IS as a separate field

This section considers the extent to which IS has been identified as a separate field at the UTAS.

The extent to which IS has a separate identity

The introduction of IS within the Department of Computer Science at the UTAS was an initiative of Dr Michael Rees. After his departure, Dr (later Professor) Chris Keen took over the role of IS advocate. Since then IS has had a separate identity in the Faculty of Business, and communication with Computing has been reduced, which, according to one participant, has been to the loss of both schools.

Although IS at the UTAS was seen by the participants to have a separate identity, this characteristic had taken more than 10 years to achieve. Information systems has been acknowledged formally as a single field of study and research within the university since January 1997, with the formation of the School of Information Systems. From about 1994, IS was associated mainly with a group operating within the Department of Computer Science at the Hobart campus. Towards the end of that year, IS was identified formally as a distinct teaching field within the Department of Computer Science. There was, however, also a smaller IS teaching and research group within the Department of Applied Computing at Launceston. Referring to the time in which IS was establishing itself at the UTAS, a participant who had been associated with the school for many years commented that most discipline areas at the university were unclear about the nature of the field. Another participant now employed outside Tasmania saw relevance as the key for survival where confusion existed about the nature of the discipline, and where opportunities and the professional community were small.

Distinguishing IS from business and computer science

In 1996, extensive discussion occurred between the staff of the proposed School of Information Systems and what were at that time the departments of Computer Science and Applied Computing. A participant reported that teaching and research topics were readily grouped into those suggested at that time by the Australian Computer Society (ACS). The topics were divided into the technical aspects of computer programming, software engineering, networking, computer systems engineering and computer science, and for IS, the business and social aspects of the application of information and communications technology (ICT). The same distinction largely continued until 2008.

In general, until recently, the participants saw computing and IS as having different perspectives, with limited communication between the two disciplines; however, they saw less to distinguish IS from business, with IS being concerned with the management of IT and not as broadly based as business. The IS units offered limited technical content, which was found in the School of Computing. One participant saw pressure on computing schools to shift towards IS teaching areas, in response to falling student enrolments. As evidence of this claim, database management has been introduced by the School of Computing in some units in recent years, delivered by their own staff members. One participant saw the demise of service teaching to be partly responsible for this last development.

One participant pointed to current pressures that act against IS groups continuing as independent schools at the UTAS and elsewhere, foreshadowing the amalgamation of IS with computing at the UTAS in early 2008.

Comparative status of IS academics

Four participants believed that IS academics had a similar status to business and computing academics at the UTAS. A comment was made that while IS and business academics had the same status, academics from schools situated within the Faculty of Science and Technology had higher status, due to the better research profile in that faculty at the university—the School of Computing was located in the Faculty of Science and Technology at the UTAS. Another participant, however, compared the size of the Schools of Computing and Information Systems when considering the status of each. The Schools of Computing and Information Systems had similar EFTSU numbers as of late 2005, with the former being the third-largest school and the latter the fourth-largest school in the university at that time. Finally, another participant considered IS academics to have a lower status than their colleagues in computing or management at the UTAS.

Comparative use of terminology

Most of the participants who responded to this question considered that IS terminology used at the UTAS would be broadly familiar to their business and computing colleagues. One person, however, believed that there was relatively little understanding of the conceptual base of IS among many staff in business. Another noted the limited contact between IS and computing staff before 2008, which, it was assumed, would make it difficult to assess the commonality in the terminology used by each group.