The next section sets out the extent to which IS was believed by the survey participants to be impacted on by local contingencies at the UTAS.
The multi-campus operation of the university within Tasmania, and the associated delivery of IS in those three centres, was seen to have come about, at least in part, by the influence of Tasmanian politicians. A participant referred to the difficulty in adjusting the staff profile to student demand, which varied by campus, and balancing this issue and others due to funding pressures.
Course advisory committees were another way that local perspectives had impacted on the courses in the past. These committees, which met irregularly, were established for the IS programs when the School of Information Systems began in 1997. Although course advisory committees had provided feedback on the curriculum of the Bachelor of Information Systems and Honours programs, they did not influence their design or development significantly. The Master of Information Systems (MIS) program was, however, designed and introduced as a response to demand for graduate professional development in IS from the Tasmanian state government. The MIS Course Advisory Committee played a significant role in the curriculum and delivery modes for that program between 1997 and 1999. In contrast, the Bachelor of Information Systems degree curriculum was influenced strongly by the broader issues of national published curricula, which included IS’95 (Longnecker et al. 1995) and the Information Resources Management Association (IRMA 1996).
Another study participant commented on a need for greater involvement of course advisory committees in more recent years to update the curriculum, but noted the introduction of logistics to the undergraduate curriculum in the past few years as a response to external demand. Two other respondents saw little evidence of the school’s curriculum responding to local external factors. One of these participants noted, however, that the school had responded to international demands in a considerable way, making reference to how the curriculum had changed to accommodate Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (DIMIA) requirements and those of the international market.
The nature of the IS programs varied considerably, depending on location. Traditionally, the majority of the school’s students were located in Hobart, while Launceston had the second-largest proportion of students. Few students were based in Burnie, and it has not been possible to complete an undergraduate IS degree there. Since the school started to deliver IS into Shanghai, however, the distribution of students by campus changed dramatically. For example, as of November 2005, 75 per cent of the total EFTSU of 800 (1010 students) of the School of Information Systems were international students. Although some of the international students studied onshore at Tasmanian campuses, 61 per cent of the school’s total EFTSU were enrolled offshore in China. A total of 59 per cent of the school’s EFTSU were enrolled in a Bachelor of Information Systems degree in Shanghai, while 38 per cent were enrolled in a range of programs in Hobart, which are listed in Appendix 8.1. All graduate programs were delivered onshore, although for the first time in 2006 students from the first cohort to graduate with a UTAS undergraduate degree from Shanghai undertook an IS course-work Masters degree based in Hobart.
In recent years, the teaching has become more centralised into the Hobart campus. A limited number of units were offered at Launceston, and fewer were available at the Cradle Coast Campus. Increased use has been made of video-conferencing and other electronic means of delivery into Launceston and the Cradle Coast Campus. The teaching focus within an individual unit did not, however, vary by campus. No Honours or Masters programs were offered in centres outside Hobart, although they had been offered in Launceston in past years.
Since the School of Information Systems was first established, emphasis had been placed on consistent teaching across the campuses, and moderation of assessment across the multiple campuses in Tasmania. This aim was achieved by using a single point of course development for each unit, while employing teaching teams that operated across all campuses. Moreover, either single points of assessment were utilised for each unit or team marking was used that spanned the centres. Although some divergence in delivery modes and assessment occurred in Shanghai and Fuzhou since the IS programs were introduced there in 2003, very similar content had been retained in all units across all centres.
The research program has not been controlled centrally within the school, resulting in some variation in the nature of the research conducted within Tasmania. For example, there were few common topics between researchers in recent years other than an interest in e-commerce. This interest was seen by one participant to be related to the era rather than a consciously adopted focus. Another participant made reference to an early emphasis on e-commerce in the School of Information Systems, from a curriculum and a research perspective. The same participant identified the establishment of the Tasmanian Electronic Commerce Centre, originally located within the School of Information Systems in Hobart, as a driver for this emphasis. A comment was made about a perceived need to focus on fewer research areas.
A decision to emphasise qualitative research methods taken in the past was still apparent in 2005, with most Honours and PhD projects using qualitative techniques. In the same year, however, the school in the centres outside Tasmania undertook no research. One participant commented that the UTAS did not have a distinct research identity, while several references were made to the need for a greater research culture in the school. This influence and others were seen to act against the development of research collegiality, which also hindered research. Many staff members were early career researchers who were still working towards completing their PhD or gaining expertise and recognition within their research area. Other participants referred to the lack of qualified supervisors available in the school, and the situation in which one or two staff members supervised relatively large numbers of PhD students—in particular, Dr Paul Turner. The appointment of staff members who had studied within the school led to an emphasis on one research method, which was seen as problematic by one participant.
Another local contingency to act on research undertaken by the School of Information Systems was the funding obtained by Senator Brian Harradine and used in part to set up the Telstra Broadband Laboratory. The laboratory became the focus of some of the school’s research for a period. One participant referred to the proposal to amalgamate all faculty research in a single school, while another participant pointed to the role of the Faculty of Business in identifying research areas. The appointment of the Woolworths Chair in Information Systems in 2004 was described as a consequence of political pressure on the state government to relax shop trading hours.
Other evidence was provided for the way the nature of research conducted in the school had been influenced by local contingencies. One participant pointed to the advantages of researching in a state capital with a small population. Several references were made to the range of local industry contacts that the school drew on, with many student projects based within the community. The small size of Tasmania had resulted in federal and state government agencies being relatively easy to access. In the past, both tiers of government were supportive of research that used their organisations for data collection. As a consequence, the School of Information Systems focused on applied projects with relevance to the industry and government bodies that participated in such research. As another example, the limited number of large private-sector organisations in Tasmania had directed research efforts to the small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and public-sector environments. The minimal extent of manufacturing carried out in the state had also acted to limit research undertaken through the school in this setting.
Finally, it was claimed that IT was more likely to be dealt with by accountants in the state rather than by senior IT staff, while greater use of consultants and outsourcing in Tasmania was reported. All three of the last characteristics were seen to impact on research undertaken in the School of Information Systems.
A degree of divergence was seen in the views of participants on whether IS was affected by local factors to a greater or lesser degree than for other disciplines at the UTAS. Several participants saw IS being affected by local factors to a similar extent as the other disciplines within the university, while another commented that little attention was paid to all computing-related disciplines.
Two participants commented that in comparison with other disciplines at the UTAS, the volatility of the IS discipline meant that there was a greater need to maintain the currency of the curriculum and to give students access to current technology, which had resource implications.