. This exercise also required the school to distinguish its offerings very carefully from those of administrative management, which teaches some of the material offered by the IS discipline in other universities; so awareness of the specific role of IS in the computing spectrum is probably focused more finely at the UniSA than it is at other universities.
Research in the IS domain is led by the three IS professors and their research groups (laboratories), as the majority of the other IS staff have still to complete their doctorates. The foci currently include requirements engineering/computer-supported cooperative work (CSCW) and electronic business/business information management, which are wide enough to include any members of staff interested in becoming involved in the Information Systems Laboratory (InSyL).
In terms of winning Australian-based competitive grants, it is obviously much more difficult for IS academics than for computer science academics in Australia—especially since the creation of National ICT Australia (NICTA), which absorbs the lion’s share of Australian IT research funding.
The School of CIS endeavours to provide a suite of offerings that covers the entire computing spectrum, from computer science right through to IS. Degree programs therefore—at undergraduate and postgraduate level—offer a wide range of options. The school provides significant incentives for teaching and research; indeed, the School of CIS at the UniSA is well above average in terms of providing incentives for research.
The newly developed Bachelor of Information Systems is a broadly based degree, with specialisations possible in a variety of more finely targeted areas. At the graduate level, the school offers conversion Masters degrees, which are extremely popular with international students, as well as an advanced Masters degree in IS. It is also developing a range of double degrees, with the Business Division in areas such as accounting and marketing, and with the Health Studies and the Education, Arts and Social Sciences Divisions. Identifying niche markets is a major focus of IS strategic planning and is likely to become increasingly important over time.
A major new venture has been the industry-funded Chair of Business Information Management, which was established within the school at the start of 2006. Funded by State Records of South Australia, Fuji Xerox and the State Library of South Australia—and with significant support from the UniSA itself—the chair has been funded to provide an entirely new approach to education and research opportunities for the management of corporate information in the twenty-first century. The four partners are aware that the previously separate disciplines of library management, preservation, records and archival management and ICT are becoming increasingly intertwined. The sponsors have funded the development of a suite of new degree programs (a graduate certificate that began taking students in the first semester of 2007, and a graduate diploma and Masters beginning in 2008) to provide a holistic approach to the understanding of the impact of all these areas on the management of business information.
The CPA accreditation means that major changes of content are rare and have to be approved by the CPA. Nevertheless, minor changes are made each semester to reflect technological developments and any variance in practice, with the proviso that there must be sufficient available literature to support these changes. This focus meant that IS staff believed firmly that IS belonged in the School of Commerce, rather than in the computing area. Although IS is also offered as part of a computing degree at the University of Adelaide (and there is sufficient overlap in content to award credit should a student wish to study in the School of Commerce), IS is perceived as relating primarily to management and the use of systems to meet business needs, rather than being focused on technical elements, which staff associate with computing. They do not regard IS as having its own terminology, seeing this as a ‘bridge’ between business and computing.
There is a paucity of local funding for research in any area of computing within South Australia, although the three universities work fairly well together and have created some highly successful technical joint ventures (for example, the SACITT group and the SABREnet initiative; see http://www.sabrenet.edu.au/ for details). With IS playing such a minor role in the state, obtaining funding for any research activities has proven extremely difficult (although, as noted a little later in this chapter, individual academic staff members have been able to build up highly successful one-to-one relationships at various levels of state and local government and therefore obtain focused funding for specific projects).
The ‘branch office’ status of Adelaide means that developing strategic relationships with private-sector companies is also very difficult. Most university partner companies must refer all decisions to their head offices—usually located in Sydney or Melbourne. Research partnerships with industry therefore tend to be focused on innovative small to medium-sized enterprises, rather than on the larger companies, which generally form the bulk of the partners for universities in other states.
Given the current lack of funding at the state and federal levels (with NICTA absorbing almost all the federal ICT funding, it is increasingly difficult to obtain government funding for IS within Australia at all), other avenues of research funding clearly need to be found. Industry support has been the logical place to look, together with less obvious sources of government funding (targeted funding of one sort or another).
The School of CIS has a very large PhD student population of approximately 60 students, 20 of whom are specifically IS students. As is the case in so many Australian IS schools/departments, lack of sufficient numbers of PhD supervisors is a limiting factor. Qualified supervisors therefore tend to take on the maximum number of PhD students permitted by university regulations. This lack is, however, slowly becoming less critical, with a number of PhD graduates obtaining teaching positions within the school and taking on supervisory roles themselves. This has been especially beneficial within individual research laboratories, as newly qualified staff members expand the supervisory capacity and the laboratories’ ability to develop grant applications.
The school has one major research ‘centre’, which is funded by the university to support research activities, the Advanced Computing Research Centre (ACRC), which, in turn, supports a number of research ‘laboratories’ (the term is taken from MIT’s approach to grouping researchers). Inevitably, there is some overlap between the activities of many of these laboratories, but two of them are primarily IS focused: the Information Systems Laboratory (InSyL), a solely IS-focused ‘broad church’ group; and the Strategic Information Management Laboratory (SIML), which has a strong interest in IS. There are two further laboratories—Health Informatics and Enterprise Security—which have at least a partial IS focus, as well as some interaction with the IS discipline group. Table 7.4 summarises the research foci of the two major IS research groups.
|
School of CIS Information Systems Research Laboratory foci |
|
|---|---|
|
InSyL |
SIML |
|
Socio-organisational systems |
Data acquisition |
|
Business information management |
Data quality |
|
Education |
Interoperability standards |
|
E-business/e-commerce |
Knowledge management |
|
Decision support and knowledge management |
Data warehousing and data mining |
|
IS methodology |
Data security |
InSyL (Information Systems Laboratory). The Information Systems Laboratory focuses on the impact of IS within organisations and society more broadly. Established in 2005, InSyL investigates the implications of ICT innovations and the ways in which organisations and individuals might capitalise on them. Some of the issues being researched include the digital divide, e-business innovations and business models, requirements engineering, evaluation methods, e-learning, creativity, nomadic computing and e-health.
SIML (Strategic Information Management Laboratory). SIML researches areas relating to information management in contemporary business. Major areas of research currently under investigation centre on data-quality issues and asset management. Industry partners include SA Water, the Defence Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO), the Centre for Integrated Engineering Asset Management and cooperative research centres.
Staff are aware of the marginal status of IS within the School of Commerce, yet do not feel its effects personally. Their perception is that they are able to pursue their own areas of research interest without funding pressures influencing the direction of that research. Like most academic staff in any institution, however, there is a constant pressure for research output, with one member describing his daily duties as a constant ‘juggling act’ between research, teaching and administrative work. This pressure, combined with his relative inexperience, might explain his lack of appreciation of the status of IS within the university and across the theoretical debates within the IS discipline more broadly.